Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 60
surrounding the church because the real intent of the study was not to investigate, but to
exonerate (Balch &Langdon, 1998). Balch and Langdon also explained that the study had
been conducted hastily in an effort to defend CUT because it had publicly been likened to a
cult in Waco, Texas. Thus, according to Balch and Langdon, the researchers saw their
mission as one of defending freedom of religion rather than investigating whether any of the
myths they sought to dispel were actually true.
Research Questions
For a selected group of former members of CUT, we investigated the following four main
questions:
1. Perceived abusiveness and deception. To what extent do former members of CUT
perceive the group to be abusive (as measured by the Group Psychological Abuse
Scale), and how does this current perception compare to the understanding they had at
the time they first considered themselves members of the group? (If these two are
different, they may provide insight into the level of deception other researchers have
ascribed to cultic environments.) In addition, how do scale scores, obtained from a
sample of former CUT members, compare with previously investigated samples of ex-
members from other groups?
2. Psychological distress. What level of psychological distress (as measured by the revised
Symptom Checklist 90) do former CUT members report, and what factors are correlated
with these scores? Do people who experienced higher levels of psychological distress
rate the group as more abusive than those who experienced lower levels of
psychological distress?
3. Personalities of former CUT members. Do the personalities of former CUT members
differ from established norms (as measured by the revised Eysenck Personality
Questionnaire), and is there any indication that these scores may change over time?
4. Changes in close personal relationships. To what extent was the reported quality of
close personal relationships, such as with one‘s spouse, affected by involvement in CUT?
This and other information was obtained on a background questionnaire.
Method
Instruments
The present survey used several instruments: (a) two copies of the Group Psychological
Abuse scale (Chambers et al., 1994) (b) the revised Symptom Checklist 90 (Derogatis,
1994) (c) the revised Eysenck Personality Questionnaire (Eysenck &Eysenck, 1994) and
(d) a 29-item background questionnaire, an adaptation and expansion of a form used by
Langone (1995) in a study investigating the BCC.
Group Psychological Abuse Scale. We used the Group Psychological Abuse (GPA) scale to
assess ex-members‘ current and pre-involvement (retrospective) perceptions of CUT. The
two GPA copies were identical except for the introductory paragraphs. One copy asked
respondents to respond according to ―your current understanding of CUT,‖ whereas the
other requested that they respond according to ―the way you would have responded when
you first joined the group.‖ To control for order effects, half of the surveys were sent out
with the post-involvement version to be filled out before the pre-involvement
(retrospective) one, and the other half of the surveys had the two versions stapled together
in reverse order. The instructional paragraphs to both versions requested that responses
reflect respondents‘ personal experiences and observations. The GPA scale consists of 28
items, 7 on each of four factors (subscales), which identify Compliance, Exploitation, Mind
Control, and Anxious Dependency as specific dimensions of group psychological abuse.
Scores on the Compliance subscale reflect beliefs about the degree to which an individual
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, 1998, page 61
must accede to group norms (e.g., ―Members must abide by the group‘s guidelines
regarding dating and intimate relationships‖). Scores on the Exploitation subscale reflect
beliefs about the degree to which a cult manipulates, abuses, and uses people (e.g., ―The
group advocates or implies that breaking the law is okay if it serves the interests of the
group‖). Scores on the Mind Control subscale reflect beliefs about the degree to which the
cult leadership uses deceptive and manipulative means to sustain membership (e.g.,
―People who stay in the group do so because they are deceived and manipulated‖). Scores
on the Anxious Dependency subscale reflect beliefs about the degree to which members
depend in an absolute and possibly also anxious way on the group (e.g., ―Members believe
that to leave the group would be death or eternal damnation for themselves or their
families‖). On each item, respondents rated the target group on a 5-point Likert scale from
1 (not at all characteristic) to 5 (very characteristic). Thus, the range for each subscale is
7-35, and the range for the overall (composite) score is 28-140. Scores above the midpoint
(21 for each subscale, 84 for the composite) indicate that the respondent rated the group as
being abusive (Langone, 1994). Previously obtained Cronbach‘s alpha (reliability)
coefficients for the GPA ranged from .70 to .81 on the four subscales (Chambers et al.,
1994).
Symptom Checklist 90, Revised. The Symptom Checklist 90, Revised (SCL-90-R), a
multidimensional self-report inventory widely used in psychiatric screening to measure
psychological distress levels, offers four normative scoring versions for both males and
females. The norms have been established for psychiatric inpatients, psychiatric
outpatients, nonpatient adults, and nonpatient adolescents. The present study used
nonpatient adult norms. A total of 90 items measure the severity of symptoms on nine
distinct dimensions: (a) somatization, (b) obsession-compulsion, (c) interpersonal
sensitivity, (d) depression, (e) anxiety, (f) hostility, (g) phobic anxiety, (h) paranoid
ideation, and (i) psychoticism. The instrument includes seven additional items that are
reflected only in the three global scores: the Global Severity Index, the Positive Symptom
Distress Index, and the Positive Symptom Total. Their inclusion is based on their clinical
significance. The function of the global measures is to express the level or depth of
psychological distress in a single score.
Because the SCL-90-R is used to screen various non-psychiatric populations (e.g., Derogatis
&DellaPietra, 1994 Derogatis &Lazarus, 1994), an operational definition of what
constitutes a positive case seems appropriate and helpful. Derogatis (1994) defined
caseness by an operational rule which states that the individual is considered a positive risk
if the person has a Global Severity Index score on the nonpatient norm greater than or
equal to a standardized score of 63 (or scores 63 or above on two primary dimensions).
Previously obtained Cronbach‘s alpha coefficients for the SCL-90-R ranged from .77 to .90
on the various symptom dimensions and from .83 to .90 for test-retest coefficients
(Derogatis, Rickels, &Rock, 1976 Horowitz, Rosenberg, Baer, Ureno, &Villasenor, 1988).
Criterion validity studies, in particular with MMPI scales, showed high convergent validity
and peak correlations on eight of the nine scales of the SCL-90 (Derogatis et al., 1976).
Eysenck Personality Questionnaire Revised. The Eysenck Personality Questionnaire, Revised
(EPQ-R) is a self-report instrument that uses 73 items to determine the strengths of three
dimensions of personality: psychoticism or ―tough-mindedness,‖ neuroticism or
―emotionality,‖ and extroversion. A fourth subscale, the Lie scale, uses 21 additional items
to measure dissimulation or social desirability. Norms for the EPQ-R have been established
for American males and females (see Results section). Previously obtained Cronbach‘s
alpha coefficients for the subscales range from .66 to .86 (Eysenck &Eysenck, 1994).
Background Questionnaire (personal information and reported quality of personal
relationships). The background questionnaire asked respondents for such information as
year of birth, marital status, religious background, level of involvement, and so on.
Previous Page Next Page