Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 50
Garden with no forewarning. They see the fruit on the tree. It looks so good. The serpent is
dangling from a branch and says, ―This is good fruit, eat it.‖ They eat it and then God comes
along and says, ―Hey, you two! You just sinned!‖ They say, ―What? We sinned? How did we
sin?‖ ―You should have known better than to eat that fruit.‖ ―Why should have we known
better?‖ ―You were spiritually deceived.‖ ―Well, you never told us not to eat that fruit!‖ ―But
if you were more spiritual you would have known.‖
If cult joining is simply a problem of spiritual deception, then the sword cuts both ways. If
cult members are responsible because they lack discernment, why is not the Church also
responsible for lack of discernment? Why hasn‘t the church been able to recognize the
wolves and warn the flock? Where was the church speaking before Jonestown? Where was
the church when Hitler came along? Where was the church when Mao Tse-tung came along?
Where was the church when David Koresh came along? Where was the church when Jeffrey
Lundgren came along? Who was warning the people who followed these leaders?
There was great silence in the church. There is still great silence in the church. So, if it is
only a deception issue, then we‘re all wrong, we‘re all deceived. To say that one group is
more deceived than the other when the church has consistently sat on its hands in the face
of this cult problem and has provided virtually no resources for cult victims is to engage in
self-righteous blame-shifting.
Hardly anything is taught about cults in seminaries and Bible schools.12 Pastors know very
little about cults, apart from some of the major doctrinal aberrations of the Mormons and
Jehovah‘s Witnesses. Currently, there is only one cult rehabilitation center in the world, and
that is Wellspring, and it receives very little support from the church. If we are going to talk
about discernment, then we better talk about the discernment of the church and heeding
the prophetic voice that warns about cults and spiritually abusive churches. That has not
often been the case. The church usually speaks out only after the fact. The responsibility for
the appalling silence and even complicity of the church in Nazi Germany rests on the heads
of evangelicals as fully as it does on those of liberals and Catholics. The appalling silence of
the evangelical church with the rise of Red China rests on our heads, too. We could just go
down the list. The discernment issue applies equally to other abuses besides those relating
to cults. As we write this, the church is experiencing more persecution worldwide than at
any time in history. To be sure, some Christians are sounding the alarm, but too few know
of the problems. Again, discernment is an issue for those in leadership, not just for the
victims.
Mind-control (or thought reform, coercive persuasion, or whatever one may call it) is not
merely a secular concept. It is also a biblical concept related to the problem of evil and how
all men and women are affected by evil. No group of Christians or non-Christians is any less
immune to thought reform than any other. What produces discernment? Is it obedience? Is
it more Bible reading? Is it going to seminary? Is it education? Are the discerning more holy
or righteous?
The Passantinos appear to be answering this last question in the affirmative. If so, their
argument runs counter to the Reformation concepts of the grace of God, the corruption of
sin, and justification by faith alone --all of which beliefs the Passantinos hold. Their
argument appears to imply that humans are capable of unassisted evaluation of data
concerning God, and making unassisted free choices in relation to spiritual matters. Thus,
they castigate cult members for being ―undiscerning.‖ But according to the Bible in the
Reformed tradition, revelation and grace are paramount. Humans may examine the
universe and their own nature to learn its complexities, but they may only know about God
as he has revealed himself. Furthermore, they may only make free choices for or against
that revelation by the grace of God. Without grace, they are only capable of rejecting
whatever revelation they might receive. Any other view denies the utter sinfulness of the
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 51
human condition and subverts the unmerited grace of God. Humans, then, are only
responsible for thoughtfully and purposely rejecting revelation and resisting grace, not for
making ―flawed choices from bad data.‖
Assuming, for the sake of argument, that somehow there is a spiritual hierarchy in which
some are less susceptible to cults than others, on what basis are they less susceptible? If it
is based on works (acquiring information and critical-thinking skills), then, according to the
Reformation tradition it has no spiritual value.13 But if cult-avoiding discernment is based on
faith, then all Christians have that and should be able to avoid cults. Thus, the Passantinos
have a grave problem, because the empirical evidence unequivocally shows that numerous
Christians have joined a variety of cults. Where, then, does discernment come from? Is it
always a sin issue in the Scripture, or is it an issue of education, knowledge, and
awareness?
Discernment may be lost because one willfully chooses to sin, but discernment may also be
lacking because one has not been educated or warned. Is one group (cult victims) culpable,
but the other (the church or society that fails to warn about cults) not? Is evil the
underlying process and factor with both kinds of discernment deficits? In other words, is our
ability to be deceived part of the human condition, part of our fallen nature? If so, and we
believe it is, then the cult victim and the silent church and society alike suffer from Adam‘s
fallen nature. But in saying this we are not saying that cult joining is a sin problem that
must be dealt with evangelistically. Rather, we are saying that the cult problem for the
church and the cult victim alike is akin to the problem of physical disease. Illness, as well as
death, is a direct result of the Fall. But the cure for disease is not evangelization leading to
spiritual redemption. The cure for disease consists of medicine and education. Through
much of history, the church has been largely responsible for the advancement of medical
science in the world. Likewise, the church needs to see the problem of cults fundamentally
as a problem of evil whose solution is, to be sure, bathed in the prayers of believers, but
realized via science and education as well as theology.
The Passantinos‘ conclusion is a call for evangelization of cult members. But their vision in
this regard is a truncated view of Judeo-Christian ethics and theology. Christians and others
have traditionally had an interest in opposing sinful systems as well as providing spiritual
comfort for those caught in them. The desire for the salvation of the souls of those bound in
the literal chains of slavery was admirable, but without the courage of Christian statesmen
like William Wilberforce, strongly supported by John Wesley and other Christian leaders, we
might still have slavery in Britain and America. Evangelizing those ―who have very real
spiritual, emotional, and social needs‖ and who ―are looking for fulfillment and significance
for their lives‖ (p. 40) without working against the oppression that enslaves them is
hypocrisy. We believe God loves cult members and wants us to work for their freedom,
whether or not they choose to follow him.
Notes
1. In a letter to the editor of Cornerstone Magazine from Douglas Groothuis, he
demonstrates some of the same errors as found in the original article to which he
was responding. Groothuis focuses on two points: first, ―the mind-control theory is
antithetical to biblical anthropology.‖ We contend that only in its extreme form, as
set up as a straw man by Bob and Gretchen Passantino, could mind-control be
regarded as antithetical to biblical anthropology. We agree that men and women are
―responsible moral agents,‖ but we also argue that humans can occasionally and
under the right (or wrong?) circumstances be led into unwise, bad, or downright evil
decisions for which God will hold us, if not totally guiltless, at least minimally
culpable. We briefly refer to a few such instances in this article: mitigation of guilt by
reason of diminished capacity due to youthfulness (Dt. 1:39), demonization, or other
Previous Page Next Page