Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 25
B. Affect (Dys)Regulation
Research on narcissists demonstrates that they ―are challenged both by the presence of
strong affects [i.e., emotions], especially rage, shame, and envy, and by the low tolerance
of the nature and intensity of such feelings‖ (Ronningstam 2005, 83 see American
Psychological Association 2000). While Lucian‘s account gives no indication that Alexander
feels any shame or envy, he does demonstrate ―intense aggressive reactions to threats to
self-esteem‖ (Ronningstam 2005, 92). In essence, after being both assailed and insulted by
Lucian‘s quite serious hand-bite upon their meeting, Alexander launches a plot to kill him. I
will return to this plot in a moment.
C. Interpersonal Relationships
Narcissism hinders and often prevents those who are afflicted with it from establishing
lasting and meaningful social relationships. These people ―are usually identified by their
specific interpersonal pattern with a more or less overtly arrogant and haughty attitude, and
entitled and controlling behavior‖ (Ronningstam 2005, 99 see American Psychiatric
Association 2000). They have a sense of entitlement, either an impaired ability to feel
empathy or no ability to feel it at all. They also demonstrate ―interpersonal control and
hostility‖ or are ―interpersonally exploitative‖ (Ronninstam 2005, 99–100 American
Psychiatric Association 2000). Again, glimpses into Alexander‘s life indicate that he has
dramatic issues regarding his interpersonal relationships.
One pronouncement from the oracle sums up Alexander‘s sense of entitlement. In a
message for the crowds that are swarming to Glycon and its ‗prophet‘, the snake-god
reputedly tells them: ―I care not so much for possessions, but I care for my prophet‖ (Alex.,
24). To be clear on the point, Alexander uses the scam of the talking god-snake to instruct
worshippers to give him gifts and money. This drive for gifts regardless of worshippers‘
financial situation suggests lack of empathy, but his blatant exploitation of the sick confirms
it (Alex., 28). So, too, does his exploitation of the rich Macedonian woman, whom he and
his initial co-conspirator drain financially by playing to her vanity (Alex., 6). Not
surprisingly, he thinks of the ordinary (and not so ordinary) people whom he bamboozles as
―the thick-headed and simple minded‖—a phrase that appears in one translation simply as
the ―fat-heads and simpletons‖ (Alex., 9 see Fowler and Fowler [trans.] 1905).
The sixth characteristic of narcissistic personality disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical
Manual states that a person with it ―is interpersonally exploitative‖ (American Psychiatric
Association 2000). From Lucian‘s account, it is clear that Alexander bases his entire career
upon exploiting people, through fake tablets, a fabricated god-birth, and elaborately
deceptive oracular processes. For scholarly reasons, however, it is worth focusing for a
moment on the act of burying tablets that contained a message about the gods, Apollo and
Aslepius, moving to Abonuteichos (Alex., 10). C. P. Jones was rather easy on Alexander
(and, by extension, Alexander‘s accomplice) regarding this act, offering: ―The device of
buried tablets is a well-known one, though it is not necessary to suppose with Lucian that it
was a cold-blooded forgery. It may rather have been self-delusion, or a fabrication designed
to serve higher ends‖ (Jones 1986, 136). He then cites another scholar who adduces ―the
parallel of Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon‖ (Jones 1986, 134 n. 15). It turns out,
however, that Smith himself probably suffered from the same disorder as does Alexander—
malignant narcissism.
D. Malignant Narcissism
The psychiatrist, Robert D. Anderson, who identifies this disorder in Smith, draws
conclusions about Mormonism‘s founder that bear strong resemblance to traits in the
account about Alexander. Indicating that ―lesser forms of malignant narcissism may be
characterized by sexual promiscuity and/or financial exploitation of followers‖ (Anderson
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 26
1999, 230), Anderson then focuses his comments directly on the American ‗prophet‘
himself:
In the case of Joseph Smith, the theme of deceiving self and others is not a
thread, but a steel cable. It began with money-digging and seer stone
peeping… after the Book of Mormon was published, it continued with his
sexual conquests under the guise of religious practice (Anderson 1999, 230–
231).
Money digging was a fraud in which a person claimed to use magic in order to uncover
buried treasure (Anderson 1999, 21 see 62 n. 87), and seer stone peeping was a related
fraud in which a person claimed to have special rocks through which one looked in order to
find ―desired objects‖ (Anderson 1999, 21‘ see 79). He supposedly used a seer stone to find
the gold plates on which was written the Book of Mormon (Anderson 1999, 70, 81). (Worth
mentioning is that Alexander, like Smith, claims that he can help people find buried treasure
[Alex., 24]). Consequently, the pattern of interpersonal exploitation exists with each of the
two religious leaders, but the forms that the exploitation takes are culturally and historically
specific.
On sexual matters, both religious founders seem to have used their status as religious
figures to gain access to members of the opposite sex. Indeed, both seem to have practiced
polygamy. Smith‘s practice was, of course, well known, having at least thirty-three wives
and possibly as many as forty-one. Even when he was in his late thirties, one of his
polygamous wives was fourteen years old, another was either fourteen or fifteen, and two
were sixteen (Compton 1997, 4–8, 486–534). Neither the numbers of Alexander‘s partners
nor their ages are known, since Lucian says only that the ―prophet‖ was ―ruining women
promiscuously…. Many women even boasted that they had borne children by Alexander, and
their husbands confirmed the truth of their claims‖ (Alex., 42).17 Alexander also has a
sexual habit, however, that Smith did not: pederasty. Once again, such a habit is in line
with existing research on malignant narcissists.
Summarizing issues of sexuality among these types of narcissists, Ronningstam reports
that:
...manifestations of malignant narcissism can involve sexual perversions
where aggression and interpersonal sadism infuse with sexual desire and
excitement. Such perverse behaviors are also characterized by non-
differentiation or mixture of sexual aims, zones, organs, and gender.
(Ronningstam 2005, 107)
This summary of sexuality among many malignant narcissists provides a context for
Lucian‘s description of Alexander‘s activities with boys:
Though he warned everyone to abstain from having sex with boys as being an
unholy practice, this prince of virtue had an artful scheme for his own
advantage. He used to order the cities of Pontus and Paphlagonia to send him
choirboys for a three-year period, to serve him by singing hymns to the god.
They had to examine, choose, and send the noblest born, the most youthful
and the handsomest. He then kept them locked up and treated them like
bought slaves, sleeping with them and using them offensively in every way. It
was his habit never to welcome and embrace anyone over 18 with a kiss on
the lips he gave his hand to others to be kissed, and kissed only those in the
bloom of youth, who were said to be ―within the kiss.‖ (Alex., 41)
Thus, according to Lucian‘s account, Alexander establishes a regional homosexual child and
teenage procurement ring around towns near the Black Sea, using religion as his guise.18
Previous Page Next Page