Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 58
the scoring pattern between the former members of the controversial BCC and their
mainstream comparison groups: BCC scores clearly fell into the abusive range, but none of
the other groups (although different from each other) approached that range.
Personality and Psychiatric Symptomatology
Langone (1996) concluded that cult members‘ personality profiles fall within the normal
range. Walsh et al. (1995) found that although ex-cult members had elevated scores on
the neuroticism scale of the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire, their scores approached
normal as a function of time since leaving the cult. Yeakley (1988) gave the Myers-Briggs
Type Indicator to members of the BCC. He asked them to respond to each item one time as
they would have responded before their conversion, a second time as they perceived
themselves at the time the study was conducted, and a third time as they imagined
themselves answering after five more years of discipling. Nearly all respondents tended to
change their psychological type scores across the three versions. According to Yeakley, the
direction in which these changes occurred was toward the personality of the leader.
A common phenomenon among cult members, which is usually witnessed by their families
and friends but not widely recognized among clinicians, is what West and Martin (1994)
called pseudo-identity or altered persona. It appears to be a dissociative coping response to
extraordinary circumstances such as profound changes in an individual‘s life, prolonged
environmental stress, or both. The pseudo-identity, which is induced, strengthened, and
maintained by the cult environment, becomes superimposed upon the original personality,
which is suppressed while the individual remains in the new stressful environment.
Although a person who is removed from the cult environment may abandon or snap out of
the pseudo-identity and revert back to his or her original personality, this process does not
usually happen without severe psychological problems (Conway &Siegelman, 1995). The
symptoms associated with the pseudo-identity syndrome, which are usually triggered by
environmental cues, are dissociative, trance-like states, depersonalization, derealization,
emotional numbness, and floating, which is a ―switching back and forth between behaviors
characteristic of the two separate personalities‖ (West &Martin, 1994, p. 274). The
restoration of the original identity ―usually requires treatment for the residual post-
traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) which is the legacy of the stress that produced the
pseudo-identity syndrome‖ (West &Martin, 1994, p. 279). Some additional commonly
experienced aftereffects of cult involvement are: (a) depression (b) loneliness and a sense
of alienation (c) low self-esteem and low self-confidence (d) difficulty explaining how they
could have joined such a group (e) phobic-like constriction of social contacts (f) fear of
joining groups or making a commitment (g) apprehension about their own idealism and
altruism (which the cult had manipulated) (h) distrust of professional services and distrust
of self in making good choices (i) problems in reactivating a value system by which to live
(j) guilt, shame, and self-blaming attitudes (k) excessive doubts, fears, and paranoia and
(l) panic attacks (Langone, 1995 Singer, 1979 Singer &Lalich, 1995).
Perceptions of Cult Members and Ex-members
Singer (1978) and Clark (1979) first recognized that dissociative defenses are a mechanism
by which cult members (much like political captives and hostages) adapt to the intense
demands of the environment in which they find themselves. As we have mentioned, the
syndrome associated with this stressful adaptation has since been called pseudo-identity
(West &Martin, 1994). While members are under the group‘s psychological control and are
not in a state of questioning or rebellion, the pseudo-identity can appear to be normal and
well adjusted. However, if an event or outside influence is strong enough to fracture the
pseudo-identity, which until then has enveloped the original self, the underlying pain and
psychological harm become apparent. Langone (1995) insightfully remarked that the
reason why cult members generally do not return to the cult after the floodgates of
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 59
recognition and emotion have opened is ―because the suffering they experience after
leaving [the cult] is more genuine than the ‗happiness‘ they experienced while in it. A
painful truth is better than a pleasant lie.... If this analysis is correct, ex-members may
indeed provide more accurate information about cults than would current members‖ (pp. 8-
9).
Former members, however, are often reluctant to participate in scientific studies. Several
factors may motivate this reluctance, such as fear of retaliation from the cult,
embarrassment at having been manipulated, ridicule from those who lack understanding,
and a need for closure. For this reason, the methodology of the present study was designed
with an awareness of these potential sensitivities.
Background: Church Universal and Triumphant
Church Universal and Triumphant (CUT) is a New Age apocalyptic cult with roots in
Theosophy and various splinters of the I AM Movement. Its core belief is that a pantheon of
Gods, Goddesses, Angels, and Ascended Masters communicate via their messenger
(Elisabeth Claire Prophet) to teach, prophesize, reprimand, and direct devotees. Ascended
Masters are considered enlightened heavenly beings who have ―graduated from earth‘s
schoolroom‖ by balancing their karma, thereby having escaped the cycle of reincarnation.
They are seen as exemplars and teachers to assist their followers to do the same.
Obedience to the dictates of these heavenly beings is seen as a guaranteed path to the
individual‘s ascension. Although Prophet is still ―inhabiting a physical body,‖ years ago it
was announced that she has balanced all of her personal karma and voluntarily remains in
embodiment. Her mission is one of ―balancing world-karma,‖ of being the one and only
mouthpiece of God, and of being a guru and spiritual teacher in the flesh. Thus, her word
and position are beyond reproach, and her power over CUT members is absolute.
One of the major identifying practices used by CUT is that of decreeing, which is also
referred to as the ―science of the spoken word.‖ It is a fast and repetitious form of chanting
affirmations and commands in the name of the individual‘s own Christ Self and by the
authority of any divine being whose power the individual seeks to invoke. Decreeing can
last many hours each day, and it may be done in solitude, in small groups, or in very large
groups. It is seen as the all-powerful tool to influence not only present and future events
but also personal and global history, including events from past incarnations. Experts on
thought reform have noted that fast, repetitive chanting, such as decreeing, may serve as a
thought-stopping technique (Conway &Siegelman, 1995 Hassan, 1988). In the context of
Lifton‘s (1987, 1991) theory of ideological totalism, CUT not only qualifies as a totalistic
environment but also exemplifies all eight criteria identified by Lifton.
Many cults show elitism, a very strong ―us-versus-them‖ mentality (often underlying
militant activities) and much secrecy surrounding their actual practices and beliefs. For this
reason, cults generally do
not readily submit to scientific investigation. CUT may seem to be an exception to this rule,
because it apparently welcomed scientific investigation in the form of an interdisciplinary
study (Lewis &Melton, 1994). The study painted a picture of a benign religious movement
that has been unjustly maligned and persecuted because of the public‘s xenophobia. A
close review of the study, however, may leave the informed reader wondering whether
these investigators were familiar with the dynamics of cults and the manipulative tactics
used by their leaders and well-trained devotees. Perhaps these researchers were naive in
believing what was orchestrated for them, thereby allowing themselves to be used as
unwitting tools of church propaganda. After elaborating on examples of groupthink (Janis,
1972), two members of the research team which studied CUT asserted that the overriding
problem was the study‘s lack of objectivity, which permeated every aspect of the data
collection process. For the most part, the scholars turned a blind eye to the controversies
Previous Page Next Page