Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 13
I envision the pseudo-personality overlaying the pre-cult personality like tarmac on a road,
a horizontal split:
Diagram 6: The cult pseudo-personality
overlaying the pre-cult personality
Cult pseudo-personality
Pre-cult personality
The tarmac ―takes‖ to one degree or another. For some it sits comfortably, but for others it
is uncomfortable from the start and when the individual leaves the cult, it will begin to
break up (Singer, 2003).
I suggest the pseudo-personality mimics dissociation—the machine relentlessly moves
forward, overlaying the personality of the new cult members, causing them to adjust to this
new world view—it is not them and it is them. I suggest the greater part of the process of
forming the pseudo-personality is not doubling, false self, or simply adaptation, not
dissociation nor DID, but introjection.
In Gestalt theory, introjection may be thought of as
...material—a way of acting, feeling, evaluating—which you have taken into
your system of behavior but which you have not assimilated in such fashion
as to make it a genuine part of your organism—your self. (Perls et al., 1951,
p. 189)
When the individual takes in from the environment without chewing over what is taken in
(as happens in a cult), it is difficult to digest and gain nourishment from it. Perls et al.
(1951) state that in introjection the organism ―takes in the ‗material‘ on the basis of forced
acceptance, a forced (and therefore pseudo) identification,‖ and that it is a foreign body, but
the organism resists it being dislodged. In the case of a cult, there is often little opportunity
for the individual to dislodge or digest it without leaving, getting into a great deal of trouble,
or becoming psychologically de-stabilised.
I suggest that Jenny, the unsuspecting new recruit, idealised her new ―friends‖ (and they let
her) and their attractive beliefs, and she took them and their cult culture and ideology in—
she introjected them—whole. She had little opportunity for critical thinking, or chewing
over: Magdalene therefore developed and overlaid Jenny, who became buried.
A number of authors acknowledge the need for ex-cult members to reconnect with their
pre-cult personality, and that doing this is a crucial part of the recovery process (West &
Martin, 1994 Martin, 1993 Langone, 1993 Singer, 2000 Hassan, 2000). Hassan (2000)
states the split-off pseudo-personality needs to be integrated.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 14
I shall discuss how this reconnection with the pre-cult personality occurs, and also look at
whether integration, or chewing over and digestion, are required for one to recover.
Recovery: Integration or Chewing Over and Digestion
Reber &Reber (2001) say that integration brings the person ―into a harmonious or
coordinated whole by rearranging, organizing, and occasionally adding or deleting elements
or parts‖ (p. 360). Van der Hart et al. (2006) note that integration is a bringing together of
a split whole.
One of the themes that came out of my unpublished M.A. research, What Helps Ex-cult
Members Recover from an Abusive Cult Experience?, was ―getting rid of the cult pseudo-
personality.‖ When I went back to my research, I was taken aback at how I had worded
this. I questioned the ‗‖getting rid of‖ bit I asked myself whether integration of that part,
as one would integrate a dissociated part, was, in fact, more appropriate. However, on
reflection, I do not think so. I think ―getting rid of‖ in a nonviolent way is actually what is
needed—chewing and digesting the introjected cult pseudo-personality rather than
integrating it. So, whilst the above definition would seem to fit the process of reconnecting
to the pre-cult personality, I suggest that it is not enough because the cult pseudo-
personality is not a dissociated part, and integrating it would entail keeping parts of the cult
experience that need to be eliminated. I will now discuss how to ―get rid of‖ the pseudo-
personality.
Gestalt writers Perls et al. (1951) use the analogy between the teeth and developmental
stages. The toothless baby takes in predigested food the toddler‘s milk teeth develop, and
he or she eats soft food the adult teeth develop, and the young child starts asking why,
what is that for, and so on. Children want to chew over what is coming in and decide for
themselves (they do not want to simply introject what is given to them). In a healthy
environment, this behaviour occurs increasingly with age.
Perls et al. (1951, p. 189) state:
Physical food properly digested and assimilated, becomes part of the
organism but food which ―rests heavy on the stomach‖ is an introject
[emphasis added]. You are aware of it and want to throw it up. If you do so
you get it ―out of the system.‖ Suppose, instead, you suppress your
discomfort, nausea, and tendency to spew it forth. Then you ―keep it down‖
and either succeed, finally, in painfully digesting it or else it poisons you.
I suggest that, with the cult-pseudo personality (Magdalene), the individual is unaware of
the poison and discomfort. The discomfort is suppressed within the pre-cult personality
(Jenny).
Perls et al. (1951, p. 189) go on to suggest that to
eliminate introjects from your personality the problem is not to accept and
integrate dissociated parts of yourself. Rather, it is to become aware of
what is not truly yours, to acquire a selective and critical attitude toward what
is offered you, and, above all, to develop the ability to ―bite off‖ and ―chew‖
experience so as to extract its healthy nourishment. [bold added]
And, I would add, to eliminate from the system that which is not nourishing.
To return to the analogy of the tarmac or asphalt, when the road is finally disintegrated, it is
possible to dig the tarmac back into the soil and perhaps obtain some benefit from it.
Hassan (2000) states that it is important not to discard the entire cult identity, but to create
a new post-cult identity that incorporates the most valuable and healthy parts of the pre-
Previous Page Next Page