Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 14
I shall discuss how this reconnection with the pre-cult personality occurs, and also look at
whether integration, or chewing over and digestion, are required for one to recover.
Recovery: Integration or Chewing Over and Digestion
Reber &Reber (2001) say that integration brings the person ―into a harmonious or
coordinated whole by rearranging, organizing, and occasionally adding or deleting elements
or parts‖ (p. 360). Van der Hart et al. (2006) note that integration is a bringing together of
a split whole.
One of the themes that came out of my unpublished M.A. research, What Helps Ex-cult
Members Recover from an Abusive Cult Experience?, was ―getting rid of the cult pseudo-
personality.‖ When I went back to my research, I was taken aback at how I had worded
this. I questioned the ‗‖getting rid of‖ bit I asked myself whether integration of that part,
as one would integrate a dissociated part, was, in fact, more appropriate. However, on
reflection, I do not think so. I think ―getting rid of‖ in a nonviolent way is actually what is
needed—chewing and digesting the introjected cult pseudo-personality rather than
integrating it. So, whilst the above definition would seem to fit the process of reconnecting
to the pre-cult personality, I suggest that it is not enough because the cult pseudo-
personality is not a dissociated part, and integrating it would entail keeping parts of the cult
experience that need to be eliminated. I will now discuss how to ―get rid of‖ the pseudo-
personality.
Gestalt writers Perls et al. (1951) use the analogy between the teeth and developmental
stages. The toothless baby takes in predigested food the toddler‘s milk teeth develop, and
he or she eats soft food the adult teeth develop, and the young child starts asking why,
what is that for, and so on. Children want to chew over what is coming in and decide for
themselves (they do not want to simply introject what is given to them). In a healthy
environment, this behaviour occurs increasingly with age.
Perls et al. (1951, p. 189) state:
Physical food properly digested and assimilated, becomes part of the
organism but food which ―rests heavy on the stomach‖ is an introject
[emphasis added]. You are aware of it and want to throw it up. If you do so
you get it ―out of the system.‖ Suppose, instead, you suppress your
discomfort, nausea, and tendency to spew it forth. Then you ―keep it down‖
and either succeed, finally, in painfully digesting it or else it poisons you.
I suggest that, with the cult-pseudo personality (Magdalene), the individual is unaware of
the poison and discomfort. The discomfort is suppressed within the pre-cult personality
(Jenny).
Perls et al. (1951, p. 189) go on to suggest that to
eliminate introjects from your personality the problem is not to accept and
integrate dissociated parts of yourself. Rather, it is to become aware of
what is not truly yours, to acquire a selective and critical attitude toward what
is offered you, and, above all, to develop the ability to ―bite off‖ and ―chew‖
experience so as to extract its healthy nourishment. [bold added]
And, I would add, to eliminate from the system that which is not nourishing.
To return to the analogy of the tarmac or asphalt, when the road is finally disintegrated, it is
possible to dig the tarmac back into the soil and perhaps obtain some benefit from it.
Hassan (2000) states that it is important not to discard the entire cult identity, but to create
a new post-cult identity that incorporates the most valuable and healthy parts of the pre-
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 15
cult, cult, and ―authentic‖ identities (p. 184). My proposal of chewing over and digesting or
eliminating introjects supports this view.
To summarise this section, I suggest that the pseudo-personality is not a dissociated part
that needs integrating nor is it doubling, false self, or simply adaptation. Instead, it is an
introjected part that needs chewing over and digesting, allowing what is nourishing to
remain and eliminating the rest.
Treatment Implications
How both ex-cult members and their helpers or therapists conceptualise the problem of
recovery is vitally important. I suggest that the concepts of introjection, chewing over, and
digestion might be more helpful than dissociation and integration.
I now will give four case examples of what I mean by chewing over, digesting, and
eliminating the cult pseudo-personality, and one example of integrating dissociation and
then chewing over, digesting, and eliminating the cult-pseudo personality:
1. Jenny became judgmental, religious, serious, and compliant as she introjected the
cult personality, Magdalene. As Jenny/Magdalene moved away from the cult, and
chewed over the beliefs of the cult and what she had become, she returned to her
pre-cult personality, exhibiting humour, playfulness, assertiveness, and
compassion. She decided that this way of being was more consistent with her own
view of Christianity as opposed to the cult‘s view. And so she chose to take a
nonjudgmental stance rather than the judgmental stance she had learned in the
cult.
2. Magdalene had to sleep with men—i.e., prostitute herself—for the sake of fulfilling
the aims of the cult. Jenny did not need to integrate the part of Magdalene that did
these things, but she needed to be compassionate with herself, to see these actions
as part of the ―bounded choice‖ (Lalich, 2004) that made sense within the cult, and
to make her own decision about her actions in the future regarding sleeping with
men (chewing over and digestion). She also needed a good deal of support in order
to recover from the trauma of it all, including the resulting post-traumatic stress
and her negative self-image.
3. A male heterosexual client in his 30s joined a Buddhist cult and discovered the
leader was homosexual and expected all the men to be the same. The client
complied with this because, as it was explained to him, doing so was more
spiritual—his ―bounded choice‖ (Lalich 2004). When he left the cult, he thought
through carefully (chewed over), with my support, whether he was actually
homosexual, and he realised that he had known since he was a teenager that he
was not. Hence, he reverted to being heterosexual. He did not integrate this
homosexual part but rather chewed over and challenged the cult‘s view. In
digesting his experience and deciding what he wanted to be in the future, he
―eliminated‖ the cult‘s view and reverted to his pre-cult stance on his sexuality.
4. A woman in her 40s had been told by the cult that her father had sexually abused
her, and this affected her deeply, causing her terrible trauma and resulting in a
severe split within the family. When she came to me for therapy, we explored this
possibility. As she chewed the issue over, she realised she had no memories at all
of being abused by her father. She checked the claim out with him and her mother,
and they confirmed that he had not abused her. She did not need to integrate this
belief she needed to chew it over, digest it, eliminate it, and return to her pre-cult
view of her parents and reconnect with them.
Previous Page Next Page