Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 56
Treatment addresses this pathological split between mind and body. In promoting this,
Farber again emphasizes the necessity for the therapist to recognize the meaning of this
behavior and the understanding that patients do what they do, no matter how hurtful, to
feel better.
To begin to change this course of action, the therapist needs to moderate each patient‘s
harsh judgments about the self. For example, the patient might feel disgust at feeling turned
on by the self-harming behavior. The tendency to have harsh attitudes toward these
regressive episodes will need to be challenged, and it is an important step for the patient to
develop empathy toward herself. If the therapist can explore all of this in a nonjudgmental
fashion and begin to look at the connection to the past, the patient‘s harsh attitude might be
modified. Helping the patient link present behavior with repressed or dissociated feelings can
not only aid in awareness of the full meaning of the behavior, but also increase awareness of
feelings and the ability to put emotions into words rather than express them through
enactments. Furthermore, Farber points out that the therapist‘s attitude of strength, vitality,
and humor is needed in order to tolerate the patient‘s aggression (and seductiveness), and
to resist either rescuing the patient (who might demand to be rescued), or getting pulled into
retaliating during dramatic enactments that might occur. If the therapist can recognize and
reflect on what has occurred, enactments that generate from the patient‘s intense
sadomasochistic relationship style developed in the past can be a positive and useful force
that involves a corrective experience for the patient. In the process of recognizing and
reflecting, the therapist must be able to contain powerful affects, listening to her own inner
states and taking responsibility for her own feelings. Farber does an excellent job illustrating,
with her own case material, how the therapist might handle all of these highly charged
situations. She also suggests the need for taking on a body ―caring‖ role in focusing on how
the patient abuses or neglects the body. This focus can become a corrective experience for
the patient while it also might lessen body alienation. Farber returns to concentrating on the
adaptive role of the behavior. She suggests that the therapist might question, ―What does
the self-harm do for you? How does it help you?‖
Themes of victimization and narcissistic entitlement, as well as boundary violations, might
be played out by the patient with the therapist in treatment sessions. I particularly feel that
Farber‘s discussion on a patient‘s sense of specialness and entitlement is quite helpful for
therapists. For example, she wisely suggests that patients might need to look at how
getting others to do what she wants might not always be to her advantage.
Farber encourages the therapist to use supervision or peer-group support, as well as to
work collaboratively with other professionals, such as medical doctors, for the therapist‘s
benefit as well as the patient‘s. In addition to a psychodynamic focus, it is important for the
patient to be armed with a variety of coping mechanisms—i.e., cognitive-behavioral
strategies for tolerating impulses to self-harm and to better manage the dysphonic affect
associated with the impulse. Having these skills will lead to a patient‘s feeling more in
control of her impulses.
Farber has given those of us who work in the cult field a scholarly and clinically informative
work about our patients who suffer and affect us in powerful ways. Many of our patients
who are former cult members enter treatment and don‘t initially reveal self-harming
behaviors, either because of discomfort and shame or because these behaviors are habitual
and dissociated. However, in time, patients often begin to share their secrets with us.
Farber‘s book not only contributes directly to our understanding of self-harm, but also
indirectly increases our understanding and management of potentially harmful symptoms
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 57
that patients might defend against through action and that might elicit strong emotions in
ourselves.
Lorna Goldberg, M.S.W., L.C.S.W.
Shattered Dreams: My Life as a Polygamist’s Wife
Irene Spencer, Hatchett Book Groups/Center Street, New York, 2007. ISBN-13:
9781599957197 (hardcover). $24.99. 400 pages.
Escape
Carolyn Jessop with Laura Palmer, Broadway Books, New York, 2007. ISBN-10:
0767927575 ISBN-13: 978-0767927574 (paperback). $14.95 ($10.17
Amazon.com). 448 pages.
Stolen Innocence: My Story of Growing Up in a Polygamous Sect, Becoming
a Teenage Bride, and Breaking Free of Warren Jeffs
Elissa Wall with Lisa Pulitzer. HarperCollins (William Morrow Imprint), New York,
2008. ISBN-10: 0061628018 ISBN-13: 978-0739496343 (hardcover). $25.95
($17.13, Amazon.com). 448 pages.
Books by Elissa Wall and Carolyn Jessop, born and raised in the polygamous Fundamentalist
Latter Day Saints (FLDS), tell gripping though very different tales of their lives, first as
children, then as unwilling wives in the isolated, tightly controlled sect, who eventually
managed to leave. Irene Spencer, a generation older, describes life in the polygamous
Colonia LeBaron group, a less-tightly-controlled polygamous community. Her involvement
was entirely voluntary, and the pains and hardships she experienced seem almost inevitable
concomitants of a polygamous relationship.
Irene, author of Shattered Dreams, was born in 1937, the 4th of 6 children born to her
mother and the 13th of 31 children of her father, a fireman in the Salt Lake City area. Irene
was early indoctrinated into the practice of polygamy with its promise of future glory for
those who hold fast to ―The Principle,‖ as it is called. She early learned that asking
questions showed ―disrespect‖ and ―lack of faith,‖ and also that her family‘s adherence to
The Principle was a secret. It was a secret difficult for a child to keep, as shown by her
amusing tale of three 5-year-olds marching together into public kindergarten and explaining
to the teacher that, although they all had the same last name, the same address, and the
same father, they were not triplets and had different birthdays and different mothers.
Irene‘s childhood was marked by poverty. Her father, struggling to support his large family
on a fireman‘s income, developed a severe drinking problem and when Irene was 5 years
old, her mother left, taking her children with her. Years of living on welfare ensued. When
Irene was 12, her mother embarked on a homesteading venture and shortly thereafter
married again, an abusive monogamist whom Irene disliked. She coped with the situation in
part by long visits to her Aunt Rhea, her mother‘s half-sister and her father‘s first wife. Aunt
Rhea had also left her husband but remained a committed polygamist. She lived in
Hurricane, Utah, a small town not far from the FLDS center, then known as Short Creek
(now Hildale-Colorado City). Aunt Rhea often took the family to Short Creek, where young
Irene experienced the liberating feeling of being among her own kind, no longer having to
conceal her core beliefs.
Among the teenaged girls in Short Creek, marriage was a hot topic. Girls were selected for
marriage by men who received word from God that a particular girl was to be ―sealed‖ to
him. This caused confusion about some of the more attractive girls, as several different men
might get the same word from God about the same girl. This eventually led to the Prophet‘s
decision that only marriages revealed by God to him were acceptable.
Previous Page Next Page