Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 36
with a lemon on her hands. The church would not castigate her as having some sort of
spiritual problem because of this plight, would it?
If the same girl would go out and start attending a Bible study that later turned out to be a
Way ―twig,‖ then the Passantinos would put a spiritual twist on it, impugning her motives or
her spiritual state for leading her into a ―heretical‖ Bible study group. But if she buys a car
that breaks down, the Passantinos would, we suspect, hold her innocent. There seems to be
a double standard here.
One other point regarding the Wellspring statement quoted above by the Passantinos: by
broadly interpreting the statement, they have misrepresented us. The senior author of this
article [PRM] testified in the criminal case of a cult member who participated in the killing of
five people3. Martin and his colleagues in this case did not argue that the cult member was
innocent and need not feel guilt or shame. They argued that the young man was guilty. The
defendant was Danny Kraft, Jr., who had been a member of a small cult led by Jeffrey
Lundgren, who killed a family of five in Kirtland, Ohio.4 Nevertheless, in this case the
defendant‘s attorney maintained that although Mr. Kraft was guilty, there were mitigating
circumstances--namely, that Kraft was under the influence of Lundgren through a process of
mind-control. Therefore, Kraft was not acting entirely as a free, moral agent because he
was suffering from a mental disorder. In other words, Kraft was made to believe something
that was not true, namely, that Lundgren was the prophet of God, and, thus, whatever he
said was divinely inspired. The court unequivocally concurred that the techniques used by
Lundgren were those of mind-control. The court agreed that Kraft did indeed suffer a
dissociative disorder, identified by the DSM-III-R and DSM-IV as scientific. Kraft was
sentenced to many years in prison, but his sentence was lighter than it would have been
had mind-control not been seen as a mitigating circumstance.
The Passantinos attempt (p. 33) to strengthen their argument by quoting Hassan:
Hassan recognizes that the cult mind-control model (which he has adopted) is
incompatible with the traditional philosophical and Christian view of man as a
responsible moral agent: ―First of all, accepting that unethical mind-control
can affect anybody challenges the age-old philosophical notion (the one on
which our current laws are based) that man is a rational being, responsible
for, and in control of, his every action. Such a world view does not allow for
any concept of mind-control‖ (Hassan, 1988).
The problem here is that Hassan is simply wrong, and so is the Passantinos‘ attempt to
attribute Hassan‘s error to all advocates of the thought-reform model. First, our current
laws do recognize diminished capacity in the commission of crime as exculpatory, as it
recognizes undue influence in the civil arena. Second, the biblical worldview also recognizes
exculpation by reason of diminished capacity due to mental underdevelopment (Dt. 1:39)
lack of knowledge (Luke 12:36-48) or demonization (Mt. 8:28-34 Ac. 16:16-185). So,
neither Western, secular philosophy nor Judeo-Christian doctrine views man as always fully
rational and responsible for his actions. In addition, the apostle Paul writes, ―You foolish
Galatians, who has bewitched you?‖ (Gal. 3:1, New American Standard Bible). Translated,
the word ―bewitched,‖ baskaino, means ―bewitch, as with the ‗evil eye‘‖ (Bauer, Arndt, &
Gingrich, 1979, p. 137) and ―to bring evil on one by feigned praise or an evil eye, to charm,
bewitch one, hence, of those who lead away others into error by wicked arts.‖ (Thayer,
1972, p.98). It is doubtful that in the Galatians reference Paul is expressing belief that the
Christians actually had the ―evil eye‖ directed at them. However, in conjunction with the
word ―foolish‖ (anoētos =not thinking or mindless), it seems evident that Paul recognizes
that the Galatians had been manipulated to a point where they were no longer thinking
clearly. Thus, the concept of mind-control may apply to the situation described by Paul, or
at least to quantitative extensions of the Galatians‘ problem.
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 37
Assumptions Seven and Eight
We accept assumptions seven and eight as written, but reject what the Passantinos infer
from these assumptions: ―7. Religious conversion and commitment may be termed mind-
control if it meets certain psychological and sociological criteria, regardless of its doctrinal or
theological standards‖ and ―8. The psychological and sociological standards, which define
mind-control, are not absolute, but fall in a relative, subjective continuum from ‗acceptable‘
social and/or religious affiliation to ‗unacceptable‘‖ (p. 32).
The Passantinos conclude this section by saying, ―According to most cult mind-control model
advocates, no one is immune to the right mind-control tactics used at the right time.
Anyone is susceptible‖ (p. 32). After quoting Hassan, the authors quote from Martin‘s book,
Cult-Proofing Your Kids: ―But the truth of the matter is, virtually anyone can get involved in
a cult under the right circumstances ...Regardless of one‘s spiritual or psychological health,
whether one is weak or strong, cultic involvement can happen to anyone‖ (Martin, 1993, pp.
21, 179).
Claiming to state the views of mind-control model proponents, the Passantinos write, ―Cult
mind-control must be distinguished from ‗mere‘ deception, influence, or persuasion. A main
distinguishing characteristic at the core of mind-control is the idea that the individual
becomes unable to make autonomous personal choices, not simply that his or her choices
have been predicated on something false‖ (p. 32).
This paragraph again reveals the authors‘ fundamental misunderstanding of the model as
propounded by most of those who hold it. Mind-control advocates do not deny that cult
members make choices rather, the advocates assert that these choices result from a
systematic, intense, and prolonged program of ―deception, influence, [and] persuasion.‖
Mind-control is not something qualitatively different from deception, influence, and
persuasion because it subsumes all of these. It is an extension of these processes and
others (e.g., lack of information, fear of considering certain choices, and perceptual
narrowing due to dissociative processes such as prolonged singing, chanting, tongue
speaking, meditating, listening to charismatic speakers, etc.). This is a crucial point. It is
not either deception or mind-control. Mind-control involves deception and other processes
that affect making choices --that is, the cult member, and on occasion even the recruit, is
gradually manipulated to the point where other options are no longer considered viable.
Objection: The Brainwashing Connection
In a section entitled ―Objection: The Brainwashing Connection,‖ the Passantinos allege that
mind-control advocates demonstrate a ―contradictory embracing and rejecting of the
brainwashing connection‖ (p. 33). According to the Passantinos, mind-control advocates say
that the early methods of mind-control were ineffective compared to later methods, which
require less coercion and employ techniques like hypnosis. The Passantinos write:
―However, it stretches one‘s credulity to believe that what highly trained and
technologically supported CIA, Russian, Korean, and Chinese experts could
not accomplish under extremes of mental, emotional, and physical abuse,
self-styled modern messiahs like David Koresh (high school dropout), Charles
Manson (grade school dropout), and Hare Krishna founder Prabhupada (self-
educated) accomplished on a daily basis and on a massive scale with control
methods measurably inferior to those of POW camp torturers.‖ (p. 33).
However, the Passantinos‘ quotation from Hassan two paragraphs earlier (p. 33) responds
to this objection. Hassan points out that ―mind-control … is more subtle and sophisticated.
Its perpetrators are regarded as friends or peers, so the person is much less defensive. He
unwittingly participates by cooperating with his controllers and giving them private
Previous Page Next Page