Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 70
levels decreased. Time out of CUT explained a significant proportion of the variability in
both regression models (one using Global Severity Index scores as dependent variable, the
other using the number of subscales on which an individual had scored 63 or above). Two
additional variables that had significant predictive value in one or the other of the two
regression models were the quality of spousal relationship during and after CUT
involvement. Individuals who reported a higher quality of relationship with their spouse
after exiting CUT also reported lower levels of psychological distress than those who had
poor spousal relationships. The same is true for the quality of spousal relationship during
CUT involvement. This is not surprising if one considers that a relationship which can be
maintained at a qualitatively high level while the spouses undergo high levels of
environmental stress may be a source of strength for the partners. This will reduce the
overall stressfulness of the experience and the psychological harm inflicted. Although time
in CUT was excluded from the multiple regression model, it was positively correlated with
psychological distress. This suggests that there is a positive relationship between the time
an individual spent in CUT and the psychological problems experienced later.
Most theorists think that people who are in pain (psychologically or otherwise) try to
attribute that pain to an outside source, which then leads to an unfair negative evaluation of
that source. What if those not in pain share the negative evaluations? Nearly half of the
present respondents met the criteria for being a positive risk. Some reported high levels of
psychological distress, but others were virtually symptom-free. The lowest individual post-
involvement GPA rating given to CUT in this study, however, was 109. According to
Langone (1995), ratings suggestive of non-abusiveness range from 28 to 84. Moreover,
there was no relationship between the reported level of psychological distress and
respondents‘ perceptions of group abusiveness.
There was a negative relationship between reported psychological distress and the extent to
which respondents portrayed themselves in a socially desirable light: Those who reported
higher levels were less inclined to answer according to what is considered socially desirable.
Respondents who scored relatively high on the lie scale may have underreported
psychological distress, perhaps because they did not want to be seen as having problems.
Personalities of Former CUT Members
The present evidence suggests that former members of CUT do not differ from the norm on
the psychoticism and neuroticism dimensions. Females did not differ from the norm in their
desire to be socially acceptable (as measured by the lie scale of the EPQ-R), but males
appeared to be less concerned with their social desirability than one expects of males in the
general population. This may be a reaction to the manipulation they experienced during
their involvement in CUT. If these scores are, however, representative of a condition
present before cult involvement, they may reflect a stronger than average desire for honest
self-evaluation. This desire, in turn, may have contributed to the vulnerability of these
individuals to manipulation. Honest people often assume this quality in others. If either or
both of these proposed explanations are valid, it is unclear why females in this sample did
not differ from the norm. Is it possible that females in general feel more pressure in this
society to represent themselves in a more socially desirable light?
Extroversion was the only personality dimension on which both males and females differed
from the norm, although the difference was slightly greater for females than males. If one
takes into account the intense alienation from the outside world former cultists experienced
during their involvement and the fact that many, upon their exit, think they were betrayed
by the thought reform program to which they were subjected, it makes sense that they
became more introverted. The significant positive correlation between extroversion and
years out of CUT suggests that with increased time away from the cult environment,
extroversion scores approach the norm.
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 71
Although the sample‘s neuroticism scores did not significantly differ from established norms,
there was a significant negative correlation between neuroticism and time since leaving
CUT: Respondents who were out longer scored lower on neuroticism.
Changes in Close Personal Relationships
The ratings respondents gave to the quality of their close relationships reveal a clear pattern
across all relationship categories. The rated quality of relationships was consistently lowest
during CUT involvement. A comparison of before and after ratings showed higher ratings
for the quality of post-CUT parental relationships. This was not the case for spouse
relationships, which were about the same before and after CUT, nor for other relationships,
which were worse after than before CUT. Based on additional comments that respondents
made on the survey, it appears that some individuals had rated their relationships with
friends who had joined the group with them or someone they had met during their
involvement. In either case, these relationships may, as a result of their exit, be strained at
best and non-existent at worst. This may be the reason why the post-involvement mean for
the category other is lower than the pre-involvement mean.
Several respondents commented that divorces were related to their cult involvement. Some
indicated that they were completely cut off from their former spouse and therefore did not
give a post-involvement rating for the spouse category. Others who remarried since their
exit rated their current marriage. Thus, the relatively high mean for post-cult ratings of
spousal relationships appears to be partly attributable to post-CUT marriages.
Unfortunately, we did not ask respondents to indicate the year they divorced. This
prevented an exact determination of how many marriage dissolutions might have been
related to CUT involvement, which marriages dissolved prior to CUT involvement, and which
dissolved considerably later.
Respondents‘ ratings of the quality of their relationship with a spouse after CUT involvement
probably reflect the relationship with the individual‘s current spouse (whether or not the
individual refers to the same spouse in each time period). As far as having used the
variable as a predictor for one of the regression models, when the marriage was entered
into seems less of an issue than whether or not a good relationship with one‘s spouse after
cult involvement is likely to contribute to a decrease in psychological distress.
Limitations, Unanswered Questions, and Suggestions for Future Research
One weakness of the present study was the sample itself, because the majority of the
respondents were recipients of a newsletter primarily sent to former CUT members. In this
newsletter, grievances about the group and its leadership are freely expressed.
Additionally, each issue of the newsletter includes a list of recommended publications about
CUT as well as more general cult educational materials. Thus, the sample‘s
representativeness of ex-members may be questioned. Sixty-one individuals represent a
small proportion of the hundreds who have left CUT during the 29 years since it was
founded. The majority of those who participated in the study had been exposed to the
newsletter‘s anti-CUT and anti-cult stance. Although this is a legitimate concern, a lack of
understanding about cult-related issues does not necessarily mean that people‘s perceptions
are more valid. Put differently, more information and education, which is generally
regarded as an advantage in discovering the truth, may be a desirable quality in
respondents. The present sample offered just that. Additionally, one cannot assume that
former members who may not be aware of the newsletter or fear being on its mailing list
perceive the group as any less abusive. Representativeness with regard to the level of past
group involvement and commitment to the group, as well as the time spent in the group,
was remarkably good.
Previous Page Next Page