Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 43
Aleph insisted that visitors be selected cautiously, according to their understanding of
religion. Aleph favored advocates of human rights and religious tolerance.
On April 24th, 2002, a meeting entitled ―Dialog with Aleph and viewing of the second
documentary film of Aum „A2‟” was scheduled to be held at the court of GS Heim and to
include the film producer, social critics, and the owner of the Aum residence. But residents
strongly opposed it because they were offended by a phrase in the organizers‘ commercial
leaflet that contained part of the ruling by the Tokyo District Court in the resident card suit,
which stated, ―The dialog between Aleph and residents should aim at securing public safety
and promoting mutual understanding—simply regarding Aleph with hostility not only robs
everybody of an opportunity for mutual understanding, but makes the solution of the
problem more difficult.‖ This pronouncement of the Tokyo District Court to Setagaya Ward
referring to the municipality‘s duty was intentionally distorted by the meeting organizers
who pointed out that local residents should do the same.
Surely, dialogue is necessary, and the intention of the organizers to create such an
opportunity is laudable. However, to what extent did they conduct this meeting to sway
public opinion, rather than to address the concerns of the condo residents? And what sort of
dialog did they intend to undertake with Aleph rather than the residents? They seemed to
overlook the fact that after two years of arguing over residential problems with Aleph, condo
residents had given up on building mutual trust. Familiarity toward individual Aleph
followers and anger toward a religious body that had responded to the residents in an
inconsistent and remote manner must be distinguished. Frank conversations between Aleph
followers and local opponents are frequently observed, as, for example, ―You should go back
to your parents‘ home. If you defected from Aum, we would take care of you.‖ Yet, we
should also not overlook the fact that the condo residential area is watched by security
police at all hours.
The difficulties faced by the opposition movements of condo residents and locals mirror the
limitations of legal redress and public authority. They have no choice but to follow the
dictates of social ethics and learn to deal with the drawbacks of the situation, what is called
consideration of the rights of a religious minority. Although the construction of a
condominium might be stopped by local residents‘ right to sunlight, the infringement on
quality of life by a specific organization is not regarded as a human-rights violation.
Condominium residents reported that they were closely united by the opposition movement
and sometimes enjoyed small parties and excursions together for a change of pace. The
council members, who included the old chairman, shop owners, housewives, and ward staff,
also valued their relationship. Without the Aleph incidents, they would not have
communicated deeply. Yet, in fairness, despite the deadlock with Aleph, they have reaped
some advantage from the disaster, and they encourage each other so as not to be isolated
individually and see their opposition movement forgotten by the general public.
Recent Aleph
According to several newspapers issued on May 5th, 2006, conflict within Aleph‘s inner
factions was in full swing and would result in its split. This fact was not uncovered by
reporters, but preemptively disclosed by the security police agency, which was concerned
about Aum/Aleph‘s fake dissolution and revival as a new religious group. Responding to this
analysis, the Aum bankruptcy administrator pronounced that even new groups would
assume liability indemnity to the sarin case injured parties.
In recent years, since a leader of Aleph, Fumihiro Joyu, was released, he has vied for power
with higher-ranking disciples of Asahara who were not arrested in the sarin gas attack and
other criminal incidents. He has been seeking to reestablish a new religious group that
breaks with the spiritual tradition of the founder of Aum because the notoriety of Aum and
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 44
Asahara would be an obstacle to group survival in Japan, even if Aleph members made a
monumental effort. Meanwhile, old members who truly believed in Asahara and his mystical
power regarded this idea as disloyal to Aum conventions and formed an anti-Joyu faction.
This is known as the A (Asahara) faction, in contrast to the Joyu faction, the M (Maitreya,
Joyu‘s holy name) faction. Between them there are some believers who have not committed
to either side.
On May 18th, the security police agency disclosed that the M and A factions had each held
spring seminars, and that as a result the M faction had collected approximately $70,000 in
donations from 80 participants, while the A faction had collected $400,000 from 220
participants. Joyu declared, ―We should think about the direction of the Aleph after the
execution of Asahara,‖ which could be scheduled within the next few years because of the
dismissal of Asahara‘s appeal in the Tokyo High Court. Asahara‘s capital punishment was
fixed in September 15, 2006. Some members believe Asahara will not die, even by hanging
however, such a thought is a by-product of shut-in persons who do not accept the real
world. It will be too late to start a new version of Aleph after the death of its founder. M and
A factions were expected to divide their assets and accounts respectively by July 2006. In
May 2007, Joyu separated his faction from Aleph and made a new religion, ―Hikari no wa‖
(Ring of Light), with approximately 200 members (Asahi News, 2007).
Discussions
Resource Mobilization and Cultural Framing
In this section, we discuss the resident movement from the perspective of social movement
theory, which focuses on the mobilization of resources, cultural framing, and political
opportunity (Tarrow, 1998).
The mobilization of resources means how funds and human resources are procured and
utilized in order to have successful social movements. The municipalities took urgent
budgetary steps by allocating approximately $100,000 for residents‘ anti-Aleph movements
in 1999 and 2000, because the Japanese public had already become aware of the treatment
of Aleph members as a social issue after a series of Aum-related incidents. But because this
budget was spent on lawsuits, the residents in Karasuyama were forced to raise funds for
their own activities.
Cultural framing is composed of a social appeal made by a movement, which convinces the
general public of, and enlists them in, the movement‘s cause. What values and interests did
anti-Aleph residents attempt to protect? Of course, mere dislike or fear of a ―cult‖ does not
convince other people who are not directly affected. They need more convincing reasons.
Sometimes that justification is presented by outside parties. Human-rights advocates
provided conflicting abstract arguments, such as ―public well-being for locals,‖ and Aleph
members‘ ―freedom of religion,‖ and ―the freedom and the right to have residence and
education.‖ But did the local people really participate in the movement because of those
ideas? This question must be addressed.
Some municipalities refused to accept Aleph members‘ residence registration on the
grounds of ―uneasy feelings of local residents.‖ They believed that what local residents
demanded was a guarantee of local security, and thus responding to that plea would
correspond to ―public welfare.‖ In response to the claims by the cult and its supporters, as
well as human-rights activists, the municipality insisted, ―(the community‘s) fears are not
gone.‖ Since dialogue was not working, they had no choice but to turn to the legal process.
The rationale of ―public welfare‖ was merely an expression of the municipality‘s view on the
local side, ―fear‖ was the reason for the anti-Aum movement.
It is easy to attribute a disdain for human rights to residents chanting ―Aum, Get Out!‖ or
voicing other hostile expressions and attitudes. For this reason, human-rights advocates
Previous Page Next Page