Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 30
Overcoming the Bondage of Revictimization:
A Rational/Empirical Defense of Thought Reform
(In Response to “Overcoming the Bondage of
Victimization” By Bob and Gretchen Passantino)
Paul R. Martin, Ph.D. &Lawrence A. Pile
With
Ron Burks, M.A. &Stephen D. Martin, M.Div.
Abstract
In 1994 Christian counter-cult researchers Robert and Gretchen Passantino
published a major article in Cornerstone magazine attempting to debunk the
theory of cult mind-control. Beginning with a rundown of several alleged
―assumptions of mind-control‖* and proceeding to numerous objections to
mind-control, the authors sought to demonstrate what they consider to be the
faulty basis of the mind-control model of cult recruitment and influence, as
well as the incompatibility of the mind-control model with Christian theology.
The present article shows that the Passantinos‘ assertions are incorrect and
misguided. Specifically, this article demonstrates that mind-control is more
than cult conversion that, while mind-control does not rob people of moral
responsibility, it mitigates it and that there is no conflict between biblical
theology and the reality of mind-control. We contend that theological
considerations inform our understanding of the sociological and psychological
destruction caused by cults. Cults distort one‘s perceptions of both natural
reality (sociological and psychological) and spiritual reality. Since the former
is supposed to reveal the latter, as in the Christian tradition, those interested
in spiritual issues must address both sides in order to minister adequately to
cultists.
*‖Mind-control‖ is used with a hyphen in this article to be consistent with the Passantinos‘
many quotes.
Long-time cult researchers Bob and Gretchen Passantino criticize the notion that through
the use of powerful and sophisticated thought-reform techniques, some cult conversions
drastically and negatively alter some individuals‘ lives (Passantino &Passantino, 1994). The
Passantinos assert that thought reform is an erroneous theory, even though most exit
counselors and countless professionals across disciplines use it to explain the changes seen
in cult members. The purpose of the article by the Passantinos is, they say, to ―look behind
the assumptions of the mind-control model and uncover the startling reality that cult mind-
control is, at best, a distorted misnomer for cult conversion that robs individuals of personal
moral responsibility‖ (p. 31). They go on to say, ―While mind-control model advocates
rightly point out that cults often practice deception, emotional manipulation, and other
unsavory recruitment tactics, we believe a critical, well-reasoned examination of the
evidence disproves the cult mind-control model and instead affirms the importance of the
informed, biblically based religious commitment‖ (pp. 31-32).
The Passantinos are well known and respected evangelical writers. Consequently, their
critique, which is rife with errors and misinterpretations, disturbs us very much and calls for
a detailed rebuttal. In this article, we will show that the Passantinos‘ assertions are incorrect
and misguided. We will demonstrate that (1) use of mind-control, or thought reform, brings
about a special variety of conversion (2) having been under the influence of a thought-
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 31
reform program, mind-control mitigates an individual‘s moral responsibility, although it does
not remove it entirely and (3) there is no conflict between biblical theology and the reality
of mind-control.1 For us, theological considerations inform our understanding of the
sociological and psychological destruction caused by cults, although others hold similar
positions without considering theological issues. Cults distort one‘s perceptions both of
natural reality (sociological and psychological) and spiritual reality. In the Christian
tradition, the former is supposed to reveal the latter therefore, those interested in spiritual
issues must address both sides in order to minister adequately to former cult members.
The Passantinos misstate the fundamental concepts of mind-control, then imply that many
countercult workers do not support the mind-control theory, and finally argue that the
mind-control concept is counter to or incompatible with biblical Christianity. Whether or not
all, most, or only a few countercult workers support a mind-control model is irrelevant to
our critique of the Passantinos‘ misrepresentations. Certainly, experience with models of
psychotherapy has shown that different models can be applied with equal effectiveness to
similar situations. Therefore, there is room for disagreement about which theoretical model
is most internally consistent, parsimonious, and consistent with empirical data. We do not
claim that current mind-control models are the end-all and be-all of countercult thinking.
Indeed, we believe that this field needs newer theoretical models that are more amenable to
empirical testing. We are not so much defending the mind-control model as we are refuting
the Passantinos‘ misleading interpretation of that model. If the model is to be criticized, let
it be criticized for what it really says, not for misrepresentations of what it says. We use the
term ―mind-control,‖ despite its sometimes being used in a sensationalized way, because we
believe it expresses in simple language what this dispute is about, namely, the control
(which doesn‘t necessarily mean ―total control‖) of the mind by forces outside that mind.
Exit Counseling and Postcult Treatment
The Passantinos‘ article begins with a description of a concerned parent seeking help. The
authors cite former Unificationist and current exit counselor Steve Hassan as stating that
the average fee for exit counseling is $3,000 plus expenses for about four days of exit
counseling. That is probably not too far off the mark. In spite of the authors‘ insinuation
that exit counselors make good money, few have a gross annual income of more than
$35,000. Because of the nature of their work, exit counselors have to be on call virtually 24
hours a day, like firemen and paramedics. The $3,000 to $4,000 is not much, given that an
average of one case a month is about all that is possible --many exit counselors do not
even do that many cases. Many counselors spend much time in research and preparation,
and they have to be willing to go where circumstances demand. Considering the work
involved in a thorough exit counseling, we believe that the Passantinos‘ reaction to exit
counselors‘ fees is unwarranted.
The Passantinos‘ implied criticism of the fees for postcult residential treatment
demonstrates their complete ignorance of the overhead and staffing costs in maintaining a
center such as the Wellspring Retreat and Resource Center, where we work. If Wellspring
were making as much money as the Passantinos insinuate, it wouldn‘t have a history of
financial crises, as had all other postcult rehabilitation centers, of which Wellspring is the
only survivor. Wellspring‘s weekly fee for room, board, and a highly individualized treatment
program (we rarely have more than three clients at one time) is lower than that of some
specialized psychiatric inpatient facilities.
The Passantinos write, ―Of course, there were no guarantees: some ex-cultists needed
additional in-patient counseling at a special ‗recovery center‘‖ (p. 31). This statement
implies that exit counseling is unreliable. It also ignores the reality of postcult psychological
distress that calls for professional treatment. Research (Martin, Langone, Dole, &Wiltrout,
1992) on the psychological state of cult members before and after exit counseling
Previous Page Next Page