Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 57
that patients might defend against through action and that might elicit strong emotions in
ourselves.
Lorna Goldberg, M.S.W., L.C.S.W.
Shattered Dreams: My Life as a Polygamist’s Wife
Irene Spencer, Hatchett Book Groups/Center Street, New York, 2007. ISBN-13:
9781599957197 (hardcover). $24.99. 400 pages.
Escape
Carolyn Jessop with Laura Palmer, Broadway Books, New York, 2007. ISBN-10:
0767927575 ISBN-13: 978-0767927574 (paperback). $14.95 ($10.17
Amazon.com). 448 pages.
Stolen Innocence: My Story of Growing Up in a Polygamous Sect, Becoming
a Teenage Bride, and Breaking Free of Warren Jeffs
Elissa Wall with Lisa Pulitzer. HarperCollins (William Morrow Imprint), New York,
2008. ISBN-10: 0061628018 ISBN-13: 978-0739496343 (hardcover). $25.95
($17.13, Amazon.com). 448 pages.
Books by Elissa Wall and Carolyn Jessop, born and raised in the polygamous Fundamentalist
Latter Day Saints (FLDS), tell gripping though very different tales of their lives, first as
children, then as unwilling wives in the isolated, tightly controlled sect, who eventually
managed to leave. Irene Spencer, a generation older, describes life in the polygamous
Colonia LeBaron group, a less-tightly-controlled polygamous community. Her involvement
was entirely voluntary, and the pains and hardships she experienced seem almost inevitable
concomitants of a polygamous relationship.
Irene, author of Shattered Dreams, was born in 1937, the 4th of 6 children born to her
mother and the 13th of 31 children of her father, a fireman in the Salt Lake City area. Irene
was early indoctrinated into the practice of polygamy with its promise of future glory for
those who hold fast to ―The Principle,‖ as it is called. She early learned that asking
questions showed ―disrespect‖ and ―lack of faith,‖ and also that her family‘s adherence to
The Principle was a secret. It was a secret difficult for a child to keep, as shown by her
amusing tale of three 5-year-olds marching together into public kindergarten and explaining
to the teacher that, although they all had the same last name, the same address, and the
same father, they were not triplets and had different birthdays and different mothers.
Irene‘s childhood was marked by poverty. Her father, struggling to support his large family
on a fireman‘s income, developed a severe drinking problem and when Irene was 5 years
old, her mother left, taking her children with her. Years of living on welfare ensued. When
Irene was 12, her mother embarked on a homesteading venture and shortly thereafter
married again, an abusive monogamist whom Irene disliked. She coped with the situation in
part by long visits to her Aunt Rhea, her mother‘s half-sister and her father‘s first wife. Aunt
Rhea had also left her husband but remained a committed polygamist. She lived in
Hurricane, Utah, a small town not far from the FLDS center, then known as Short Creek
(now Hildale-Colorado City). Aunt Rhea often took the family to Short Creek, where young
Irene experienced the liberating feeling of being among her own kind, no longer having to
conceal her core beliefs.
Among the teenaged girls in Short Creek, marriage was a hot topic. Girls were selected for
marriage by men who received word from God that a particular girl was to be ―sealed‖ to
him. This caused confusion about some of the more attractive girls, as several different men
might get the same word from God about the same girl. This eventually led to the Prophet‘s
decision that only marriages revealed by God to him were acceptable.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 58
Irene‘s mother tried to discourage her daughter from entering into polygamy. But the
teenager, although powerfully attracted to a monogamous young man whom her mother
supported, opted instead to marry 23-year-old Verlan LeBaron, who was already married to
her half-sister Charlotte. Irene was attracted to Verlan and eager for the match.
The LeBarons claimed to be ―spiritual direct descendants‖ of Joseph Smith, giving the name
a certain cache, even though the family was also known for mental instability. Indeed,
Verlan was a brother of the notorious Ervil LeBaron, who eventually murdered, among
others, his brother Joel and Irene‘s uncle, Rulon Allred. Ervil‘s murderous career is described
in Jon Krakauer‘s Under the Banner of Heaven.
Not only because the marriage was polygamous, but also because Irene‘s mother would
have prevented it had she known, the ceremony was secret and surreptitious, achieved with
the connivance of her Uncle Rulon. Shortly thereafter, an eager, committed 16-year-old got
on the bus to Mexico in 1953, where the LeBarons had started a colony, and where she
would commence 28 years of hardship, bearing and raising 13 children in conditions of
physical and emotional deprivation that made her earlier life seem almost comfortable.
The author describes complexities of her polygamous life openly and frankly: the lack of
sexual and emotional intimacy the constant scrounging for food, clothing, and other
necessities the frequent moves within Mexico and elsewhere in search of economic
sustenance and the complex relationships—the jealousy, competition, but also friendship,
and support—among her husband‘s ever-increasing collection of wives. Verlan was not
physically abusive. It was the overwhelming string of broken promises, mainly about
relationships with other women, combined with the exhausting task of providing for her own
and, at times, other wives‘ children, that drove Irene to leave. The parting was prolonged: a
5-month stay with a sister‘s family, then an attempt at reconciliation that included a trip to
Europe (and where did Verlan get the money for that?), and 3 years ―out in the world,‖
followed by another year back with the group in Mexico. The story ends with Verlan‘s
untimely death in an automobile accident. The reader is left without details about Irene‘s
final transition to the outside.
Irene Spencer‘s experience, grim as it was, pales beside the outright tyranny the two
younger authors endured. Carolyn Blackmore Jessop, author of Escape, was born a
generation later, in 1968, and, except for one early year in Salt Lake City, raised in the
Hildale-Colorado City enclave that straddles the border between Utah and Arizona. While
Carolyn‘s parents were descended from a long line of polygamists, they were monogamous
for much of her early childhood. Although she was favored by her often-absent father,
Carolyn describes frequent spankings and beatings by her severely depressed mother, given
in the name of love, and viewed by the community as ―good discipline.‖ There were also
good things—quilting parties, games, and friends, and a powerful message from her
grandmother: FLDS members were of the elite few who, by practicing plural marriage, could
win their way into Heaven.
Supplementing this teaching were the children‘s own games that reflected the coming
apocalypse and the evil ways of all outsiders. Carolyn attended the local public school,
which was staffed and run by FLDS members as its own indoctrination center, and where
teachers employed physical violence (occasionally at sickening levels) against the students,
under supervision of a principal who was close to and protected by ―Uncle Roy‖ (Leroy
Johnson), the prophet.
When she was about 10 years old, Carolyn‘s father took a second wife, her cousin Rosie. A
nurse, Rosie was better educated than most FLDS women. She worked in a nearby town
and often took young Carolyn with her to take care of her infant daughter. Rosie‘s job
contrasted powerfully with the factory work of most FLDS members and Carolyn was
strongly impressed with the value of education.
Previous Page Next Page