Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 51
The Family prompted her to say, knowing it is not true but unable to decipher lies at that
time of her life. The conversation between Celeste and the research expert in the book is a
pivotal passage of evidence for the unreliability of research data collected from current cult
members. It appears from this account of the interview that Celeste easily convinces the
scholarly expert that she (Celeste) was not abused. The expert witness scholar of ―new
religious movements‖ seemed to convince the Lord Justice Ward that abuse was not
widespread in the group, which may have influenced Ward‘s ruling to allow the child to
remain in The Family.
Soon after this incident, Celeste, among the hundreds of teens in the group, is singled out
to live in the most secret of Family homes and meet the top leaders of the cult after the
death of Moses David (Berg)—namely, Maria (Karen Zerby) and her consort, Peter
Amsterdam. Celeste is told that Maria received ―prophecies‖ (spiritual messages) from the
deceased Berg and the Lord to call this home the ―house of the open pussy.‖ Here Celeste
sees firsthand that the sexual activities that had destroyed her childhood happiness were
initiated and blessed by these same top leaders. Although no turning point is without
preceding doubts, it is here that Celeste has her epiphany that The Family leaders are not
the God-sent messengers of love as she had been taught all her life. She leaves The Family
after a short visit to her beloved father, who refuses to accept responsibility or hold his
leaders accountable for his daughter‘s abuse.
The second story is told by Juliana, who is born from a union of Celeste‘s father and one of
the many Family sisters he ―mates‖ over the years to serve his sexual needs. Juliana suffers
immense emotional pain as a result of the separation from both her parents, and she is
depicted as the lost child whom nobody loves. She is subjected not only to sexual abuse but
also unrestrained emotional and physical abuse that she recounts with chilling detachment.
Desperately longing for adults who will love her, she secretly wishes that the strange Indian
couple who knock on the door of The Family home one day looking for a child to adopt will
take her. Her father, who brags he has fathered more than twenty children, appears not to
know of his children‘s whereabouts, living conditions, or personal anguish.
Juliana is rarely with any of her siblings as she is shuttled from home to home and suffers
under various guardians who appear to care little for her safety or happiness. Despite being
taught all her life that ―we are all one family,‖ when Juliana learns of a biological relative,
she clings to the idea of a sibling bond. This hope is depicted in the scene in which she
fondly remembers a photograph of a little girl in India who her father casually states is one
of Juliana‘s sisters. In the end, while on a visit with her older siblings in London, after they
had already left The Family, Juliana has her epiphany and begins the turning point in her
slow journey out of the ―bizarre upside-down world that made no sense.‖
Readers might be astounded that it takes so long after her revelation for Juliana to
physically leave the group, but it‘s important to bear in mind that she endured a most
intense socialization and isolation from the rest of the world. In her story we see the long-
term processes and effects of such extreme indoctrination. In the end, even while Juliana
appears free to travel, leave, and marry according to her own desires, she is tied by strings
we cannot distinguish in shorter versions of these lives, such as those presented in scholarly
publications. Although some scholars hotly debate and debunk the ―brainwashing‖ process,
evidence of the mind-control tactics groups such as the Children of God use is seen in
Juliana‘s extended withdrawal from the group. Apologist scholars for cults often use the fact
that members are free to leave when they want as proof that brainwashing or mind control
does not exist. However, Juliana‘s account, and other stories about leaving cults, reveals
the superficial level of such an argument.
The third story is told by Kristina, the younger of the two sisters born to Simon Peter and
his first wife. Kristina is separated from Celeste and her father soon after her birth in India.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 52
She lives her childhood with a malicious stepfather who enforces strict rules on his new
stepchildren and seems eager to follow Berg‘s and Zerby‘s directives on sexual activities
with children.
While her mother is often bedridden with difficult pregnancies, Kristina is sexually abused by
her stepfather. The abuse began when she was three years old and he performed oral sex
on her as she lay on her top bunk bed.
As he continued with similar sexual behaviors along with increased physical abuse, other
men in the group forced Kristina to engage in sexual activities she detested but endured in
silence. Kristina‘s molestation is conducted mostly in private. She is forced to have sex in
secret with relative strangers as she travels among small missionary homes in India and
other Eastern countries. For example, her stepfather hides his sexual exploitation of Kristina
from her mother. Kristina describes her mother as living in a trance while in The Family, and
it appears that her mother is not cognizant of her children‘s abuse until she is finally out of
the group.
Kristina‘s accounts of sexual activities with adults appear to be more hidden that those of
her sisters, yet one might wonder why she does not inform anyone of this behavior. Recall
that Kristina has read The Family literature in which the group‘s leader and prophet
endorses adult sex with children, so she has no reason to report this behavior as abuse to
her mother or other group members who should have protected her. She also knows that
whatever occurs in The Family is not to be revealed to those outside the group, and she
learns to live a ―double life‖ when she is around ―systemites‖ (those living outside the
Family). Yet the most redeeming characters in Kristina‘s story are in fact those systemites
she comes in contact with throughout her travels. It is by observing the differences between
the behaviors of systemites and the behaviors of adults in The Family that Kristina is
encouraged to testify with her mother in a court case involving child-abuse accusations.
Unfortunately, their testimony appears to garner less respect than that produced by the
scholarly experts with their theoretical alleged insights. It is two other systemites, her
grandparents on her stepfather‘s side, who defend her when a teenaged Kristina is trying to
force an apology from her stepfather (their son) for the sexual abuse she suffered as a
child. Overhearing the girl‘s plea, the elderly couple storm into the room, condemning their
son for the accusations they were loathe to accept previously.
In my mind, the support by Kristina‘s grandparents represents a dilemma we find in
academia. This incident is symbolic of how academics seem to find it difficult to accept
stories of abuse as valid until the stories hit home in a personal way. This may be why
scholarly research, which is biased toward producing findings that support the reigning
paradigms, ignores the anecdotal evidence in favor of dissenting theoretical views.
Regrettably, the popular theories on cults (new religious movements) have too easily
dismissed the stories of child abuse in cults as ―atrocity tales.‖ Only those scholars who
listen to stories such as those written in this book have honestly examined the issue of cult
abuse. And these scholars are typically not published in the academic journals that would
allow their theories to receive attention on a broader scale. Thus, the issue of why, how,
and which cults engage in this type of abuse, and how to stop it, is rarely addressed in
academic circles.
In Not Without My Sisters, the apologist scholars are subtly exposed as naïve or misguided.
In their brave effort to provide an honest account, the sisters reveal how the experts are
too easily convinced of The Family‘s innocence, the blamelessness of the leaders, and the
extent of the abuse. The authors suggest veiled deceit on the part of the academic expert
witnesses.
In contrast, in the book Jesus Freaks, Lattin does not engage in subtleties but explicitly and
intentionally exposes the apologists‘ agenda by devoting an entire chapter to their scholarly
Previous Page Next Page