Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 32
demonstrates that, despite the effectiveness of exit counseling in helping cult members
make a decision to leave their cults, exit counseling does not usually relieve the
psychological distress. This is not surprising because exit counseling is an educational
intervention designed to help clients reevaluate their group involvement, not to ―recover‖
from it. Consequently, a client‘s attending a residential treatment center after exit
counseling reflects not on the exit counseling‘s ineffectiveness, as the Passantinos imply,
but on the psychological needs of the client due to the aftereffects of cult involvement.
Recommending postcult counseling may be considered an ethical obligation of exit
counselors, not a sign of their inadequacy. Moreover, only a small percentage of exit-
counseled clients actually seek out residential postcult treatment.
All-or-Nothing Fallacy
In their book Witch Hunt, under the heading ―It‘s Not Always Either/Or,‖ the Passantinos
state: ―Another problem Christians often have in discerning between good and bad is the
tendency to miss some of the options‖ (Passantino &Passantino, 1991, p.113). Remarkably,
the article that concerns us relies on the all-or-nothing fallacy criticized by the Passantinos.
They suggest, for example, that all who subscribe to a mind-control model believe that
every cult member is completely under mind-control, and totally and always unable to think
for himself or herself.
No responsible researcher or practitioner subscribes to the mind-control model described by
the Passantinos. In Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism, Robert J. Lifton wrote:
Behind this web of semantic ...confusion [regarding the definition of thought
reform] lies an image of ―brainwashing‖ as an all-powerful, irresistible,
unfathomable, and magical method of achieving total control over the human
mind. It is of course none of these things, and this loose usage makes the
word a rallying point for fear, resentment, urges toward submission,
justification for failure, irresponsible accusation, and for a wide gamut of
emotional extremism (1961, p. 4).
In Cults in Our Midst, Margaret Singer and Janja Lalich write:
Thankfully, these [thought reform] programs do not change people
permanently. Nor are they 100 percent effective. Cults are not all alike,
thought reform programs are not all alike, and not everyone exposed to
specific intense influence processes succumbs and follows the group. Some
cults try to defend themselves by saying, in effect, ―See, not everyone joins
or stays, so we must not be using brainwashing techniques.‖ Many recruits do
succumb, however, and the better organized the influence processes used,
the more people will succumb (1995, p. 61).
In an essay entitled ―Persuasive Techniques in Religious Cults,‖ Dr. Louis J. West wrote:
The persuasive techniques used by totalist cults to bind and exploit the
members, while not magical or infallible, are sufficiently powerful and
effective to assure the recruitment of a significant percentage of those
approached, and the retention of a significant percentage of those enlisted.
(1989, p.188).
The Passantinos’ Assumptions of Mind-Control
In a section headed, ―Assumptions of Mind-control,‖ the Passantinos contrast biblical
apologetics with psychological techniques. The authors suggest that postcult recovery
should involve conversion, but that the secular mind-control model concerns itself only with
the recovery of precult personality. These two notions, the biblical and the secular, cannot
be reconciled, according to the Passantinos. They assert that mind-control adherents do
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 33
away with theological concerns: ―Biblical analysis and evangelism of the cults has been
overshadowed by allegedly ‗value neutral‘ social science descriptions and therapy-oriented
counseling‖ (p. 32). This all-or-nothing dichotomy is not characteristic of the program we
offer at Wellspring, nor that of many others.
The Passantinos list, summarize, and critique eight categories which they say represent ―the
principal assumptions of the cult mind-control model‖ (p. 32). Before addressing the details
of their critique, we want to state that the Passantinos‘ eight-assumption model is
inaccurate in so many respects as to be useless as a summary of mind-control models,
although aspects of their summary are valid. Our critique will attempt to show what is false
and what is correct in their analysis.
Assumption One
―Cults‘ ability to control the mind supersedes that of the best military ‗brainwashers‘‖ (p.
32). In a footnote, the Passantinos mention two factors offered by proponents of the mind-
control theory to account for cults‘ success: ―(1) greater levels of sophistication, technology,
and psychological knowledge and (2) the addition of hypnosis techniques to the practice‖
(p. 40). Not mentioned, however, is one factor we believe is perhaps more significant than
either of these two --namely, that in military brainwashing the subjects were unwilling
participants, and, in fact, antagonists of the brainwashers (at least in the most well-known
instance of the brainwashing of Korean War POWs) whereas in cultic mind-control,
generally the subjects are favorably disposed toward the cult members and, indeed, toward
the teachings with which they are being indoctrinated. This factor must not be ignored or
minimized. Moreover, the indoctrination of cult members is so subtle and deceptive that
they often do not even realize they are objects of persuasion, unlike POWs who were
painfully aware of their captors‘ desire to change them. So, it really is not at all surprising
that cultic mind-control is more successful than the ―brainwashing‖ inflicted on POWs. We
will elaborate on this point when we criticize the Passantinos‘ objection to the ―brainwashing
connection.‖
Assumption Two
―Cult recruits become unable to think or make decisions for themselves‖ (p. 32). This is
another example of all-or-nothing thinking, which the Passantinos have criticized in other
works. We reject the implied assertion that we and our colleagues in this field accept this
statement as it is written. We are well aware that many cult members do retain the ability
to think for themselves in many areas of life, even in matters religious. We have always
recognized that there are many degrees of mind-control, depending on numerous factors,
including, but not limited to (1) the type and severity of any precult spiritual or
psychological problems (2) the degree of divergence of the cult‘s teachings and practices
from the cult member‘s prior religious affiliation (3) the intensity of the cultic
indoctrination (4) the degree to which the cult severs the cult member from his or her
previous connections (family, friends, activities, etc.) and (5) the kind and degree of any
corrective or disciplinary measures exercised by the cult on members who step out of line.
Having said this, we hasten to add that during the 12 years of Wellspring‘s operation we
have worked with many ex-cult members who did have very serious difficulty thinking for
themselves and making decisions. Their problems cannot be glibly dismissed as ―precult
problems‖ that presumably had nothing to do with the cultic experience. One girl who came
to Wellspring from a well known ―shepherding movement‖ would sit at the dinner table and
wait until she received permission to eat any item on her plate before she would do so.
Assumption Three
―Cult recruits assume ‗cult‘ personalities and subsume their core personalities‖ (p. 32). This
statement conforms to clinical experience. For example, most ex-cult members who come to
Previous Page Next Page