Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 44
all of it, including the studies that point to the remarkable successes of some mind-control
efforts.
The Passantinos say, ―Some mind-control model advocates bring up studies that they feel
provide objective data in support of their theories. Such is not the case. These studies are
generally flawed in several areas: (1) Frequently the respondents are not from a wide cross
section of ex-members‖ (p. 37). First of all, invoking methodological purity is a common
ploy for avoiding the real issue in psychological discussion. Psychology is not nuclear
physics. It is rare to find fields in which all the relevant research uses representative
samples. That is why replication of empirical studies is so important and also why clinical
findings are respected, despite their limitations. These methodological problems are
compounded by ethical constraints on research (one cannot study the effects of trauma, for
example, by randomly assigning one group of subjects to a bus crash and another group to
a pleasant bus ride) that are especially applicable to the field of cultic studies. Nevertheless,
a growing body of empirical literature and a huge amount of clinical experience supports the
primary contention of mind-control advocates --namely, that cult involvement causes
psychological distress to many if not most cult members (Galanter, 1989 Langone, 1993
MacDonald, 1988 Martin et al. 1992 Yeakley, 1988).
The Passantinos also say that it is ―almost impossible to gather data from the same
individuals before cult affiliation, during cult affiliation, and after cult disaffection‖ (p. 37).
This is true, but it does not mean that psychological researchers are helpless. The same
problem existed with regard to the study of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among
Vietnam vets. There was no way to study them before they suffered PTSD yet some
excellent studies have been done using regression analysis (Winocur, Whitney, Sorenson,
Vaughn, &Foy, 1997).
Objection: Low Recruitment Rates
The Passantinos raise an objection to the mind-control model on the basis of ―low
recruitment rates.‖ They write:
Studies show that the vast majority of young people approached by new
religious movements (NRMs) never join despite heavy recruitment tactics ...
Eileen Barker documents that out of 1,000 people persuaded by the Moonies
to attend one of their overnight programs in 1979, 90% had no further
involvement. Only 8% joined for more than one week and less than 4%
remained members in 1981, two years later (p. 37).
In our opinion, the fact that almost 4% stayed in the group after one overnight program is
remarkable! That is amazing compared to Billy Graham‘s crusades in which only about 1%
of the attendees heed the altar call. And those who do heed the altar call return to their
families, jobs, and personal lives. They do not become full-time missionaries like the 4%
who join the Moonies after a brief workshop (Langone, 1993).
That the Passantinos seem impressed by Barker‘s finding reveals again their lack of
understanding of mind-control. No responsible mind-control advocate ever said that mind-
control is 100% effective on everyone, just as no doctor ever said that Tylenol is ineffective
because not everyone who takes it finds relief from headache. Are the Passantinos saying
that mind-control must be 100% effective in order to exist at all? Are they again shifting
from a presuppositional position, which says that mind-control cannot exist because people
can‘t lose their free will, to an empirical argument which says mind-control does exist,
people do lose their free will, but it doesn‘t work very well because only a very few people
succumb? What do they really wish to say?
Low recruitment rates demonstrate that a mind-control environment interacts with
idiosyncrasies within the person or his situation, not that mind-control does not exist. A net
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 45
will only catch fish bigger than the net‘s holes. If a majority of fish pass through the net
safely, one does not conclude that the net does not exist. Mind-control is defined by its
conditions, not its results, just as a net is defined by its structure, not how many fish it
catches. The power of mind-control is revealed in what it does to those whom it captures,
not by the number that it captures. Recruitment creates the opportunity for mind-control to
occur. Recruitment, though it may be very manipulative, is not necessarily, itself a full-
fledged mind-control program (Zablocki, 1997).
Objection: High Attrition Rates
The Passantinos‘ next objection is a corollary of the last --namely, ―high attrition rates.‖
The authors assert that the fact that many people who join cults eventually leave them
within a year or two without outside aid is ―deadly to the mind-control model‖ (p. 37). If
mind-control did exist, they imply, no one would be able to break its hold by himself. This is
a distraction. The issue is not whether there are high attrition rates or low conversion rates.
The issue is whether or not mind-control exists. We know of no professional who believes
that mind-control is 100% effective. On the other hand, an examination of history reveals
that when it is effective, indeed, it can be deadly. How else do we explain the mass suicide
of 912 people in Jonestown?9 A coincidental gathering of spiritually deceived individuals?
What kind of hold did David Koresh have over his followers that made them stay in the
building after the FBI started spraying tear gas into it? They had from about 6 o‘clock in the
morning till about noon to leave before the building finally caught fire. They could have left.
What kept them in there? What made one woman run back into the fire after she had run
out of the burning building? We could offer story after story of similar incidents. What led an
innocent boy from a small town in Illinois, Danny Kraft, to participate in the killing of a
mother, a father, a 13-year-old girl, an 11-year-old girl, and an 8-year-old girl? What led
the Nazis to gas Jews by the millions, and what led millions of Germans to pretend they did
not know what was going on?
The effects of mind-control can be diminished by numerous factors. One of them is how
conflicts and dissonance are dealt with. One young woman, describing her own voluntary
exit, said that every time she had a doubt or a misgiving about the group she would put it
on an invisible shelf so she wouldn‘t have to deal with it. But then one day, the shelf got
too heavy and caved in (Tobias &Lalich, 1994, p. 55). In other words, eventually there
were simply too many doubts and questions, and she was no longer able to ignore them
she had to deal with them.
Another factor that may weaken mind-control is a traumatic event that occurs in the cult
member‘s life or in the group as a whole. This could be a beating administered (or
threatened) by the leader or another member at the leader‘s behest. Haferd and Outlaw
describe one such incident involving Rose Watson Thomas, a member of an obscure group
named the Christian Alliance Holiness Church. They write:
Rose was terrified of what would happen when [an expected phone call from
the imprisoned leader] came through. Since the night before, the commune
residents had harangued her and threatened her with punishment. And she
had seen the punishment that Bishop Thomas [her father-in-law] meted out
to those who displeased him in his Christian Alliance Holiness Church-
merciless bloody beatings that left men and women with flayed skin on their
backs and flowing wounds for days afterward. This time, Rose felt sure, she
was going to be the one who would be beaten. She was sure the bishop‘s
next orders would deal with the punishment to be inflicted upon her. So Rose
had decided to take her son and run away from The Frontier [the cult‘s
compound in eastern Ohio] (Haferd &Outlaw, 1993, p. 5).
Previous Page Next Page