Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 5
order for her to ―stay right with God,‖ they would need to punish her by
beating her 40 times with a cane. Jenny/Magdalene was deeply shocked by
this and was left shaking and frightened. Following the rebukes and beating,
Jenny became Magdalene in actuality—she became quiet, serious, and
religious, complying fully with the beliefs and practices of her new group of
people, her new ―family.‖ She dressed differently, wore her hair differently:
She looked and behaved like a different person.
Not long after, she was told that God wanted new members to join the
community. And although at one time Jenny would have questioned this
whole ―going out and dragging people in‖ thing, and would have absolutely
refused, on some level, Magdalene remembered their anger and her shock at
being rebuked and beaten, which had happened unpredictably many more
times, and so did as she was told. She was unresponsive when she was told
that any tactics at all would be okay to bring people in—she was assigned to
bring men into the group. She understood the implications, and Jenny was
buried deep within. Magdalene identified with her new community of people,
truly believing that sleeping with men in order to bring them in and obeying
without question were the work of God.
Following investigation by local church leaders, the community was
disbanded. Unfortunately, the leaders did not know the full extent of the
abuse in the community or understand the impact the experience had had on
Jenny/Magdalene. She therefore continued her church involvement, not
realising how traumatised and abused she had been, or how compliant she
still was. Over time, she learned to question more, although doing this was
challenging for her because she was still fearful of punishment. Nevertheless,
Jenny began to re-emerge and at that point, she began to experience real
depression and post-traumatic stress. She felt trapped: She HAD to be part of
a church otherwise, God would kill her (so she had been told). But she could
not stay part of a church and survive psychologically. Looking back at this
time in her life, she saw that Jenny, her ―old self‖ or pre-cult personality, was
re-emerging over a long period of time and as this happened, life was much
more painful than when she was complying with her cult pseudo-personality,
Magdalene. As she became more aware, she did not know which side she
should be on. Others had noticed this split, and she confused those who
thought she was one sort of person and then discovered she actually thought
quite differently. For example, other ex-members of the community thought
she was serious and judgmental, whereas she was actually quite playful and
compassionate.
After she left the group, Jenny said,
Magdalene, was ―born‖ so I could become the person they
expected me to be, hating my parents, rejecting all outside the
community, and doing things I would never have done before—I
was a stranger to myself. Magdalene is still present in me, and
her voice is different from mine. I fight her a lot of the time
because they told us our parents deserved to die. I am
exhausted and mixed up.
Jenny‘s very self, and her personality, were sharply changed and deeply and
utterly affected by the experience of being with this group of people.
To discuss what happened to Jenny/Magdalene, I will briefly explore what is self and what is
personality. I will then look at some attempts to define the cult pseudo-personality.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 6
Self, Personality, and Pseudo-Personality
I conceptualise the self as changing moment by moment in response to contact with self,
others, and the environment. In thinking about what happened to Jenny/Magdalene, I have
found Gestalt psychotherapy theory helpful in its conceptualisation of the self as the being
and doing aspects of an individual. Perls, Hefferline, and Goodman (1951) state:
Let us call ―self‖ the system of contacts at any moment. As such, the self is
flexibly various, for it varies with the dominant organic needs and the
pressing environmental stimuli it is the system of responses it diminishes in
sleep when there is less need to respond. The self is the contact-boundary at
work… (p. 235)
The self is, therefore, an ever-changing process (Taylor, 2004) in contact with our selves,
others, and the environment. This moment-by-moment response to the environment means
we are all vulnerable to the impact of environmental stimuli and influence (Cialdini, 2001
Zimbardo, 2007), particularly when the environment is radicalised (as Jenny was
responding, the pseudo-personality, Magdalene, was developing). Change and development
occur within the organism or individual throughout the life cycle in many circumstances
(Wilkinson, 2006 Gerhardt, 2004).
Personality can be conceptualised as the more enduring aspects of the organism or
individual. Philippson (2001), a Gestalt writer, states that the personality function of self is
―the knowable, relatively predictable, verbalizable aspect of the self that can be called up in
answer to the questions ‗who are you?‘ or ‗what are you like?‘ or ‗how do you do things?‘…‖
(p. 38).
Whilst Jenny‘s self was responding moment by moment, becoming a fully fledged member
of the community, her personality (her preferences, her answer to the question ―What are
you like?‖) was also changing and Magdalene, the cult pseudo-personality, formed. New
preferences, a new sense of self and how she did things, was created by involvement in and
interaction with the community.
There is much evidence that many individuals who have been in a cult exhibit a change in
their personality (Langone, 1993 Singer 2003 Hassan, 2000 Lalich &Tobias, 2006). The
change in Jenny/Magdalene illustrates Singer‘s view:
As part of the intense influence and change process in many cults, people
take on a new social identity, which may or may not be obvious to an
outsider. When groups refer to this new identity, they speak of members who
are transformed, reborn, enlightened, empowered, re-birthed, or cleared [my
addition: saved, surrendered]. The group-approved behavior is reinforced and
reinterpreted as demonstrating the emergence of ―the new person.‖ Members
are expected to display this new social identity. (2003, p.77–78)
I suggest that this new social identity is the cult pseudo-personality or pseudo-identity.
West &Martin (1993) note: ―Cases of pseudo-identity observed among cult victims are
often very clear-cut, classic examples of transformation through deliberately contrived
situational forces of a normal individual‘s personality into that of a ‗different person‘‖
(p.274).
This change in Jenny/Magdalene was a gradual process over time, and eventually she barely
knew herself. Hassan (2000) states: ―Creation and imposition of a new ‗identity‘ is done
step by step‖ (p.58).
You might ask how this change takes place. Martin (1993) suggests that the common goal
enables the cult to overrule difference: ―Cults typically attack an individual‘s personality.
Previous Page Next Page