Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 10
Adaptation
Adaptation is, in social psychology and sociology, ―a shift in sociological or cultural
disposition. Thus, one is said to ‗adapt‘ to a new environment‖ (Reber &Reber, 2001, p.
11).
It could be said that joining a cult is simply an adaptation: Individuals are choosing to be
the way the cult wants them to be, and they want to change. This suggests that the
individual has a choice, and free will. Even though there probably is an adaptation occurring
in the individual when he or she first joins the group, there is, in many cases, a more
fundamental, enforced change (my conceptualisation of the machine in the next section),
which I suggest is therefore not just adaptation. The pseudo-personality is much more than
adaptation. An adapting personality is not split into a Jenny and a Magdalene, for example
it maintains inner coherence while exhibiting external change. The pseudopersonality of
cult joiners, on the other hand, is changed centrally, rather than peripherally (Ofshe &
Singer, 1986), as in adaptation.
Dissociation
The idea that parts of a single personality can be divided, or dissociated, is not a new one.
Van der Hart, Nijenhuis, and Steele (2006) state, in relation to patients with PTSD and other
trauma-related disorders (p.28-29), that ―...dissociation is a division among ‗systems of
ideas and functions that constitute the personality,‘‖ that these parts are self-conscious, and
that each part involves its own separate sense of self.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM IV) states that ―The
essential feature of the Dissociative Disorders is a disruption in the usually integrated
functions of consciousness, memory, identity, or perception. The disturbance may be
sudden or gradual, transient or chronic.‖
The Dictionary of Psychology states that the term dissociation is
Used generally to characterize the process (or its result) whereby a
coordinated set of activities, thoughts, attitudes, or emotions becomes
separated from the rest of the person‘s personality and functions
independently. Mild forms are seen in compartmentalization ...more extreme
forms are observed in the dissociative disorders. (Reber &Reber, 2001)
Dissociation therefore occurs on a continuum, and we all dissociate to some degree (West &
Martin, 1994). At one end of the continuum, we may experience the sensation, for example,
of driving a familiar route and not recalling the journey. At the other end is complete
memory loss, and there is much in between. At the more serious end of the continuum, Van
der Hart et al. (2006) propose the following conceptualisation of dissociative disorders. The
simplest division of the personality in traumatised individuals is primary structural
dissociation, wherein there is a single split—one apparently normal part (ANP) and one
emotional part (EP) of the personality [see diagram 4 following], also sometimes referred to
as alter personalities (Putnam, 1989). Secondary structural dissociation, as a result of
prolonged and repeated traumatisation, has a wide range of complexity and involves one
ANP and a number of EPs. Tertiary structural dissociation is characteristic of Dissociative
Identity Disorder (DID), previously known as Multiple-Personality Disorder (MPD), in which
there are multiple ANP and EP parts of the personality.
Jenny/Magdalene‘s experience supports Langone‘s assertion that many members end up
―proclaim[ing] great happiness yet hide great suffering.‖ He states that this is a ―state of
dissociation in which members are ‗split‘ but not ‗multiple.‘‖ (1993, p. 9). They do not
exhibit an alter, as in structural dissociation.
Cultic Studies Review, Vol. 7, No. 3, 2008, Page 11
Hassan (2000) says, ―Cult mind control dissociates a person from his authentic identity, and
makes his new cult identity dependent on the group. From a mental-health perspective, cult
mind control splits elements of an individual‘s psyche into another distinct personality‖ (p.
55).
This raises the question: Is the cult-pseudo personality a dissociative phenomenon or even
DID? I agree with Langone that it is not DID (―multiple personality‖), and this view is
backed by West &Martin (1993, pp. 273-4). They note the following differences between
DID and the pseudo-personality: DID is more likely to be related to early childhood trauma
(also Van der Hart et al., 2006) DID patients may have more than one ―alter‖ or part and
DID is notoriously hard to treat.
West and Martin (1994, p. 274) also assert that the aims of therapy differ between DID and
pseudo-personality, further highlighting the differences. With DID, ―reconciliation and
integration of alters‖ is the aim, while with pseudo-personality, the aim is ―restoration of the
original identity.‖ They note that residual PTSD will usually need to be treated.
It is generally held that the split in primary, secondary, and tertiary structural dissociation is
a vertical split:
Given the terrible childhood abuse and trauma suffered by those born and raised in a cult
(Jones, Jones and Buhring, 2007), it is possible that DID and dissociative disorders resulting
from their cult upbringing may be present in this population. Because many members
recruited as adults suffer deep trauma within cults, there might also be dissociation that
forms as a result of the cult trauma. This trauma can include beatings sexual abuse
abusive and harsh encounter groups, and shouting and loud commands to change, to hate
one‘s parents, and to hate one‘s ―old self‖ or ―worldly self.‖ There might also be structural
dissociation present in individuals before they joined the cult. The cult will nevertheless
cause wounds in their life.
I envisage this split both horizontally and vertically:
Apparently normal part
(ANP)
Emotional part (EP)
Diagram 4: Illustration of primary structural
dissociation
Previous Page Next Page