Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 62
throughout by a loving companion, had fewer practical problems, but relates in touching
detail the powerfully symbolic act of cutting her hair.
Although finding it more difficult to slough off the theological burden, Irene‘s description of
her attempts to re-integrate into mainstream society echoes these themes:
I felt like a zoo animal let loose in the wild. I had no job skills, so we lived off
welfare. ...Everything was different. The variety among the people and the
ideas I encountered was … a huge shift from my prior life, in which everyone
thought and acted the same way … And then there was my constant doubt
and guilt over the choices I made to leave Verlan and the church.
The cultural adjustment was even harder for her children, who had never lived ―outside.‖
Irene—explaining to a school psychologist that the child in question was not retarded, but
simply had never seen a baseball mitt, a fire hydrant, or even a light bulb, and in fact had
never seen a single one of the items pictured in a test he had flunked—eloquently conveys
this struggle.
Perhaps the most salient message of these books is the variety of ways life can impose
misery in a totalitarian group, and the valor and resiliency that can overcome a lifetime of
indoctrination.
Livia Bardin, M.S.W.
What Orwell Didn’t Know: Propaganda and the New Face of American
Politics
Edited by András Szántó, PublicAffairs (250 West 57th St, Suite 1321, NY, NY
10107). 2007. ISBN—10: 1-58648-560-1 ISBN—13: 978-1-58648-560-3
(paperback), $14.95 ($10.17, Amazon.com). 272 pages
Publication of this collection of essays by twenty writers coincided with a symposium at
Columbia University in New York to honor the sixtieth anniversary of Orwell‘s essay ―Politics
and the English Language.‖ George Orwell (pen name for Eric Arthur Blair, 1903–1950)
wrote his classic commentary on misuse of language in 1946, three years before he
published his apocalyptic novel 1984 (or Nineteen Eighty-Four). The novel reflects Orwell‘s
prognosis that language as propaganda can augment a social dystopia or totalitarian
regime. Orwell argues that language should reflect reality as directly as possible. ―Politics
and the English Language‖ is reproduced in full in the appendix of this volume. The editor,
András Szántó, who resides in New York, is a writer and consultant to philanthropic
organizations. He is also a freelance journalist.
Most of the essays in this anthology reflect on our current state of politics, and that includes
criticizing the Bush administration and its handling of the war in Iraq. The book project
began when the deans of five prominent journalism schools commiserated about the sad
state of political language and how rapidly it seemed to be disconnecting from reality.
Despite the book‘s overall leftist lean (Orwell, a socialist, should have been pleased with
that), a few essayists strike notes that cut left and right through political jargon. As Szántó
notes, ―It goes without saying that politicians have always taken liberties with the truth‖ (p.
x). However, Szántó already overlooks two Orwell rules (1 and 3) for writers here: ―It goes
without saying that‖ is better stated as ―Invariably‖ or ―Notoriously.‖
Before I go on, let us look at Orwell‘s six rules for writers, from his essay:
1. Never use a metaphor, simile, or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing
in print.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 63
2. Never use a long word where a short one will do.
3. If it is possible to cut a word out, always cut it out.
4. Never use the passive voice where you can use the active.
5. Never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word, or a jargon word if you can think of an
everyday English equivalent.
6. Break any of these rules sooner than say anything outright barbarous.
Now I feel better because I can make this review simply to the point. Of course, I am being
facetious, or should I say coy? These are not simple rules to follow without professional
discipline. I will try. Orwell‘s rules might be decent guidelines for editing, but they are also a
death knell for totalitarian propaganda. As Robert J. Lifton stated, ―Totalist language then, is
repetitiously centered on all-encompassing jargon, prematurely abstract, highly categorical,
relentlessly judging, and to anyone but its most devoted advocate, deadly dull: in Lionel
Trilling's phrase, ‗the language of nonthought‘‖ (see Lifton, 1961, Thought Reform and the
Psychology of Totalism, chapter 22: Loading the Language). Several of the essayists refer to
Lifton.
Orwell‘s rules indicate the power of language to inform and enlighten, and to confuse and
deceive. With that in mind, allow me to comment on the essays.
The introduction is by Orville Schell, a journalist who authored twelve books. He currently is
director of the Asia Society‘s Center on China-U.S. relations. Schell argues that manipulative
language has evolved since the 19th century with the advent of a deeper understanding of
the human psyche and the effects of communication technology. He believes that several
evolutionary breakthroughs led to a level of ―efficaciousness‖ in propaganda today that
would astound Orwell. The first step came about when Chinese Communists imbued
Stalinist propaganda with Chinese characteristics, thus creating ―Mao Zedong Thought.‖ The
second step married old-style politics with Freudian insights about what triggers human
response. Not surprisingly, Sigmund Freud‘s nephew, Edward Bernays, developed new
psychological mechanisms to induce people to buy more consumer goods by tapping desires
and overriding needs.
Bernays is ―the father of public relations‖ who developed mass persuasion ideas for
advertising. The last evolutionary step came on the new wave of electronic technology and
the Internet. Schell finishes his discussion with brainwashing in China that combines
Confucian tradition of self-cultivation and obligation to community with a Maoist worldview.
He cites Robert Lifton and writer Milan Kundera as particularly observant of how this all
works. In the end, Schell states, ―…propaganda‘s evolution has hardly run its course.‖
Part One, Language and Politics, begins with ―Orwell Then and Now‖ by David Rieff, who is a
contributing writer to The New York Times and author of eight books. Rieff discusses the
fates of successful writers, most of whom fade into obscurity shortly after they die, if not
before. Orwell struck a chord that still rings loud in our political arenas. Nearly everyone
with an education understands what Orwellian indicates. Rieff compares and contrasts
Orwell with Simone Weil: ―Both Weil and Orwell were ‗judgers‘… Their standards were high
and their opinions severe.‖ Rieff sees a writer‘s influence ‗evolving‘ over time. Orwell, clearly
a man of the left, is today claimed by both sides of the political debate. Opponents of the
George Bush regime describe it as a propaganda machine that uses ―Newspeak,‖ whereas
proponents see Bush with Orwell, fighting totalitarianism. Neither side has a right to claim
Orwell, Rieff says. To attempt it is a ―vulgar quest … We haven‘t a clue what Orwell would
have thought or what side he would have taken.‖
Nicholas Lemann is dean of Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism and a staff
writer for The New Yorker.
Previous Page Next Page