Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2006, Page 19
Hume, Lynne. ―Witchcraft and the Law in Australia.‖ Journal of Church and State 37 (1995):
135–50.
Kerbaj, Richard. ―Imam's Secret Talks for Future.‖ Weekend Australian, 17 June 2006.
Langone, Michael D. ―Assessment and Treatment of Cult Victims and Their Families.‖ In
Innovations in Clinical Practice Vol 10. Sarasota, Florida, 1990.
———. ―Cults and Weapons of Mass Destruction: A Pre-Proposal for Avoiding Future
Carnage.‖ Bonita Springs: AFF (ICSA), 2004.
Macquarie University. The Macquarie Dictionary. Sydney: Macquarie Library Pty Ltd, 1981.
Manne, Robert. ―The Unknown Story of Cornelia Rau.‖ The Monthly Essays, September
2005.
McGeough, Paul. ―The Making of a Monster.‖ Goodweekend: The Sydney Morning Herald
Magazine, 16 October 2004.
―Onus on Muslims to Stop Extremist ‗Cults,‘ Canadian MP Says.‖ Ottawa Citizen, 10 June
2006.
Pape, Robert. Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism. Melbourne: Scribe,
2005.
Post, Jerrold M. ―Terrorist Psycho-Logic: Terrorist Behavior as a Product of Psychological
Forces.‖ In Origins of Terrorism: Psychologies, Ideologies, Theologies, States of
Mind. Walter Reich (Ed.). 25–40. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Radio National. What Makes a Suicide Bomber? Geraldine Doogue interview with Waleed
Aly. ABC Online 16 July, 2005.
Simon, Daniel Benjamin &Steven. The Next Attack: The Globilization of Jihad. London:
Hodder &Stoughton Ltd, 2005.
Victoria Legislative Council. ―Parliamentary Debates (Hansard).‖ Melbourne: Victoria
Parliament, 1982.
Ware, Michael. ―Zarqawi Disciple Ready to Fill Void.‖ Weekend Australian, 10 June 2006.
Woolstone, Rabbi Pinchos. Letter to the author, 27 April 1993.
This paper is based on a presentation to the Annual International Conference of the
International Cultic Studies Association, June 23, 2006.
Stephen Bruce Mutch Ph.D., LL.B (UNSW), is a solicitor of the Supreme Court of New
South Wales and has convened a course on the Politics, Law and Morality of International
Political Violence in the Department of Politics and International Relations, Macquarie
University, Sydney, where he is an Honorary Associate. He also conducts a colloquium on
Religion, Secularism and the State for the Macquarie Global Leadership Program and is
currently lecturing in Australian Foreign Policy. A former member of the NSW Legislative
Council (State Senate) and then the Australian House of Council (State Senate) and then
the Australian House of Representatives, Stephen served in parliament from 1988 to 1998.
His doctoral thesis is entitled ―Cults, Religion and Public Policy.‖ Dr. Mutch is also the Patron
of Cult Information and Family Support Inc. (CIFS), a Sydney based support and
information network for those with family members and friends in high demand groups.
This article is an electronic version of an article originally published in Cultic Studies Review, 2006, Volume 5, Number 2,
pages 169-197. Please keep in mind that the pagination of this electronic reprint differs from that of the bound volume.
This fact could affect how you enter bibliographic information in papers that you may write.

Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2006, Page 20
Are Terrorists Cultists?
Arthur A. Dole, Ph.D., ABPP
Emeritus Professor, Psychology in Education
University of Pennsylvania
Abstract
Are terrorists cultists? Or, are cultists terrorists? To open exploration of these
questions within a speculative framework, I begin by examining the
definitions of basic terms, relying heavily on previous analyses by Dole and
by Langone, Stout, Lifton, Zimbardo, and others. After a review of extremely
harmful acts by terrorists and cultists since 2001, I discuss how often, for
what purposes, and under what circumstances such groups use violence. As
examples I select two terrorist groups and two cultic groups and compare
them on selected abusive and beneficial characteristics, using a modified
version of the Group Psychological Abuse Scale as a rough yardstick. I then
discuss possible counter actions appropriate to some of the similarities and
differences among cultists and terrorists. What research is needed to support
prevention and control? Can aspects of exit consultation or other methods of
behavioral control be applied to members of terrorist groups? When, if at all,
might soft power or constructive action in the spirit of Martin Luther King be
effective? I conclude that some but not all terrorists are similar in their
dynamics to cultists and that many cultists are not similar to terrorists.
Are terrorists cultists? Or, are cultists terrorists? To explore these questions within a
speculative framework, I will review and update portions of a chapter in The Psychology of
Terrorism (Stout, 2002) that I prepared in the fall of 2001 just after the bombings of
September 11. I then compare two terrorist and two cultic groups.
Terrorist
After examining various definitions of "Terrorist," I concluded (Dole, 2001, p.213):
As Michael Kinsley (2001) has written, defining terrorism is essential it's
also impossible. I propose to use to use the term terrorist in the following
sense: Given a conflict, a terrorist is an extremely hostile opponent.
Current usage among coalition countries tends to define terrorist as anyone who harms
noncombatants. Such thinking demonizes without accounting for variations and distinctions.
Thus, by this definition, Basque separatists, Moroccan bombers, Hezbollah, Saddam
Hussein, and the bin Laden suicide gang are all terrorists. A Spaniard or American may be
tempted to overlook that each group may have very different histories, customs, purposes,
grievances, and methods. Events since 9/11 have not changed my view that calling an
opponent a terrorist without amplification interferes with the resolution of a particular
conflict, whether by military or diplomatic means. Thus although Saddam could be called a
terrorist and a tyrant, he was not responsible for the suicide attacks on the United States
(9/11 Report, 2004).
Suicide attacks and other murderous assaults are not new as methods in all kinds of
warfare including insurgency they have been used for centuries. See also Stout (2002) for
a wide variety of views about terrorism.
Cultist
In 2002 (Dole, 2002) I wrote that cultist (cult member) is also a tricky term. Lawyers,
sociologists, and theologians among others apply different meanings. As a psychologist, I