Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 35
Conflict Between Aum Critics and Human-Rights Advocates
in Japan
Yoshihide Sakurai, Ph.D.
Hokkaido University
Abstract
Japanese society has experienced two phases of cult controversy over the
past decade. The public reacted to the Aum incidents in the 1990s with
avoidance, declining belief in religion, and moral revulsion. As a result,
criticism of cults in the mass media by academics and laypersons grew
markedly. However, excessive criticism of cult members who had not faced
criminal charges provoked a human-rights backlash in Japan. Human-rights
advocates and intellectuals who were protective of Aum (which had changed
its name to Aleph) declared cults to be ―religious minorities‖ and ―ordinary
people‖ hence, they should not be subjected to discrimination. The refusal
by some municipalities to permit residence to Aum members or entrance of
their children into school was judged unconstitutional by courts. Although
security police have kept Aleph under surveillance and have sought to
prevent them from recruiting new members and engaging in illegal fund-
raising, the Japanese people remain unconvinced that the approximately
1,500 members of Aleph do not still pose a threat. This study examines the
disparity between Japanese intellectuals‘ arguments in support of Aleph and
the common-sense views of ordinary people concerning recent cult
controversies by examining chronological data of the Aum/Aleph movement
and social responses to it.
The decade following the 1995 sarin gas attack on the Tokyo subway system witnessed a
shift in the way the cult issue was handled as a social problem in Japan. In the period
between 1995 and 2000, the Japanese public reacted defensively toward any religious
group with which it had come into conflict, most notably against the Aum Supreme Truth
Cult (Lifton, 1999 Reader, 2002 Watanabe, 1998). Irrespective of how social conformity
and civil order are maintained in Japanese society, situations provoking panicked reactions
against outsiders or groups that may disrupt the social order certainly emerged in this
period. The media also fueled negative impressions, as in the phrases ―‗cults‘ are scary‖ and
―mind control can manipulate you like a slave‖ (Kimiaki, 1995). Fear-mongers exploited and
stoked uneasy feelings. Specific measures were taken against religious groups deemed
―cults,‖ such as the Unification Church (known for the fraudulent sales of spiritual goods),
Three Practices of Dharmic Flower (known for fortunetelling by the soles of the feet), and
the Life Space Group (known for the case of mummified bodies). As with the Aum cult,
religiously motivated donations and monetary offerings, the sales of spiritual goods, and the
abuse of fellow members and followers were punished as illegal activities.
Three Practices of Dharmic Flower and Life Space Group leaders declared bankruptcy and
their followers dispersed yet other groups, such as the Unification Church, still flourish as
religious corporations. The Aum leader was convicted and jailed, the organization‘s license
was revoked, the group declared bankruptcy, and the authorities disposed of its assets,
using the proceeds to compensate its victims. Yet, the group, now renamed ―Aleph,‖ still
continues its activities as a religious organization. The court was able to punish the
members who had been directly involved in illegal activities of the group, but it could not
punish the religious entity that had spawned those illegal activities. As a result, the problem
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 36
of how society should deal with the existing group and its former members, who were not
criminally charged, remains unresolved.
From 2001 through 2005, the local communities and educational institutions that had to
face this problem dealt with it by campaigning against the residency of former members or
by rejecting their enrollment in local schools—as if to say these communities and
institutions could not coexist with ―cults.‖ Local authorities initially refused to accept the
former members‘ registration of residence under the pretext of safeguarding the area‘s
―public welfare.‖ That such measures were taken is not surprising, given the anxiety of local
residents and the public‘s anti-cult sentiment in the late 1990s. Indeed, new laws had been
enacted to monitor the Aum cult. However, at the insistence of Aleph members and their
supporters, the courts demanded that local communities and schools comply with the law.
In other words, the courts reaffirmed the right of any Japanese citizen to enjoy freedom of
residence and the right to education, even if he or she was a ―cult‖ member. At that time,
human-rights groups strongly supported those related to Aleph critics and media pundits
admonished the ―morally panicked‖ Japanese and went on to criticize the logic of banishing
―cults‖ as an emotional reaction that was not in line with ―the public good‖ (Shimizu, 2004).
Journalists, writers, and the general public, who, since the late 1990s, have grown tired of
the endless ―Aum bashing,‖ now tend to share the view that ―cult‖ followers are ordinary
people. At this point, those who have campaigned against the residency or college
enrollment of Aleph-related persons and members in the local community are considered
obstinate, even socially isolated.
In this paper, the author explores the conflict between Aum and local communities—in
particular, cases that occurred between 1999 and 2001. Aleph members, the children of the
Aum leader and related persons, and a number of other members moved into the local
communities of Fujioka City, Gunma Prefecture, Ryugasaki City, Ibaraki Prefecture, and
Karasuyama, Setagaya Ward, Tokyo. In these areas, authorities refused to allow these
individuals to register as residents and to permit their children to enroll in school, and local
residents conducted a campaign urging Aleph members to leave the community.
Before discussing these cases, however, let me comment on the conflict between the anti-
―cult‖ movement and the logic of supporting human rights.
The Anti-“Cult” Movement and the Human-Rights Movement
The phrase ―anti-cult movement‖ refers to a variety of social activities promoted by those
who are critical of certain groups deemed ―cults,‖ as well as to experts working to educate
the public about the ―cult‖ issue (Shupe and Bromley, 1994). The term ―anti-cult
movement‖ was coined by sociologists of religion who took issue with the concept of ―cult‖
and preferred the term ―new religious movement.‖ However, to understand how the term
―cult‖ became so widespread in public discourse, it is necessary to explain who created the
concept and who has used the term to promote their own interests with the public (Barker,
2002). The Japan De-Cult Council (later The Japan Society for Cult Prevention and
Recovery) was founded in 1995 and consists of Aum victims and their families, former
members who support defectors from cults, lawyers and counselors, and clinical
psychologists. The council has devoted its time to educating the public on the issue. The
author, as a board member of this organization, has been involved in working to resolve the
cult issue in a practical and realistic manner. Thus, the cult issue was initially formulated as
a social problem by the anti-cult movement.
In recent years, criticism of the anti-cult movement has begun to dominate scholarly, if not
public, discourse. This trend has been particularly conspicuous in local anti-Aleph
movements, the leaders of which are local municipalities, councilpersons, city officials, and
local residents, all nonprofessionals who confronted the Aum cult with great determination
despite the ominous ―cult‖ images purveyed by the media. Those leaders were emotionally
Previous Page Next Page