Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 48
illustration of this ―victim‖ mentality. We find it surprising that the Passantinos should object
to this in light of the Apostle Paul‘s admonition to the Colossians, ―Make sure that no one
traps you and deprives you of your freedom by some second-hand, empty, rational
philosophy based on the principles of this world instead of on Christ‖ (Col. 2:8, Jerusalem
Bible, emphasis added). Elsewhere, Paul reproaches the Christians of Corinth for ―tolerating
somebody who makes slaves of you, makes you feed him, imposes on you, orders you
about and slaps you in the face‖ (2 Corinthians 11:20, Jerusalem Bible, emphasis added).
Next, the Passantinos appear to digress into a victim-bashing section in which they take
potshots at John Bradshaw and his dysfunctional family theory, adult children of alcoholics,
the various 12-step programs, and claims of repressed memories that later proved to be
false memories.
Some would argue that in some cases mind-control by unethical or incompetent therapists
caused false memories of abuse to arise. But that is only one of many possible
explanations. We agree with the Passantinos that a person‘s developing false memories in
therapy does not necessarily mean the therapist was practicing thought reform. Yet
ironically, false memories are sometimes produced by thought reform. So the Passantinos
confront a dilemma: how can they believe in the creation of false memories (and they
clearly do) and, yet deny powerful influence techniques, such as thought reform? The
Passantinos seem to believe that psychological influence can be so powerful that in a few
sessions a therapist can (sometimes unwittingly) convince a client that her parents are
really members of a satanic cult that sexually abused her for years. Yet, they deride the
notion that a group led by a skillful, psychopathic leader can cause radical behavioral
changes in people who may be under the group‘s influence 24 hours a day for many months
or years.
The Passantinos again quote Barker, who says: ―Research has shown that, unlike those who
have been deprogrammed (and thereby taught that they had been brainwashed), those who
leave voluntarily are extremely unlikely to believe that they were ever the victims of mind-
control‖ (p. 39, citing Barker, 1989, emphasis in original). Yet, this is precisely what we
would expect. If someone has no knowledge of what happened to him, how could he
conclude he was a victim of mind-control? One must be exposed to the information.
Barker‘s conclusion is that this belief in mind-control is inculcated into hapless victims, that
they have been deceived again into believing that they were under mind-control. Another
alternative, however, is that these people are sufficiently responsible individuals that when
presented with information about the techniques of mind-control and examples of it they
are able to compare their own experience with that information and reach their own
conclusion that ―that‘s exactly what happened to me.‖11 Moreover, Barker faces the same
quandary the Passantinos confront regarding false memory: in three days an exit counselor
can completely change a person‘s outlook, but a group over a period of years allegedly
cannot.
Perhaps the Passantinos‘ rejection of the ―victim‖ label for cult members stems from their
partially correct criticism of today‘s pop psychology in which
everyone is a victim. One doesn‘t need to be saved from one‘s own sins as
much as from the sins of others. Psychology and sociology have replaced
Scripture for understanding human behavior and developing emotionally and
spiritually healthy persons. Yet nowhere in Scripture do we find support for
the complaint first voiced by Eve that ‗the devil --or the cult leader --made
me do it.‘ One cannot remove human responsibility without also destroying
human morality (p. 40).
Once again, these remarks are based on a distorted view of mind-control and an either/or
approach to understanding human behavior: either psychology and sociology, or the Bible.
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 49
However, we do not see the necessity of such a dichotomy, though we recognize that some
psychosociological and theological theories and approaches leave much to be desired. The
Passantinos seem to disallow any reference to prior abuse as even a partial explanation for
the current problems many people experience. We believe this is both unfair and
detrimental to the individual‘s healing.
The Passantinos seem to advocate an improper use of the Bible that is disturbingly common
in some evangelical and fundamentalist circles. The Bible is implicitly viewed as the only
textbook necessary for psychology, not just for doctrine and morality. But the Bible does not
make such a claim for itself. Are we to view it as the only textbook necessary for geology,
geography, or architecture? Shall we make all engineering students study only the Old
Testament because it contains instructions on how to build the tabernacle or the temple and
thus all construction must be based on those models? Or shall we base medicine only on
what is in the Bible?
Why, all of a sudden, are human sciences suddenly limited to what is in the Bible? Who
drew this arbitrary line and said, ―We can study astronomy, geology, medicine, whatever,
but the Bible must be the only textbook for the human sciences‖? That is absurd. The facts
refute this. Does the Bible talk about manic depressive illness? Does the Bible talk about
psychotic depression? Does the Bible talk about panic disorders or agoraphobia-what causes
them, how are they cured? Does the Bible distinguish between organic and functional
psychoses? Does the Bible explain what learning disabilities are, what hyperactivity is? Does
the Bible explain what a personality disorder is, how a dependent personality can be
distinguished from a borderline personality?
Objection: Theological Inconsistencies
From a theological standpoint, the Passantinos appear to undervalue the role of deceit in
the introduction of sin into the world of humans. They write:
If the cult recruiter‘s skill at manipulation is considered so coercive that
members are not responsible for their own beliefs, actions, or even the
decision to join/stay in the cult, then many biblical affirmations about
personal responsibility and decision-making are jeopardized. To a secular
mind-control model advocate, this may seem a trivial objection. But several
advocates are Christian evangelicals and must come to terms with the
theological inconsistencies introduced when the cult mind-control model is
adopted.
For example, in the Garden, Satan personally appeared to orchestrate the
temptation of Eve --and who could be more persuasive? Our first parents
succumbed to the temptation and were cast out of the Garden, and all of
humanity thereafter has been penalized by this primal sin. If our first parents
could be held morally responsible when confronted by the ultimate tempter,
how is it that we seek to excuse ourselves or our offspring when confronted
by human tempters of far less power, skill, and charisma? (p. 40).
The simple answer to their question is that the analogy between the serpent‘s beguilement
of Eve in the Garden of Eden and what happens in cult recruitment is like comparing apples
with chimpanzees. God had explicitly told Adam and Eve in advance, ―Don‘t eat of this tree.‖
The tree was identified, the tree was located. They knew what it was, they knew where it
was, they knew all about it. God had given them complete and adequate information. Most
people we know who have joined cults did not have anyone (and certainly not anyone with
the authoritative voice of God) saying, ―Don‘t join this group, it is evil, and here is the
evidence.‖ But that is basically what God did with Adam and Eve. The comparison of the
Garden with the cult situation would be more appropriate if God put Adam and Eve into the
Previous Page Next Page