Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 49
Book Reviews
Not Without My Sister: The True Story of Three Girls Violated and Betrayed
Kristina Jones, Celeste Jones, and Juliana Buhring, HarperCollins UK. 2007. ISBN-
10: 0007248067 ISBN-13: 978-0007248063 (hardcover), $24.95 ($18.21
Amazon.com). 416 pages. HarperCollins UK. 2008. ISBN-10: 0007248075 ISBN-
13: 978-0007248070 (paperback), $13.95 ($11.86 Amazon.com). 432 pages.
Jesus Freaks: A True Story of Murder and Madness on the Evangelical Edge
Don Lattin, HarperOne. 2007. ISBN-10: 0061118044 ISBN-13: 978-0061118043
(hardcover), $24.95 ($18.21 Amazon.com). 256 pages.
Two books published in 2007 and written by authors outside academe provide an in-depth
understanding of life in The Children of God, a new religious movement started in the 1960s
by evangelical preacher David Berg. This group was popularly recognized as a cult. The
Children of God were later called The Family and are now known as The Family
International.
Both books provide evidence of the group‘s leadership encouraging and engaging in sexual
activities with children. Such accounts are disputed in scholarly publications and dismissed
by some scholars as exceptions or exaggerations. Both books, however, depict much
academic research as inadequate, misguided, or misrepresented. Although the authors of
these two books provide shocking details about growing up in The Children of God, the
honest discussion of respected research is perhaps the greatest impact they will have on the
academic field of cultic studies.
The first book in this review, Not Without My Sisters, is a memoir. Popular media reviews of
the book focus on the ―horrific detail‖ in the lives of the authors, who were ―treated by their
'guardians‘ as sexual beings.‖ Some academics who label appeals to mainstream values as
―moral panics‖ that are beneath the objective perspective of scholarly research dismiss such
shock tactics by publishers and marketers. In some corners of academe, these supercilious
scholars are regarded as ―experts‖ in their field, but those dark corners are becoming
increasingly exposed by books such as this one. In my opinion, the major contribution of
Not Without My Sister to the field of cult studies is its insights into the processes and effects
of brainwashing (a.k.a. mind control or thought reform), a disputed concept in academia.
There are differences of scholarly opinion regarding memoirs written by former members of
such groups as The Children of God/The Family. Although these differences exist on a
continuum, the extreme on one side includes the apologist scholars of cults who claim that
memoirs are self-accounts distorted by personal biases, and on the other side academics
who claim the apologists—those scholars who debunk anti-cult allegations—promote
perspectives distorted by hidden agendas. The apologists have labeled these scholars ―anti-
cultists‖ because they typically present data, analysis, and findings that are less than
favorable to cults and often based on interviews with former members or memoirs by
former members.
As a memoir writer and academic, I am familiar with both sides of the debate. As a former
member of a cult and researcher, I can identify the blind spots and pretense of scholars who
claim to remain objective, as well as those of the individuals who, influenced by their life
experiences in a cult, write with righteous indignation. I have tried to maintain neutrality,
but I suspect that both sides will challenge some of my views and critiques.
Not Without My Sisters is about growing up in The Children of God. The authors of this book
are two biological full sisters, Kristina and Celeste, and their half sister, Juliana. They all
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 50
have the same father, known in the group as Simon Peter. I mention ―biological‖ because as
a sociologist I am amazed at the strong connection between these sisters, who by their own
accounts were separated at a young age and continued to be kept apart with very little
physical interaction or communication throughout their lives. Also, as a former member of
The Children of God, I know that this group not only espoused but also enforced its
communal ideal by physically, emotionally, and psychologically dividing families, or what
they called ―selfish little units.‖
The authors‘ accounts of sexual, emotional, and physical exploitation and abuse will interest
all readers concerned with social justice and human rights. The book will be a compelling
read for any parent, instructional material for any student of social sciences, and an
informative account for anyone with family members involved in cults or other fanatic
religious groups. But my primary recommendation of this book is for scholars of
controversial religious and social movements, and professionals working with abuse victims,
dysfunctional families, and cult survivors.
I was a member of The Children of God for fifteen years. Based on my insider knowledge, as
well as my informed understanding of the academic debates regarding this group, I found
Not Without My Sister most effective in its exposure of the way in which sexual and physical
abuse was not only encouraged but also practiced by its leaders throughout the group‘s
history. I have written in my memoir that I did not see child sexual abuse everywhere, but
we group members all read reports that indicated it existed in the homes of the cult‘s
leaders. This book sheds more light on the degree and progression of child abuse in the
Children of God, starting with the perspective an abused child.
The book opens with the story of Celeste, the first-born of Simon Peter, a charismatic young
disciple of the Children of God who rose to fame and favor with the leaders of the group as
a result of his ―Music with Meaning‖ radio shows in Greece. Readers become aware that
Simon‘s access and unfailing obedience to top leadership resulted in his children‘s
subsequent exposure to some of the worst child-abuse scenarios in the history of the group.
I am not denying that perhaps Celeste‘s story chronicles one of the more bizarre and
atrocious abuse experiences of children in The Family, but I remain suspicious of scholars
who claim that this abuse was isolated, since the extent of such activities is still unknown.
Celeste describes scenes that have become legends among ex-members of this group, such
as the beatings at the huge ―Combo homes‖ for teens, the rapes of young girls, and the
suicides of young male members. These stories have been exposed in Internet sites and
newspaper articles for years, but Celeste‘s account supports the stories and offers more
detail from a true insider‘s perspective—as a young child growing up and viewing the scenes
first-hand. Moreover, Celeste herself is not spared these injustices, and while the reader is
aghast that her father is not protecting her, Celeste continues to excuse him and hold him
on a pedestal. Any pretense that the leadership did not know of adults forcing sex on
children is dispelled by Celeste‘s account of living in leadership homes where she is forced
to have sex with adults. Celeste lived in the homes that most Family members only read
about in The Family newsletters. More-concerned parents in the group feared that their
teens would be sent to one of these ―Combo‖ homes, which were considered the juvenile
detention homes of The Family. Celeste is sent there not because she is bad but because
her father is needed in secret homes where she is not needed.
Celeste longs for reunion with her absent mother and sister, who left the group after being
separated from the rest of the family. A golden opportunity for escape and justice arises
when she is asked to testify in a British court case involving child abuse in the Children of
God. Because Celeste is one of the young girls dancing naked and suggestively on a video
used as evidence in the case, a reputed religious expert interviews her and asks her to
explain her childhood strip dance experience. Celeste repeats exactly what the leaders of
Previous Page Next Page