Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 40
anti-Aum movement, both of which were supported by human-rights activists, government,
and police, was very complicated. A conspiracy theory is not necessary to explain the facts,
especially since there is no direct evidence of government manipulation of anti-Aum
residents.
Regional Case
Chitose-Karasuyama
Chitose-Karasuyama, a quiet residential area in Setagaya Ward in Tokyo, is a 15-minute
ride from Shinjuku Station. If you pass the Setagaya Karasuyama Community Center in
front of the station, cross the old Koshu Highway, and follow a side street for about 20
meters, you will find more than 100 Aleph members residing together under Fumihiro Joyu
in the five-story Chitose-Karasuyama GS Heim condominium and the two 2-story
apartments across from it. Located in front of the Heim condo is a police box where the
police officers maintain order by monitoring Aleph‘s movements till late at night. During the
day, two people from the Council for Countermeasures stand guard.
Ever since the Aleph members moved into Karasuyama, an anti-Aleph movement consisting
of local residents has been active. This period, between late 2000 and 2005, can be divided
into three shorter periods. Period One was when Setagaya Ward was campaigning as a
municipality against the residence registration of Aleph members in 2001 and 2002 (Note
1). In Period Two, Setagaya Ward exchanged information with municipalities engaged in
similar disputes with Aum and switched its strategy to urging relevant agencies and the
federal government to carry out anti-Aum countermeasures. At the same time, the Council
for Countermeasures explored various options by regularly holding study group meetings on
the cult issue. Period Three was the era of the ―fight against the fading of the movement,‖
according to the Council for Countermeasures. Although a very small number of ward
councilmen and officials still maintain a strong interest in their local residents, local
administrators can do little but conduct surveillance. The morale of the condominium
residents is still high, yet there is a slight inconsistency in their principles one is willing to
accept a ―soft-landing‖ approach, while the other insists that all Aleph members in the area
must leave. In November 2003, the condominium residents launched the ―Citizens‘ Group to
Protect Setagaya Ward from Aum,‖ apart from the existing Council for Countermeasures.
While the Council‘s goal is to bring about comprehensive anti-Aleph legislation, the
condominium residents want to see more direct, short-term anti-Aleph movements and
measures.
Period One
On December 19, 2000, thirteen followers of Aleph separately presented their moving-in
notification to twelve branch offices of Setagaya Ward simultaneously, apparently to conceal
that it was a group relocation. The ward office became aware that they were Aleph followers
on the 21st, proceeded to cancel their newly created resident cards, and deleted them from
the resident register. Nonetheless, followers were able to move into the first and second
floor of GS Heim on the 20th, because the owner of those floors made a direct lease to Aleph
without notifying his condominium neighbors. Anxious condominium residents gave
followers a written request to leave the building.
Aleph members, however, claimed their presence to be lawful and conducted reconstruction
work on the 1st floor for a seminary hall and on the 2nd floor for Fumihiro Joyu, a new leader
of Aleph. On January 4th, 2001, a right-wing organization member who hated Aleph, fired
four bullets at the first floor and was subsequently arrested. While condo residents
anxiously consulted with the ward office and police, Aleph members moved into two
apartments on the opposite side of GS Heim owned by the same person. As of 2006, there
are more than one hundred members of Aleph in the condominium and two apartments.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 41
The Karasuyama area Aum Shinrikyo Measures resident council was formed on January 9,
2001 and consisted of the condominium residents, neighborhood and storekeepers‘
association, PTA members, and volunteers who were concerned about Aleph‘s activities.
This group conducted protest rallies and monitored and filed a petition against Aleph
members with the Setagaya Ward office. Its risk-management office offered consultation for
residents and study meetings, and advised school route changes for children.
The reason the ward directly opposed Aleph was that Aleph demanded that the deletion of
their resident cards be suspended via the Tokyo District Court on December 25, 2000,
claiming that the deletions violated a basic resident registry law and infringed their freedom
of movement and right to vote, which was guaranteed by the Constitution.
The court ruled in favor of Aleph, although the ward immediately filed an appeal. In April,
the Tokyo High Court overruled the District Court decision and rejected Aleph‘s petition, on
the grounds that the ward had the authority to investigate concerning the acceptance of
resident cards and Aleph had interfered with its investigation by applying for the movement
of resident cards separately. Aleph then made a special appeal. In June, the Supreme Court
overruled the High Court decision on the grounds that the ward did not have the authority
to investigate concerning the acceptance of resident-card movement and that the deletion
had caused serious damage to Aleph members. By this decision, the ward was compelled to
recover the resident cards. Furthermore, at the trial in which Aleph claimed damages from
the ward office, the Tokyo District Court ruled in favor of Aleph and ordered the ward to pay
compensation. The ward office appealed, however, but this was rejected by the Tokyo High
Court in May 2002, and the ward office finally renounced an appellate procedure to the
Supreme Court. As a result, the ward had to pay a fifteen million yen settlement to Aleph.
The Tokyo District Court also admitted other claims of Aleph concerning the case of the
moving-in notification, which had been rejected in March and April 2002.
Period Two
In the activity of the second period, while the residential council also held another study
meeting on the ―cult‖ problem and sought countermeasures, the ward communicated
mutually with local governments that had the same problem and formulated a strategy in
conjunction with concerned government agencies in quest of measures against Aleph.
The ward had to change the policy of direct opposition to Aleph, which had resulted in the
verdict of unlawful rejection of resident card moving. The ward set up a task force on the
Aleph problem in Congress and hosted town and village liaison meetings for Aum Shinrikyo
countermeasures in May, 2003 and requested action of the Prime Minister, Minister of Public
Management, Home Affairs, Minister of Justice, Director-General of Public Security
Investigation, and Director-General of the National Police Agency. The ward also enforced
―the Setagaya Ward safe and sound community building‖ regulation from June 2003.
Although the activity of the ward and the residential council was well-known in the
Karasuyama area, as seen in the example of the banner ―opposition to Aum‖ on the ward
office building, not all residents of Setagaya Ward shared the same sense of crisis. This
holds true for residents in the Karasuyama area. The anxiety of the condominium residents
who lived by the headquarters of Aleph was different from that of local residents in general,
which caused the differences in their struggles for opposition measures. The menace of
Aleph for Setagaya Ward and its residents was so abstract that they just wanted to protect
their ideal community. In contrast, for residents compelled to share a condominium with
Aleph members, their living environment changed completely, since daily they had to face
Aleph members and were beset with troubles.
From my in-depth interviews with condominium residents, the following grievances came to
the fore: 1) chanting and voices leaking out from the ceremony hall on the first floor, and
Previous Page Next Page