Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 28
―[I]n a loud voice,‖ the Epicurean recounts an incident where Alexander had directed a
father to take his slaves before the governor because the man‘s son had gone missing while
returning from Alexandria. Alexander had told the man that the slaves had killed the boy.
Subsequently, the governor had the slaves ―cast to the beasts,‖ only to have the boy return
home, late but unharmed (having made an unexpected, but lengthy, unplanned journey). In
essence, Alexander‘s oracular interpretation of events cost the slaves their lives, and it was
completely, factually, wrong (Alex., 44).
Alexander responds as one might expect a malignant narcissist would, and even Lucian
picks up on the reason: ―Alexander was much annoyed by the exposure, and could not
stomach so well deserved an affront‖ (Alex., 45). In what now we might call narcissistic
rage, Alexander ―ordered the bystanders to stone him, or they themselves would be put
under a curse and be called Epicureans‖ (Alex., 45). The crowd turns on the man and would
kill him if it were not for the brave actions of a distinguished citizen who places his body
between the crowd and its target. Scorning the reaction of the infatuated crowd with
Alexander, Lucian adds, ―he was very nearly stoned to death, and quite right too! What
need had he to be the only sane man among such lunatics, and be on the receiving end of
Paphlagonian stupidity?‖ (Alex., 45).
Malignant narcissists sometimes kill in order to either ―protect and raise their self esteem‖
(Ronningstam 2005, 107) or ―restore their sense of undiminished power‖ (Malmquist 2005,
165), and Alexander appears to be been no different.
From various sections of Lucian‘s rendition, it is very clear that Alexander feeds off the
adulation and attention of crowds (Alex., 12, 14–15, 39). Certainly for him to see a crowd
turn against a critic is exhilarating, and gives him a sense of regaining control over the
public image that he presented.
The third attempted murder is very personal. Alexander knows of Lucian‘s opposition to
him. When, for example, Alexander‘s supporter and (soon to be) elderly son-in-law,
Rutilianus, asks Alexander about Lucian, the ‗prophet‘ responds with an oracle implying that
he is a sexual degenerate (Alex., 54). Then, when Lucian has a personal visit with
Alexander, Lucian refuses to call him by the title, ‗Prophet,‘ and insists upon using his name.
More dramatically, in the presence of the prophet‘s followers, Lucian bites Alexander‘s hand
rather than kiss it when Alexander offers it to him. Indeed, Lucian indicates that he gives
―him a hearty bite..., which very nearly crippled his hand‖ (Alex., 55).
Whatever physical pain Lucian caused Alexander, it likely is nothing compared to the affront
to Alexander‘s pride. At the time, however, Alexander‘s response to the affront is very
measured, calling off his assaulting entourage and then ostensibly trying to win over his
opponent. This initially measured reaction, however, subsequently festers into a murder plot
in a manner consistent with narcissistic rage. Current research on homicidal narcissists
indicates that ―narcissistic individuals may develop an indifferent or cool exterior as an initial
response to threats to their self esteem. However, when their composure gives way, it is
striking to see the intensity of their anger and need for revenge‖ (Malmquist 2005, 168).
While it is true that Lucian feigns friendship with Alexander in order to escape his presence,
his act likely has not fooled the ‗prophet,‘ since even ―the onlookers were quite astonished
at how easily my feelings had changed‖ [or at least appeared to (Alex., 55)].
Lucian is caught completely off guard by Alexander‘s murderous retaliation. After accepting
from Alexander a ship for his travels, Lucian is at sea when
I noticed the skipper in tears and arguing with the sailors, and I thought my
future prospects were not hopeful. They had had instructions from Alexander
to seize and fling us [i.e., Lucian and his traveling companion] into the sea,
which would have ended his war with me then and there. (Alex., 56)
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 29
Only the captain‘s pleadings with the crew save his life. It is speculative, but certainly in
accordance with events, to say that Alexander would have seen Lucian‘s ―killing as a
righteous act of retaliation‖ (Ronningstam 2005, 107).
Conclusion: Narcissism and Sectarian Religious Formation
In records from the ancient world, Alexander is unique.
There is no known instance in the pagan world in which a single ―religious
genius‖ achieved success equal to that of Alexander. He appeared from
nowhere and convinced people throughout much of the Mediterranean basin
that he was, in some sense, intimate with the divine. (Branham 1989, 186)
And so we are left wondering if others in his era express narcissism through non-religious
channels, or if the condition was even rarer then than it is now [currently at less than one
percent of the population (American Psychiatric Association 2000)]. To these questions, we
will never have answers. Certainly the ancient world—Jewish, Christian, and pagan—
witnessed some remarkable sectarian expressions (see, for example, Horsley and Hanson
1985 Hultgren and Haggmark [eds.] 1996 Kraemer 2004 MacDermot 1971) but we
simply lack the biographical detail about their founders that exists about Alexander.
What we can answer, however, are questions about whether narcissism often plays a role in
the origins of religion or in the motivation for religious leaders within existing traditions. To
both of these questions, we can answer affirmatively. In the context of religious origins, we
have two well-documented faiths whose creators were narcissists—Joseph Smith of
Mormonism and Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh of the Rajneeshees.19 As I pointed out, Smith
likely was a malignant narcissist himself, and it is also worth noting that his rage at an
institution that had criticized him ultimately led to his death. A mob dragged him out of a
jail and murdered him in 1844, ―after he destroyed a printing press that had published the
Nauvoo Expositor, which spoke negatively about him, polygamy, and a theocratic
monarchy‖ (Anderson 1999, 242). The religion that he founded, however, has flourished,
and it has ―become the only truly successful American religion, now international in scope
and capable of wielding social and political power‖ (Anderson 1999, 242). In its day, the
Glycon cult also was successful, reaching into the upper ranks of Roman society and
apparently surviving well into the century following the death of its founder (Jones 1986,
138).
Rajneesh‘s religion has not fared nearly as well as Mormonism, with its main community in
America dissolving after the guru‘s conviction (and resultant deportation in 1985) for
making false statements to a government official, followed by his deportation (Carter 1990,
236–237). When flourishing in 1983, the commune in Oregon attracted some 15,000 people
to a particular celebration (Carter 1990, 166, 183), and some 1,500 to 2,500 lived in the
facility in 1984 (Carter 1990, 207). Despite Rajneesh‘s death in 1990, however, hundreds of
centers still operate in countries around the world.
Although the religious and psychotherapeutic message of Rajneesh is very different from
the prophetic oracular directives and reputed healings that Alexander produces, the
personalities of the two men are very similar. Like Alexander, ―Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh‘s
sense of self-importance and uniqueness seem[ed] to possess no limits‖ (Clark 1988, 33).
He ―clearly consider[ed] himself to be a man of world-historical significance‖ (Clark 1988,
34), although he never developed the political contacts that Alexander does. Reminiscent of
Alexander‘s willingness to reinterpret failed prophecies, Rajneesh, too, had a ―narcissistic
penchant for transforming failures into successes‖ (Clark 1988, 35). Just as Alexander feeds
off the energy and support of crowds, ―Rajneesh thoroughly delight[ed] in being the sole
focus of attention of his thousands of adoring fans‖ (Clark 1988, 38). Moreover, both
religious figures were ―‗master[s]‘ at manipulating and exploiting other people‖ (Clark 1988,
Previous Page Next Page