Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 80
inferno that eventually killed David Koresh and 80 of his followers, including 22 children.
The author provides a factual account of the Waco siege, which he acknowledges at the end
of the book. He does not provide any literature references or bibliography, however, the
book reads of his own investigation. The author does not imply conclusions or insights of his
own, but stays with providing information that he collected. His book is an accumulation of
evidence provided by ex-cult members, court and official documents compiled to tell the
story of David Koresh and the Branch Davidians. This book would provide a novice cult
reader with an exploration of how a cult is a danger to society and individuals. It does not
provide a critical analysis of the issues or factors that centered around the controversy of
what happened at Waco.
Kimberly Salow, BS, RSW
Therapist, Grad Student
Kalamazoo, MI
Understanding New Religious Movements. John A. Saliba. Grand Rapids, Mich.:
William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1995, 240 pages. Paperback, $18.00
ISBN 0-8028-4226-7
This is a book for students of the new religions that have sprung up amid the controversy
surrounding ―cults‖ since the early 1970s. The author, John A. Saliba, a Jesuit priest, is
professor of religious studies at the University of Detroit Mercy. He took part in a study of
new religious movements conducted for the Vatican, and he has written two major
bibliographies on new religious movements, Psychiatry and the Cults and Social Science and
the Cults. Saliba begins by giving the reader an overview of the cults in contemporary
Western culture followed by a history of new religious movements in the West. In separate
chapters he covers new religions in four perspectives: psychological, sociological, legal, and
theological. He finishes with a chapter on counseling as it pertains to the new religions. The
book has extensive footnotes and a useful index. The lower portion of the elegant front
cover shows a photo of the Branch Davidian Compound at Waco going up in flames.
Saliba is careful to define his terms. Cult proves especially problematical as he prefers ―new
religious movement.‖ Nevertheless, he uses cult throughout in its popular function to
indicate strange, extremist or non-orthodox Christian sects. In his overview Saliba relies
heavily on J. Gordon Melton‘s typology but recognizes that different scholars categorize the
same group in different ways. Although he attempts a balanced approach-and succeeds
remarkably in most of his presentation-Saliba tends to denigrate the ―anti-cult‖ camp.
History shows, he says, that the new religions repeat old patterns as he briefs us on
Gnostics, Cathars, Flagellants, Ranters, Mormons and the ever fascinating Shabbatean
movement of the seventeenth century. The modern anti-cult movement seems to him to be
a reactionary, clumsy if not unethical effort to suppress religious experimentation. This is
not to say that he is an ―apologist‖ for new religions.
Saliba offers studied overviews of the psychological, sociological and theological approaches
to new religions. He contends that the mental health ―experts‖ offer ―an overall negative
psychiatric assessment of new religions‖ (p. 83), but does a fair comparison of the
―brainwashing‖ verses the ―drift‖ models of conversion to cults.
Saliba is most comfortable with the sociological approach that attempts an evenhanded,
non-judgmental observation of facts surrounding new religions. He complains that anti-
cultists, the media, and sometimes the courts ignore the sociological research. ―The
sociological approach to the new religions is based on well-established academic principles
and, in spite of some weaknesses, has many advantages‖ (p. 129). In his chapter on the
law and cults, he tackles the thorny issues surrounding what constitutes a religion in the
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 81
United States. He cites the lengthy Scientology vs. IRS litigation as one example. He also
cites the lawsuit brought by the Local Church of Witness Lee vs. the ―anti-cult‖ group, the
Spiritual Counterfeits Project.
The final chapter, ―Counseling and the new religious movements‖ covers several forms of
therapeutic interaction with members of the cults, including deprogramming, exit counseling
and psychotherapy. Saliba points out that counseling professions assume that fringe groups
are dangerous institutions. Most counseling, he says, tends to be a strategy to attack the
new religion and persuade the cultist to leave it because it is a form of ―religious pathology‖
(p. 199). Again he decries the ignorance about sociological literature by anti-cultists:
―...sociology has provided a method for getting reliable information on the practices and
ideologies of these movements‖ (p. 201). He states that the first responsibility of counselors
should be ―to sift through the information on new religious movements and to present their
clients with a balanced picture...‖ (IBID.). He suggest that the client be alerted of any
dangerous situations ―without exaggerating or sensationalizing those relatively few
occurrences that are a cause for concern‖ (IBID.).
His advice follows sound counseling strategies that respect the client in every way.
Saliba‘s considerable effort to remain ―balanced‖ in his approach to new religions is
commendable but not without a serious flaw. He speaks of ―perception‖ many times and
how that can mislead people about the harmful nature of new and marginal groups. In this
we cannot disagree as rumors and panics about what a group may or may not do, or even if
it exists, are well-known in our recent history. Consider the ―satanic panics‖ of a decade ago
that have nearly faded away. But perception, not scholarly accounting, seems to guide his
reactionary stand against the ―moral crusaders‖ of the anti-cult ranks.
In a few patronizing passages he quotes from that camp to show that they too recognize
that some good can come from a cult experience, and that a calm, objective approach is
most useful in counseling.
Saliba takes issue with advice given by Madeleine Tobias (co-author of Captive Hearts,
Captive Minds) who suggests screaming in a car and fantasizing ―revenge‖ might help
relieve post cult-anxieties. ―The first suggestion is rather ridiculous, the second is conducive
to violence,‖ says Saliba (p.223). The perception he gives of Tobias‘s text is just as cranky
as the worst of anti-cult perceptions about new religions. Here Saliba echoes only what has
been previously written in a review (his) about Captive Hearts in the Journal for Scientific
Study of Religion (December, 1995). Saliba also states that exit counseling is only
deprogramming without coercion (p. 233), that it aims to persuade a cultist away from a
group while not examining objectively the facts of conversion and social issues surrounding
the conversion. He implies that exit counselors and deprogrammers attempt and succeed at
―brainwashing‖ their clients while turning them into ―moral crusaders‖ against all new
religions.
Two serious problems come to mind with this view: 1. While arguing that brainwashing is
hardly a fact-the vast majority of seekers leave their cults voluntarily, so where‘s the
brainwashing (p. 87)-he implies that the exit counselor is an effective brainwasher because
the majority of interventions work. 2. Saliba omits mention that a paucity of objective
research about deprogramming or exit counseling exists. To come to the conclusions he
does is merely a bias based on reactionary literature produced by scholars horrified by
deprogramming. One should agree with Saliba that coercive interventions cannot be
condoned as a general policy by any organization, but there is no reliable ―science‖ that has
analyzed the negative and perhaps positive effects of interventions of any kind. Non-
coercive exit counseling might be more than a mere deprogramming without security
guards, and the very anti-cultists he derides might be more sympathetic with his
recommendations for intervention counseling than he realizes.
Previous Page Next Page