Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 19
Narcissistic Fraud in the Ancient World: Lucian’s Account
of Alexander of Abonuteichos and the Cult of Glycon1
Stephen A. Kent, Ph.D.
University of Alberta
Abstract
Based upon Lucian of Samosata‘s account of Alexander of Abonuteichos, who
is the founder of the Glycon cult in second century Asia Minor, I argue that
Alexander likely is a malignant narcissist. I construct this argument by
summarizing Alexander‘s behaviors, and then showing how those behaviors
seemingly relate to modern psychiatric descriptions of narcissists. As such,
Alexander‘s behaviors have parallels with several modern cult leaders.
Moreover, Alexander‘s attempts to kill his critics suggests that he is a
particular type of narcissist—a malignant narcissist—making him a dangerous
and vengeful personality.
A single, but rather detailed, account of a newly formed cult and its leader survives from the
ancient world, written by a rhetorician named Lucian of Samosata (now Samsat, Turkey).
He is born around the year 120 A.D., lives for periods of time in Athens and Egypt, and dies
during or probably soon after 180 (see Costa 2005, vii Edwards 1949 Jones 1986, 8, 17).2
To a friend, he writes a scathing exposé of Alexander of Abonuteichos,3 and this account
surely ranks as among the earliest reports of sectarian malfeasance in Western civilization.
In and of itself, the account is of interest to persons who concern themselves with religious
wrongdoing in the contemporary world, since Alexander‘s deceits have broad parallels with
those of some more recent sectarian founders. Of some importance, however, is our ability
to apply contemporary psychiatric research to gain insight into the mind and motivations of
this manipulative, deceitful leader. In essence, I suggest that a mental disorder quite
recognizable among psychiatrists and clinicians likely is behind the actions of this cult figure
who lives some eighteen centuries ago. Since we have mounting evidence of the role that
mental disorders play in sectarian formation in modern times (Kent 2006 Lys 2005 Raine
2005), we can begin to explore the possibility that these disorders have played generative
roles in the creation of abusive religions for centuries if not millennia.
I contribute to this explorative possibility by first summarizing the account that Lucian
provides of Alexander, followed by an interpretation of Alexander‘s behaviors and attitudes
according to contemporary research on narcissistic personality disorder. More specifically, I
argue that Lucian‘s account strongly suggests that Alexander is a particularly dangerous
type of narcissist called a malignant narcissist, because of the way that he responds to
persons who appear to threaten either his public image or his fraudulent operation. By
making this argument, I place Alexander in the company of some modern sectarian leaders
who share similar traits.
Lucian’s Account
Calling Alexander a great ―villain‖ and a ―quack‖ (the latter because of his medical claims
[Alex., 1, see 5]),4 Lucian writes a multi-page account of both his ―daring schemes and his
chicaneries‖ (Alex.,, 1). Scholars generally agree that this account is based upon an actual
figure, ―and its factual basis [is] firmly established‖ by various archeological finds (Branham
1989, 182 see Anderson 1976, 72 Jones 1986, 133–148). Even with these finds as
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 20
support, however, the possibility always exists that Lucian spins some of his information
through his favorite literary motifs (see Anderson 1976, 16–19 Jones 1986, 146).
In any case, Alexander is born sometime ―between about 105 and 115 in Abonuteichos, a
small port-city on the coast of the Black Sea…‖ (Jones 1986, 134). In his prime, this cult
leader:
...was tall and good-looking, really god-like, with a fair complexion, a beard
which was not very thick, hair partly natural and partly false, but so well
matched that most people couldn‘t tell the difference. His eyes flashed like
one possessed, while his voice was very clear and pleasant.... [I]n
intelligence, sagacity, and shrewdness he was far ahead of everyone and as
for an enquiring mind, a readiness to learn, memory, and a natural capacity
for knowledge—every single one of these qualities he had in excess for every
occasion. But he used them for the worst purposes, and, equipped with noble
instruments, he lost no time in becoming the most accomplished of those who
have been notorious for wickedness. (Alex., 3–4)
His immodesty is sufficiently great that he ―claimed to resemble Pythagoras‖ (Alex., 4)—a
comparison that Lucian scorns.5
While not considering Alexander to be anywhere near the man that Pythagoras was, Lucian
nevertheless realizes that Alexander has skills—all of which he uses for evil purposes:
I ask you to imagine and carefully picture the most complex psychological
temperament, consisting of lying, perjury, and malice, a temperament which
is unscrupulous, daring, reckless, energetic in forwarding its own schemes,
persuasive, plausible, making a pretense of virtue, and with an appearance
totally opposite to its real purpose. Indeed, no one who met him for the first
time failed to go away with the impression that he was the worthiest and
most honest of men, and the most artless and unaffected as well. In addition
to all this he had the character of a high achiever and of one who designed
nothing petty, but always had his mind set on the highest things. (Alex., 4)
As we shall see, all of the ―highest things‖ onto which he fixes his mind actually are (as
Lucian portrays them) very evil, exploitative, and self-serving.
In his youth, Alexander is (according to Lucian) a male prostitute, who ―sold his favors
freely and went with anyone who would pay for his company‖ (Alex., 5).6 Among his lovers,
Alexander has a man whom Lucian described as:
...a quack, the type who offer magic spells and marvellous incantations,
charms for love affairs, afflictions for your enemies, discoveries of buried
treasure, and inheritances to estates. This man saw that he was a talented
lad and very well suited to assist him in his dealings, and was just as
enamoured of his own villainy as he himself was of the boy‘s beauty. So he
trained him well, and made continual use of him as his assistant, servant, and
attendant. (Alex., 5)
After his teacher dies, Alexander joins forces with ―a much more disgusting character‖ than
even his mentor had been (Alex., 6). Working with this accomplice, the two ―travelled
around, practising witchcraft and quakery, and fleecing the thick-headed, as charlatans
usually refer to the public‖ (Alex., 6). As Lucian observes:
...they easily perceived that human life is at the mercy of the two great
tyrannies of hope and fear, and that anyone who could exploit both of them
would very quickly get rich. For they saw that both he who fears and he who
Previous Page Next Page