Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 65
refers to the symbol of conservative in a president who appears clumsy and pedestrian
when addressing other worldviews thus, the inept initial handling of the war in Iraq. Lakoff
points to Al Gore‘s successful campaign and film about global warming as a good example of
the proper use of ―real mechanisms of mind … to tell important truths.‖ Gore‘s film
producers used a host of influence techniques, including personal narratives, emotions,
images, and worldviews to get the point across. If they had merely stuck to the facts, the
project would have flopped.
Drew Weston is a psychologist and a professor at Emory with a particular focus on politics
as a consultant with Western Strategies. He believes Orwell got the title of his novel wrong
by two decades: 2004 marked a several-year period that was ―the most Orwellian of
American democracy.‖ Weston lists typical criticisms of the Bush administration‘s positions
on education, the environment, and waging ―perpetual‖ war. He believes that Orwell would
have recognized ―No Child Left Behind‖ and ―Clear Skies Initiative‖ as Newspeak. He might
have been surprised at how well television images and Internet propaganda have increased
manipulation of the public even in a democracy. He argues that Reagan was able to defeat
Carter largely through ―masterfully crafted‖ patriotic media adverts. Weston notes offensive
manipulation of Barack Obama‘s image by the ―right‖ that has associated Obama with
Muslims and Blackness. Weston suggests we combat 21st century Newspeak by exposing it
as it happens.
Alice O‘Connor writes in ―Bad Knowledge‖ that the ―‗faith-based‘ administration‖ and the
―right-wing‖ establishment battered ―evidence-based knowledge‖ with their propaganda for
war and misreading of evidence for global warming and stem-cell research. Her critique is
not entirely partisan. The left also contributes to bad knowledge with its ―technocratic think
tanks‖ that pretend to an aura of neutrality as well as gravity. O‘Connor refers to the
conservative reaction to the ―culture wars … in the 1970s and 1980s‖ against an
increasingly permissive and ―liberal‖ activism as one factor that contributes to our present
state of political obfuscation. O‘Connor teaches at the University of California, Santa
Barbara, and her latest book is Social Science for What? (2007).
Frances FitzGerald, author of several books and frequent contributor to The New Yorker (I
recall her excellent 1986 New Yorker articles on the Rajneesh cult), follows the progression
of U.S. defense policy from the Cold War years. In 1983 President Reagan announced plans
for a Strategic Defense Initiative, or ―star wars‖ thus, FitzGerald‘s essay ―Stellar Spin.‖
Although there was never a viable technology to prevent enemy ballistic missiles from
entering the United States, administrators continued to make policy as if they had
something. ―The U.S. National Missile Defense program is a case study in just what George
Orwell warned us about: rhetoric over reality.‖
Konstanty Gebert, a former Solidarity activist in Poland, is a columnist and reporter for
Gazeta Wyborcza and visiting professor at universities in America. He writes in ―Black and
White, or Gray: A Polish Conundrum‖ that Orwell may have been naïve to think that
democracy with its ―freedoms‖ of speech would be an antidote to the Newspeak of
totalitarian regimes. In Gebert‘s native Poland, the current regime of Chairman Jaroslaw
Kaczynski, with his twin brother Lech as president, created a coalition under their Law and
Justice Party with the smaller Self-Defense (leftist and led by a former Communist) and the
extreme right-wing League of Polish Families parties. Gebert argues that this post-
totalitarian democracy has maneuvered into becoming a version of a ―post-Communist
monster‖ that it opposes. The coalition has done this by manipulating the ―silent majority‖
of Poland to believe that it was both rooting out old Communist influences and relieving the
guilt of those who supported Communism. In effect, Kaczynski has been suppressing media
criticism of his alliance by using neo-Orwellian Newspeak.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 66
Susan Harding teaches anthropology at the University of California, Santa Cruz and has
written a book critical of Reverend Jerry Falwell thus, her essay ―After the Falwellians.‖
Harding follows Lakoff above in pointing out that conservatives have undermined liberal
agendas by reframing political language and burdening the liberal with creating a relativistic
and immoral society. She takes the Falwellians to task for constricting the discussion about
the secularization of society, but predicts that their challenge might lead to the emergence
of a new social soul. The signs are among evangelicals who support environmental care and
good science. She sees Al Gore‘s An Inconvenient Truth as an example of a ―jeremiad‖ and
a leftist adaptation of a faith-based style. She notes that Orwell would have agreed with
Falwellians that the revolt against religion caused the ―amputation of the soul‖ in modern
society however, Orwell defined soul as ―the belief in human brotherhood.‖
Part Three covers Media and Message and begins with Martin Kaplan‘s ―Welcome to the
Infotainment Freak Show.‖ Kaplan was a campaign manager and chief speechwriter for Vice
President Walter Mondale. He earned a Ph.D. from Stanford University, and he holds the
Norman Lear Chair in Entertainment, Media, and Society at the USC Annenberg School.
