Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 11, No. 1, 1994, Page 22
The first point is that “cosmic” self religiosity is well in evidence:
In management the priority is to know yourself. Only on the basis of self-knowledge
can you interfuse with the cosmic energy system--that is to say, God. God is not an
idea outside of you. He is part of our self-nature, part of our feeling.
The second point is that--at least in this spiritual ideology--the Self-orientation of BCCI
meshes in with a strong emphasis on the expressive ethic. Thus the passage just cited
continues,
When we feel that we can comprehend totality within us, that is the feeling of God.
As soon as you know that feeling, everything becomes simple.
In other words, as the following extract from Lessem (who is citing Abedi) makes explicit,
once managers are in touch with the Source within, good decisions naturally ensue:
Should we as corporate managers confine ourselves to empirical wisdom and its
application? Or should we attempt to reach beyond that through the process of
humility and interfusion of the streams of the energy psyche of individual human
beings with the main stream of the cosmic energy psyche? We may ask ourselves if
wisdom is merely human reason and perception confined within the prison of the
human ego, or is wisdom nature, its laws and its principles. We in BCC have
attempted to give precedence to nature. (Lessem, 1989, p. xvi)
God Running a Bank: New Age Expressivism in Practice
The “formal” corporate culture of BCCI, it is quite clear, was extraordinary. And according to
Lessem (Reader in International Management at the City University Business School), its
metaphysical principles “have turned BCC into a major, multinational bank, over the course of
fifteen years” (1989, p. vxi). Just prior to the collapse of the bank in mid-1991, it can be
observed, the institution was the fifth largest bank in the world, with assets of $20 billion, and
was operating in some 70 countries.
But we all know what has been revealed during the last year or so, prompting Private Eye to
describe the institution as “the Bank of Crooks, Cocaine and Impostors.” And so to an
interesting consideration: Could it be the case that self religiosity, in particular the role played
by the expressive ethic in decision making, has contributed to the demise of BCCI?
On a general note, it is difficult to see how the expressive ethic--placing trust in the wisdom
that lies within rather than in that which is encoded from without--can be relied upon in
private life let alone in business. Even in the ultimate sphere, intuition is by no means a
reliable guide in all eventualities. True, expressive ethic can work if there is a wise Self
dwelling within. But it is surely problematic to ground a personal relationship, let alone a
business empire, on such an act of faith.
Yet BCCI appears to have taken such an act of faith. We do not have many details of how
BCCI was run before its collapse, but observations from Lessem, Thomas Thiss (1986), and
my own informants indicate that those in charge attempted to transcend conventional ways of
running a business empire. At least in measure, traditional authority systems have been
rejected--supposedly to facilitate the revelation of natural wisdom, and allow it to have its
say.
Thus according to Thiss,
Because it [the bank] values spontaneity, trust, initiative, intuition, and feelings, it
minimizes structure to facilitate these qualities. There is very little formal planning,
scheduling, and budgeting in the conventional sense. Plans evolve and schedules
change with the continuous interaction of people. They call it “dynamic planning.”
Sometimes things just seem to happen. (1986, p. 272)
Cultic Studies Journal, Vol. 11, No. 1, 1994, Page 23
According to Lessem,
People ...are viewed as “beings in progress,” as self-directed sources of energy.
They have no fixed position in the organizational tree. Formal reporting chains are
non-existent. People belong, not by virtue of having a place in the formal structure,
but by relating to the process of the flow. (1989, p. 579)
And according to The Vital Principle,
In BCC there is no hierarchy of management flowing from top to bottom ...We
should not allow our minds or our feelings to be contained by the present situation.
The aim, then, has been to liberate the God-self from the authoritative impositions of
conventional business. “interfusing” with Ultimacy, managers are supposedly able to operate
(at least in measure) without relying on the normal props of commercial activity. After all, as
Lessem puts it, “The moral, which is equivalent to the laws and principles of nature, governs
all that is material” [emphasis mine](1989, p. 578).
What a way to run a bank! Thiss cites the example of an international officer, posted to Africa,
who “sensed” that it was right to open an agency office (regional management was informed
only after the event). The official then proceeded with more ambitious plans, this time being
criticized for not having “interfused beforehand” (1986, p. 277). But would such inner
“interfusion” really have made much difference? Surely the correct decision would have
involved attending to the “external” logistics of the situation.
A major problem with management by intuition, relying on the Source that lies within, is that
the way is paved for corruption. BCCI might have expected its managers to be honest to God,
but many, it is clear, succumbed to the temptations which surrounded them in their wealth-
creating environment. Precisely because of the (relative) absence of formal controls and
accountability systems, precisely because of the freedoms afforded by the use of “intuition,”
precisely because of the sums passing through BCCI, it has been only too easy for managers
to succumb to their “base,” that is utilitarian, drives.
I have argued elsewhere (1991, 1992) that self religiosity can function to benefit capitalist
enterprise. Accordingly, it is possible that the rapid expansion of BCCI has owed something to
the motivational consequences of this factor. However, with regard to the overall
consequences of New Age application within BCCI, the monistic path within has played a --if
not the --key role in bringing disaster. It explains why the bank may not have made a profit
after provision for many years, if ever it explains why there were so many opportunities for
certain managers to feather their own nests it explains why the New Age teaching of Abedi
and his close associates has resulted in something as far removed from the spirit of the
genuine” New Age as it is possible to imagine.
Looking to the future, it will be interesting to see how New Age commerce progresses in its
original homeland--India. In this country, HRD is increasingly being formulated in terms of
monistic potential. At a high profile conference (Madras, 1991), for example, talk was of
“Divine sources for human resource development.” One senior participant emphasized that no
one should forget “the divine source within us, and that God dwells within us.” It is perhaps
not without significance that Abedi continually looked to this nation while planning for the
future.
References
Baldick, J. (1989). Mystical Islam. London: I. B. Tauris.
Evans, R., &Russell, P. (1989). The creative manager. London: Unwin.
Previous Page Next Page