Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 29
Only the captain‘s pleadings with the crew save his life. It is speculative, but certainly in
accordance with events, to say that Alexander would have seen Lucian‘s ―killing as a
righteous act of retaliation‖ (Ronningstam 2005, 107).
Conclusion: Narcissism and Sectarian Religious Formation
In records from the ancient world, Alexander is unique.
There is no known instance in the pagan world in which a single ―religious
genius‖ achieved success equal to that of Alexander. He appeared from
nowhere and convinced people throughout much of the Mediterranean basin
that he was, in some sense, intimate with the divine. (Branham 1989, 186)
And so we are left wondering if others in his era express narcissism through non-religious
channels, or if the condition was even rarer then than it is now [currently at less than one
percent of the population (American Psychiatric Association 2000)]. To these questions, we
will never have answers. Certainly the ancient world—Jewish, Christian, and pagan—
witnessed some remarkable sectarian expressions (see, for example, Horsley and Hanson
1985 Hultgren and Haggmark [eds.] 1996 Kraemer 2004 MacDermot 1971) but we
simply lack the biographical detail about their founders that exists about Alexander.
What we can answer, however, are questions about whether narcissism often plays a role in
the origins of religion or in the motivation for religious leaders within existing traditions. To
both of these questions, we can answer affirmatively. In the context of religious origins, we
have two well-documented faiths whose creators were narcissists—Joseph Smith of
Mormonism and Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh of the Rajneeshees.19 As I pointed out, Smith
likely was a malignant narcissist himself, and it is also worth noting that his rage at an
institution that had criticized him ultimately led to his death. A mob dragged him out of a
jail and murdered him in 1844, ―after he destroyed a printing press that had published the
Nauvoo Expositor, which spoke negatively about him, polygamy, and a theocratic
monarchy‖ (Anderson 1999, 242). The religion that he founded, however, has flourished,
and it has ―become the only truly successful American religion, now international in scope
and capable of wielding social and political power‖ (Anderson 1999, 242). In its day, the
Glycon cult also was successful, reaching into the upper ranks of Roman society and
apparently surviving well into the century following the death of its founder (Jones 1986,
138).
Rajneesh‘s religion has not fared nearly as well as Mormonism, with its main community in
America dissolving after the guru‘s conviction (and resultant deportation in 1985) for
making false statements to a government official, followed by his deportation (Carter 1990,
236–237). When flourishing in 1983, the commune in Oregon attracted some 15,000 people
to a particular celebration (Carter 1990, 166, 183), and some 1,500 to 2,500 lived in the
facility in 1984 (Carter 1990, 207). Despite Rajneesh‘s death in 1990, however, hundreds of
centers still operate in countries around the world.
Although the religious and psychotherapeutic message of Rajneesh is very different from
the prophetic oracular directives and reputed healings that Alexander produces, the
personalities of the two men are very similar. Like Alexander, ―Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh‘s
sense of self-importance and uniqueness seem[ed] to possess no limits‖ (Clark 1988, 33).
He ―clearly consider[ed] himself to be a man of world-historical significance‖ (Clark 1988,
34), although he never developed the political contacts that Alexander does. Reminiscent of
Alexander‘s willingness to reinterpret failed prophecies, Rajneesh, too, had a ―narcissistic
penchant for transforming failures into successes‖ (Clark 1988, 35). Just as Alexander feeds
off the energy and support of crowds, ―Rajneesh thoroughly delight[ed] in being the sole
focus of attention of his thousands of adoring fans‖ (Clark 1988, 38). Moreover, both
religious figures were ―‗master[s]‘ at manipulating and exploiting other people‖ (Clark 1988,
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 30
40). Surely, however, the most remarkable, and disturbing, parallel between the two
narcissists was the large organizations that operated fraudulently if not criminally to further
the leaders‘ respective deceptions.
In his prime, Rajneesh, along with a trusted assistant, oversaw an international corporate
structure with major financial concerns in the United States, India, Switzerland, and the
United Kingdom (see Carter 1990, 86 see 83–96), with small centers throughout most of
the industrialized world. In fact, an academic who studied the group concluded that one
could view it ―as a multilevel marketing device with central control in a charismatic core‖
(Carter 1990, 97). Broadly speaking, Alexander‘s operation has parallels. His bureaucracy of
―helpers, servants, questioners, oracle-writers, oracle-keepers, secretaries, sealers,
interpreters...‖ (Alex., 23) includes missionaries who travel ―abroad to spread reports of the
oracle among other nations, and to announce that he gave prophecies, found runaway
slaves, detected thieves and robbers, showed the way to buried treasure, healed the sick,
and sometimes even raised the dead‖ (Alex., 24 see 30). He even establishes what one set
of translators called ―an intelligence bureau‖ in Rome (see Alex., 37 in Fowler and Fowler
[trans.] 1905), whose ―spies‖ act as both monitors of public (and presumably political)
opinion, providing ―forewarning of the questions and the particular wishes of the
questioners...‖ coming from that important city (Alex., 37). In varying degrees, however,
both Rajneesh‘s and Alexander‘s operations used fraud, deception, and attempted murder
as standard procedures.
With the collapse of Rajneesh‘s Oregon community, at least sixty-three individuals were
charged with criminal offences, and an unspecified number of followers (including the leader
himself) were convicted and sentenced. The offences included lying to federal officials,
criminal conspiracy, racketeering, first- and second-degree assault, and attempted murder
(Carter 1990, 236). Looking at these offences within a comparative perspective, what is so
striking is how many of them resemble activities that Alexander and his bureaucracy also
perpetrate almost two thousand years earlier. He uses trickery and deception to establish a
new religion that offers the public fraudulent prophecies, ineffectual protection from a
serious public heath crisis [i.e., the plague (Alex., 36)], and questionable medical cures
(Alex., 25 cf. 22). It also interferes in the justice system of the era by claiming to detect
―thieves and robbers‖ and even identifies murderers who turned out to be innocent (Alex.,
44). It runs an extortion ring against influential citizens (Alex., 32), and—much like the
Ranjeesh organization—tries to assassinate its critics.
Among others, attorneys working against the Rajneeshees were targets of the Rajneesh
organization, which used poisoning and a planned (but never enacted) ambush (Carter
1990, 222). In two instances, Alexander‘s techniques are cruder, simply using (or trying to
incite) mobs to kill critical Epicureans but the murder plot against Lucian involves a
conspiracy between the leader and hired thugs that fails only because of the conscience of a
sea captain.
What these similarities suggest, however, is that narcissists creating and running religious
organizations can be dangerous, and the plans that they initiate can be deadly. These
insights transcend time, location, and culture, since persons with mental disorders often find
ways to create mischief, if not outright harm, in whichever societies or eras they live.20
End Notes
1 Reprinted with permission from Ancient Narrative 6 (2007): 77-99, 161. The Author grants
permission for the free use of this article in classrooms.
2 Lucian refers to ―the late emperor Marcus‖ (Alexz., 48), and we know that Marcus Aurelius died in
180 (Sutherland 1949). I follow the standard method of citing Lucian‘s account of Alexander, referring
to Alexander or the False Prophet with the abbreviation, Alex., followed by a paragraph number. All
quotes come from the translation by Desmond Costa (2005, 129-151).
Previous Page Next Page