Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 68
Reported Quality of Personal Relationships
Table 4 shows the mean reported quality of personal relationships before, during, and after
CUT involvement. Paired-sample t tests across all relationships revealed higher ratings
before than during CUT involvement. In addition, all after ratings were higher than
corresponding during ratings. For spouse relationships, ratings were higher before and after
than during CUT involvement, and for other relationships, ratings were higher before than
after during ratings were the worst. In short, the reported quality of all relationships was
consistently worse during CUT involvement.
Discussion
This study investigated a sample not examined by previous research: former members of
CUT. It used the first, and as yet only, objective measure designed to assess the level of
group abusiveness, the GPA Scale (Chambers et al., 1994). A novel use of the instrument
made it possible to measure reported discrepancies between initial and post-involvement
perceptions of abusiveness, thereby assessing the extent to which individuals‘ interpretation
of events may have changed or to what extent misrepresentation on the part of the group
may have influenced their perceptions. Although the study used no comparison groups -a
design feature that may be regarded as a weakness --whenever it was appropriate and
possible, we made use of established normative values and comparative data from previous
research to evaluate the findings. They clarify the major four research questions posed
earlier.
Perceived Abusiveness and Deception
No previous study using the GPA scale has found mean values for the composite score and
each subscale score that were as high as those found here. The difference between the
overall GPA means for another cultic group, the BCC (Langone, 1995), and the CUT sample
exceeded two standard deviations. The overall GPA mean in the initial study (110.7), which
surveyed former members of 101 different cults, was only 2.2 points higher than the mean
score of the BCC sample (Langone, 1995). The present findings suggest that among groups
perceived as abusive by their former members, CUT is at the high end of reported
abusiveness. Even if sampling bias is taken into account and one assumes that the mean
score of former members who do not subscribe to the newsletter were two standard
deviations below that of subscribers, ex-CUT members‘ GPA means would be similar to
those obtained from former members of other allegedly cultic groups.
A comparison of retrospective GPA scores reflecting ex-members‘ recollections of their
perceptions when they first joined the group with their post-involvement perceptions
revealed profound differences (see Table 1). Several studies have investigated
retrospection biases (Marcus, 1986 for a review, see Dawes, 1988). These studies argue
that recollections of past beliefs are biased toward current beliefs. The large discrepancies
between retrospective perceptions and current perceptions of former CUT members suggest
that any such bias did not eliminate the differences found here. The perceptions these ex-
members remember having had at the time they joined CUT match the image CUT tries to
portray, which is clearly a nonabusive one. Respondents‘ current perceptions reflect a
highly abusive environment. If a retrospection bias toward current views operated in this
study, the retrospective scores were conservative. If we had been able to measure
abusiveness while respondents were actually joining CUT, the reported abusiveness might
have been even lower. Other studies suggest that peoples‘ investment (e.g., in time,
money, or emotion) in something biases them to exaggerate the differences between pre-
and post-involvement if there is an unconscious desire to justify the investment by viewing
the change as a positive one. In the present study, the change in perception was negative.
Thus, given the conditions and findings of this particular study, neither of these conclusions
offers an adequate explanation.
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 69
If false recollections are not a likely cause of the discrepancies between the two sets of
scores, one might conclude that CUT misrepresents itself and deceives its prospective and
current members. Support for this interpretation comes from the finding that the greatest
discrepancy between pre- and post-involvement was on the Mind Control subscale, and the
next greatest was on the Compliance subscale. These two subscales also showed the
highest post-involvement means, and each of them was near the highest possible score
(35) on the subscale.
Another possible interpretation for the discrepancies between GPA1 and GPA2 is that
individuals changed their interpretation of reality when they first came in contact with CUT
and then again when they left it. While a person is still in a cultic group and subscribes to
the group‘s interpretation of reality, he or she may not perceive abusive actions or attitudes
as abusive. Instead, a person may interpret what outsiders might consider being abuse as
a need to atone for past transgressions or deserving chastisement for imperfections. In
CUT terms, this is an individual‘s karma, and ―bad karma‖ may stem from past deeds of a
previous or several previous embodiments. This belief allows the leader to interpret current
events, including being abused, by attributing them to a past of which the follower may
have no knowledge and which may be impossible to verify. Additionally, if one subscribes
to the belief that ―God chastises those most whom he (or she) loves most,‖ abuse may be
interpreted as a privilege of ―the chosen.‖ A belief that a follower‘s devotion or
unquestioning commitment must be tested so that his or her spiritual attainment may be
assessed also provides a formidable tool to change the meaning of events. Clinicians who
are familiar with issues of domestic abuse may find interesting parallels between what is
referred to as mystical manipulation (Lifton, 1987, 1991) in a cult context and the mind
games with which victims of domestic abuse are manipulated.
The high discrepancies between GPA1 and GPA2 may also be attributable to individuals‘
changes in the interpretation of events that took place during the conversion process,
throughout involvement, and since exiting CUT, as well as misrepresentations on the part of
CUT. These explanations may be two sides of the same coin. To an outsider, a
reinterpretation of reality may appear to be deceptive (and not necessarily abusive), but to
the new recruit and long-term follower it may be a ―higher form of knowledge.‖ Former
members who have shed their pseudoidentity (West &Martin, 1994), however, are not
merely outsiders. Their personal experiences may cause them to view the former
interpretation of their realities as deceptive and abusive. They may often prefer even
stronger terms, such as spiritual betrayal.
The evidence of discriminant validity with respect to the GPA scores strengthens the
credibility of these findings. Moreover, we found no relationship between the extent to
which respondents‘ ratings reflected group abusiveness (both current and retrospective
perceptions) and the extent to which they portrayed themselves in a socially desirable light.
Additionally, the sample‘s low-to-average scores on the lie, or social desirability, scale
suggest that their responses were not influenced by motives to misrepresent the
abusiveness.
Psychological Distress
A large percentage of former CUT members (almost 50% of the respondents) reported
experiencing such high levels of psychological distress as to be categorized as positive risks
(Derogatis, 1994). However, only 6.6% of the respondents had received psychotherapy or
counseling prior to their involvement in CUT. This low percentage may partly be
attributable to the relatively young age at which many of them joined (57.4% joined before
the age of 25 and 72.1% before the age of 30).
Although the percentage of ex-members experiencing such high levels of psychological
distress to qualify as a psychiatric risk is large, as time away from CUT increased, distress
Previous Page Next Page