Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 44
Asahara would be an obstacle to group survival in Japan, even if Aleph members made a
monumental effort. Meanwhile, old members who truly believed in Asahara and his mystical
power regarded this idea as disloyal to Aum conventions and formed an anti-Joyu faction.
This is known as the A (Asahara) faction, in contrast to the Joyu faction, the M (Maitreya,
Joyu‘s holy name) faction. Between them there are some believers who have not committed
to either side.
On May 18th, the security police agency disclosed that the M and A factions had each held
spring seminars, and that as a result the M faction had collected approximately $70,000 in
donations from 80 participants, while the A faction had collected $400,000 from 220
participants. Joyu declared, ―We should think about the direction of the Aleph after the
execution of Asahara,‖ which could be scheduled within the next few years because of the
dismissal of Asahara‘s appeal in the Tokyo High Court. Asahara‘s capital punishment was
fixed in September 15, 2006. Some members believe Asahara will not die, even by hanging
however, such a thought is a by-product of shut-in persons who do not accept the real
world. It will be too late to start a new version of Aleph after the death of its founder. M and
A factions were expected to divide their assets and accounts respectively by July 2006. In
May 2007, Joyu separated his faction from Aleph and made a new religion, ―Hikari no wa‖
(Ring of Light), with approximately 200 members (Asahi News, 2007).
Discussions
Resource Mobilization and Cultural Framing
In this section, we discuss the resident movement from the perspective of social movement
theory, which focuses on the mobilization of resources, cultural framing, and political
opportunity (Tarrow, 1998).
The mobilization of resources means how funds and human resources are procured and
utilized in order to have successful social movements. The municipalities took urgent
budgetary steps by allocating approximately $100,000 for residents‘ anti-Aleph movements
in 1999 and 2000, because the Japanese public had already become aware of the treatment
of Aleph members as a social issue after a series of Aum-related incidents. But because this
budget was spent on lawsuits, the residents in Karasuyama were forced to raise funds for
their own activities.
Cultural framing is composed of a social appeal made by a movement, which convinces the
general public of, and enlists them in, the movement‘s cause. What values and interests did
anti-Aleph residents attempt to protect? Of course, mere dislike or fear of a ―cult‖ does not
convince other people who are not directly affected. They need more convincing reasons.
Sometimes that justification is presented by outside parties. Human-rights advocates
provided conflicting abstract arguments, such as ―public well-being for locals,‖ and Aleph
members‘ ―freedom of religion,‖ and ―the freedom and the right to have residence and
education.‖ But did the local people really participate in the movement because of those
ideas? This question must be addressed.
Some municipalities refused to accept Aleph members‘ residence registration on the
grounds of ―uneasy feelings of local residents.‖ They believed that what local residents
demanded was a guarantee of local security, and thus responding to that plea would
correspond to ―public welfare.‖ In response to the claims by the cult and its supporters, as
well as human-rights activists, the municipality insisted, ―(the community‘s) fears are not
gone.‖ Since dialogue was not working, they had no choice but to turn to the legal process.
The rationale of ―public welfare‖ was merely an expression of the municipality‘s view on the
local side, ―fear‖ was the reason for the anti-Aum movement.
It is easy to attribute a disdain for human rights to residents chanting ―Aum, Get Out!‖ or
voicing other hostile expressions and attitudes. For this reason, human-rights advocates
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 45
formulated the standard framing by raising the question: ―Is it acceptable to limit individual
human rights due to abstract fears based on insufficient evidence and emotional loathing?‖
That is how the logic of fairness was introduced. In fact, at that time, the point in dispute
was not denying the human rights of Aleph members (discriminating against them) or
weighing those rights on a scale. And it was not about respecting the human rights of local
residents more than the human rights of Aleph members from the standpoint of public
welfare.
The local residents‘ fear was directed toward nothing other than the security threat posed
by Aleph (Aum). Unless the cult group disbanded, that fear would not disappear, so the
residents thought they had no incentive for meeting the cult members face-to-face. This
mindset was sustained by the memories of the sarin gas attack and media reports that Aum
followers are mentally controlled by the cult group. Naturally, there were individual
differences in their fears and degree of loathing, not to mention differences in residential
styles.
Aleph‘s supporters maintained that ―fear‖ would be reduced if residents recognized that they
were not really in danger. But residents‘ fears prevented them from engaging in dialogue
that might lead to a reduction of their fear. The residents‘ reluctance was, ironically,
strengthened by the condescending and disdainful way in which human-rights advocates
treated them. Thus, the Aleph supporters were able to gain a decided advantage in framing
the issue for the public by portraying the anti-Aum residents as obstinately and irrationally
afraid. Even had the residents successfully communicated their ―fear‖ to society in general,
the distance between their situation and that of the observing public would have made the
public‘s empathy low. Hence, it was easier for society to acknowledge the more normative
argument that there would be no exception in protecting human rights of minority people.
In terms of framing strategy, then, human-rights advocates defeated the residents.
Structure of Political Opportunity
The structure of political opportunities, the background of this verbal strategy, also turned
out to be a blessing for human-rights advocates. The structure of political opportunities
hinges on whether or not the national government would tolerate social movements. When
an anti-Aum movement was launched in Namino Village in Kumamoto, other local anti-Aum
movements were tolerated. This is because the municipality cooperated fully with the local
residents, and the national government also gave consideration to the Aum issue. In 1999,
the municipalities submitted a request to concerned government ministries and agencies, in
which they urged the government to crack down on Aum. This request gave some
momentum to the enactment of new anti-Aum laws. The framing from the local
communities was successful—―We cannot live in peace as long as cult activity is tolerated.‖
Because of court decisions, however, it became difficult after the year 2000 to take judicial
and administrative measures that go beyond surveillance (supervision by the Security Police
Agency) in regard to the residence of Aleph members. In other words, now there are no
special reasons to prevent Aum members‘ freedom of residence. In that respect, the refusal
of residence registration in municipalities was a countermeasure that lacked legitimacy. The
municipalities were aware of this and patiently waited until the Aum-related persons finally
left the municipality, and then switched the anti-Aum slogan from ―Get out!‖ to ―Break Up!‖
They proposed a fundamental resolution of the problem so that no one could accuse them of
local egoism or of avoiding the problem.
In spite of all this, some Japanese, especially some intellectuals and young people, began to
show empathy for the A and A2 instead of the anti-Aum movement (Miyadai, 2002
Ohsawa, 2005 Gardner, 2001). Those films were produced by Tatsuya Mori, who
documented Aum from within and tried to break its typical ―cult‖ image. They slowly began
to accept the argument that the new religious group (Aleph, not Aum) was not dangerous
Previous Page Next Page