Kaplan writes that it is not so much Orwell‘s 1984 world that should worry us, but rather,
Aldous Huxley‘s Brave New World, which describes a society on the drug ―Soma.‖ We are in
―immanent danger of amusing ourselves to death.‖ In our media-driven lives, everything
has to be entertaining—politics, sports, news, commerce, health care, self-image, law—or
we will merely ignore it. Informing an audience is less important than having an audience. A
postmodern consciousness or ―pomo‖ of subjectivism has trumped the robustness of science
and real journalism. Perhaps there is an antidote via the Internet, but Kaplan warns, ―[o]n
the Internet, no one knows if you are Big Brother.‖
Victor Navasky asks ―What About Big Media?‖ in his essay that discusses the changes in
postal rates that now advantage the largest media corporations such as Time-Warner while
all small publishers must pay much higher rates. The founding fathers of our nation wanted
free fare for posted opinion magazines, to better inform the public and thus keep the citizen
as free as possible. Since the Postal Reorganization Act of 1970, the USPS demands that
―each class of mail must pay its own way.‖ That Act was implemented in 1984, ironically. In
2007, after a decade of lobbying, Time-Warner convinced the USPS (a monopoly) ―that in
the name of ‗efficiency‘ it ought to adopt an Orwellian plan whereby the smaller the
magazine, the higher the postal rates.‖ Navasky reports that this newsworthy reversal of
public policy ―received little or no coverage in the conglomerated, mainstream media.‖ The
number of Big Media companies is now in the single digits. Navasky asks, ―Whatever
happened to antitrust?‖ He doubts the Internet‘s ―unfact-checked blogosphere‖ will have
any effect because studies show that any blog longer than 1,000 words is discouraged
thus, it is no substitute for the journal of opinion that flowed more freely through the snail-
mail system in the past.
Geoffrey Cowan formerly directed Voice of America and is a professor at University of
Southern California. His essay ―Reporters and Rhetoric‖ discusses rhetoric deployed by the
administration in recent events in Iraq. For example, there was a political debate over
media reports of the so-called ―surge‖ of troops in Iraq that Democrats called ―escalation.‖
Also, the government resisted all media efforts, led by NBC-TV, to declare that ―civil war‖
had broken out in Iraq. Fox TV commentator Bill O‘Reilly insisted it was ―out-of-control
chaos, not civil war.‖ Noting Orwell‘s admonition, Cowan urges that we continue to ―struggle
against the abuse of language.‖
In ―Lessons from the War Zone,‖ Farnaz Fassihi, an Iranian American born in the United
States of America, discusses ethics and dilemmas of journalists. She worked as a journalist
post-9/11 in both Afghanistan and Iraq. Fassihi ponders the role of a journalist who hears of
an impending attack on U.S. troops. Does she have a duty to inform the troops, thus
augmenting the news, or does she remain neutral to just report events? If a journalist
Previous Page Next Page