Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 46
The ability to leave a cult on one‘s own is not necessarily a sign of health, that is, that the
individual has been unaffected by the group. To say and acknowledge that many people do
leave cults on their own does not address the question of why they leave, or whether they
have been detrimentally affected during the time of their involvement, in spite of the fact
that eventually they are able to walk away. We believe it is a gross error to assume that
those who leave cults on their own are as healthy psychologically and spiritually (or even
physically) as when they joined.
Objection: The Anti-religious Bias of Mind-control Assumptions
The Passantinos‘ next objection is ―the anti-religious bias of mind-control assumptions.‖
Basically the Passantinos say that brainwashing is a value judgment rather than an
analytical concept, and that the brainwashing/mind-control model almost inevitably arises
from or creates an antireligious bias. They quote sociologist Thomas Robbins, who says that
the mind-control model derives from Enlightenment ideals that seek to liberate man from
religion. Then, they quote William Sargant, who argued that Christian evangelical preaching
techniques are similar to Communist brainwashing methods. Finally, they refer to Conway
and Siegelman, who criticized fundamentalist Christians in the first edition of their book
Snapping.
We fail to see, however, what relevance the antireligious sentiments of some authors have
to do with the modern concept of cult mind-control as held in particular by evangelical
proponents of the model. That some people in the field might be biased against religion
does not mean the concept itself is antireligious or necessarily leads to such a bias. Mind-
control theories can apply to a religious setting, a psychotherapy setting, a political setting,
a business setting. Are mind-control advocates, then, antipsychotherapy, antipolitics, and
antibusiness? Are mind-control advocates antimilitary because the concept was first studied
under military conditions? Hardly.
Ron Enroth, well known for his evangelical convictions, cannot be accused of an antireligious
bias when he says there are churches that abuse (Enroth, 1992). Rather, he speaks as a
modern prophet against mistreatment of God‘s flock. Did the prophet Ezekiel have an
antireligious bias when he rebuked the wicked shepherds who were exploiting, harming, and
destroying the people of God? In this section, the Passantinos employ an ad hominem
argument that is rather poorly thought out. If we were to employ this form of reasoning, we
might conclude that the Passantinos are guilty of an ―antisecular‖ bias. It seems that once
again the Passantinos have violated their rule, ―Similar Does Not Prove Same‖ (Passantino &
Passantino, 1991).
The Passantinos also maintain that the inability to draw a clear-cut line between a legitimate
religion and a cult is final proof that mind-control does not exist. Would they use the same
reasoning regarding domestic abuse? When does a husband‘s verbal criticism of his wife
become verbal abuse? When does spanking a child become child abuse? Where are the
clear-cut lines in these cases? Or where is the clear-cut line between political authority and
dictatorship? If the authors can locate it, they will be in great demand all over the world.
The last paragraph of this section is particularly troubling. The Passantinos write, ―In short,
there is no objective, evidential way to define groups that are ‗good‘ (not using mind-
control) versus groups that are ‗bad‘ (using mind-control)‖ (p. 38). But this is simply not
true. A group can be evaluated according to explicit criteria. For example, is it characterized
by the use of certain techniques, like Lifton‘s eight criteria of thought reform? That is, does
it use milieu control, mystical manipulation? Does it have a sacred science? Does it practice
doctrine over person? Does it have a loaded language? Does it have a ―cult of confession,‖
the demand for purity? Does it dispense with the existence of nonmembers, whether
spiritually or physically? One of the most famous books in psychology deals with the open
and the closed mind and how these systems work (Rokeach, 1960). There is a wealth of
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 47
literature in the social sciences about controlling, tight organizations versus loose
organizations. There are criteria in political science for determining what is and is not a
totalitarian system. Moreover, research is now underway to validate the first measure of
group psychological abuse (Chambers, Langone, Dole, &Grice, 1994). Undoubtedly, future
research will result in improvements in our capacity to evaluate the destructiveness of
group environments.
Objection: Creating Victims
The Passantinos object to the mind-control model because, they say, it ―creates victims.‖
We would argue instead that it is mind-control, not the mind-control model, that creates
victims. We would also argue that cult survivors are revictimized by those, such as the
Passantinos, who lay all or most of the blame for their plight at their own feet.
The authors introduce this objection by writing:
Many people who join cults want to help the needy, forsake materialism, or
develop personal independence from their families-not necessarily bad goals,
although misguided by false cult teachings. The cult mind-control model,
however, attributes cult membership primarily to mind-control and thereby
denigrates or discounts such positive activities and goals, misaffiliated to cults
as they are (p. 38).
This passage again illustrates the Passantinos‘ failure to clearly understand what mind-
control model advocates actually say. Mind-control is not exercised in a vacuum --it needs
information to work with, whether it is cult-generated doctrine or the hopes, dreams, fears,
and hang-ups of the potential recruit. Thus, the goals listed by the Passantinos may be used
by the cult recruiter as ―hooks‖ to draw the target into the sphere of the group. We do not
denigrate such goals at all. We applaud any positive aims and activities. The problem is that
they can also be used as lures to attract new members, or as ploys to achieve legitimacy in
the community. Most of our clients at Wellspring say, ―This is why I joined the group. I
wanted to help the needy, forsake materialism, develop some personal independence from
my family, and grow up. I wanted to serve the Lord.‖ Jim Jones‘ Peoples Temple took over
nursing homes in the San Francisco Bay Area, significantly improving them to the benefit of
the residents. Peoples Temple members also helped drug addicts kick their habits and
obtain education. These and many other activities of the Peoples Temple were highly
commendable and worth doing, were it not for the fact that Jones exploited these
achievements ultimately to lead people to their deaths.
The Passantinos go on to say:
The mind-control model also fails to give proper weight to the role natural
suggestibility plays in making people vulnerable to the cults. Highly
suggestible people are especially susceptible to religious salesmanship as well
as many other ―sales pitches‖ (pp. 38-39).
On the contrary, this is exactly the point we have made. Suggestibility probably does make
people more susceptible to mind-control. 10 Some people are naturally more suggestible
than others, others go through periods in life in which they are more suggestible than at
other times (e.g., times of crisis, bereavement, or transition of some kind or another). In
such a condition people may be victimized, whether by a con artist, a Lothario, or a cult
recruiter. It is not ―adopting a victimization perspective‖ that ―strips the cult member of his
capacity for rational activity.‖ Rather, it is the victimization itself that does this --though we
acknowledge that it does so to varying degrees in different people.
The Passantinos assert that ―the cult mind-control model epitomizes a ‗victim‘ mentality‖ (p.
39). They quote Hassan‘s remarks about the cult member being caught in a trap as an
Previous Page Next Page