International Journal of Coercion, Abuse, and Manipulation Volume 8 2025 122
It seems, however, that many mental health therapists
are not knowledgeable about the psychological
issues related to spiritual abuse, religious trauma,
and cult dynamics and, therefore, are unsure how to
help survivors of such abuse. This lack of knowledge
and resultant treatment uncertainty may be partly
explained by what the authors of the 2024 scoping
review “Addressing Harm From Adverse Religious/
Spiritual Experiences in Psychotherapy” described as a
“dearth of research on psychotherapeutic intervention
for these concerns.”70
1
That review was “a synthesis of
the psychotherapy recommendations for addressing
harm from adverse religious/spiritual experiences that
have been published in the peer-reviewed and grey
literature.”71
While research is limited on effective therapeutic
interventions for survivors of religious/spiritual abuse,
the concepts of spiritual and religious trauma are not
new. In “The Spiritual Abuse and Harm Screener and
Its Revelations,”72 Araya Baker discussed two books
published in the 1990s on the subject: The Subtle
Power of Spiritual Abuse: Recognizing and Escaping
Spiritual Manipulation and False Spiritual Authority
Within the Church and Ronald Enroth’s Churches That
Abuse: Help for Those Hurt by Legalism, Authoritarian
Leadership, Manipulation, Excessive Discipline, and
Spiritual Intimidation. The authors of The Subtle Power
of Spiritual Abuse coined the term “spiritual abuse.” In
his book, Enroth examined five areas conducive to
religious abuse: “authority and power, manipulation
and control, elitism and persecution, lifestyle and
experience, [and] dissent and discipline.”73 These areas
of abuse are very familiar to former COG/The Family
members.
After discussing those books, Baker wrote:
70 Lauren M. Zaeske, et al, “Addressing harm from adverse religious/
spiritual experiences in psychotherapy: A scoping review,” Practice
Innovations, 9 no, 1 (2021), 2024. https://doi.org/10.1037/pri0000237
71 Lauren M. Zaeske, et al, “Addressing harm from adverse religious/
spiritual experiences in psychotherapy.”
72 Araya Baker, “The Spiritual Abuse and Harm Screener and Its
Revelations”, Beyond Cultural Competence (blog) Psychology Today, April
24, 2024, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/beyond-cultural-
competence/202302/the-spiritual-abuse-and-harm-screener-and-its-
revelations.
73 Ronald Enroth, Churches That Abuse: Help for Those Hurt by
Legalism, Authoritarian Leadership, Manipulation, Excessive Discipline, and
Spiritual Intimidation (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing
House, 1992).
Religion and spirituality are actually distinct
concepts. Yet not much difference exists in
terms of how leaders of organized institutions
and groups use both to gain power and control
over others.
Thus, both spiritual abuse and religious abuse
overlap significantly with adverse religious
experiences, which the Global Center for
Religious Research defines as, ‘an event,
series of events, relationships, or circumstances
within or connected to religious beliefs,
practices, or structures that are experienced
by an individual as overwhelming or
disruptive. These experiences have the potential
of resulting in religious trauma.’74
1
Keep in mind that many of the former members of
COG/The Family and other high-demand religions had
experienced “overwhelming disruptive” experiences
for years, if not decades.
In Leaving the Fold (2006), Marlene Winell, a religious
abuse survivor and psychologist, introduced and
conceptualized the Religious Trauma Syndrome
(RTS). Winell’s theory of RTS built upon previous
work about the process of religious and/or spiritual
abuse and offered a framework for understanding
the long-lasting and multifaceted impacts on one’s
nervous system. RTS is not an official diagnosis in
the DSM-5-TR, but she described the concept as “the
condition experienced by people who are struggling
with leaving an authoritarian, dogmatic religion and
coping with the damage of indoctrination. It can be
compared to a combination of PTSD and Complex
PTSD (C-PTSD).”75 Several years later, Winell
published a trilogy of essays in Cognitive Behavioural
Therapy Today, urging the counselling and psychology
professions to respect RTS as a legitimate form of
trauma and abuse that is religious and/or spiritual as a
serious form of abuse.76
While it may be challenging to ensure that all therapists
receive the necessary training to address the unique
74 Baker, “The Special Abuse and Harm Screener and Its Revelations.”
75 Marlene Winell, Leaving the Fold: A Guide for Former
Fundamentalists and Others Leaving Their Religion, (San Francisco:
Apocryphile Press, 2006).
76 Marlene Winell, “Religious Trauma Syndrome: It’s time to
recognise it.” CBT Today, 39, no. 3 (September 2011). https://www.
journeyfree.org/religious-trauma-syndrome-articles/
ISSN: 2710-4028 DOI: https://doi.org/10.54208/0008 123
issues faced by survivors of religious or spiritual abuse,
many psychologists and therapists are likely acquainted
with family dynamics, domestic abuse, and coercive
control in contexts that are not specifically religious
or spiritual. Consequently, considering the scarcity of
therapists well-versed in religious or spiritual trauma,
I propose that the therapeutic strategies used in
domestic abuse cases not linked to religion could also
be effectively applied to situations where spirituality or
religious dogma serves as the primary catalyst for the
abuses experienced by their clients.
A fundamental metaphor associated with mystical
marriage illustrates the relationship between Christian
believers and God as that of a parent and children:
“Our Father which art in heaven.”77
1
The bond among
a community of believers is often viewed as familial:
“For this cause I bow my knees unto the Father of
our Lord Jesus Christ, Of whom the whole family
in heaven and earth is named.”78 These metaphors
explain why many Christian cults and other religious
organizations (including the Children of God/The
Family) incorporate the word “family” in their names.
Given David Berg’s perversion of biblical bridal
theology and Karen Zerby’s extension of his diabolical
doctrines, most of the abuses experienced by those
who were part of the Children of God were forms of
domestic abuse. In the final chapter of my memoir, I
write: “I found it helpful to understand my experiences
in the Family as a spiritual variation of long-term
domestic abuse causing battered wife syndrome,
a subcategory of PTSD. After all, I had been a bride
of Christ according to the Family’s version of bridal
theology.”79
The correlation between religious or spiritual beliefs
and domestic abuse is not limited to extreme groups
like The Family it also extends to many Christian
denominations, churches, sects, and organizations,
even those with conventional interpretations of bridal
theology. Another example of a notorious doomsday
cult leader with an extreme interpretation of bridal
theology that broke up families is William Costellia
Kamm, who also had an international following.
“Kamm was married and had four children but
77 Mt 6:9 (KJV).
78 Eph 3:14 (KJV).
79 Bulwar, Misguided.
unknown to his wife, this self-proclaimed Messiah
was planning on creating a royal harem, filled with 12
queens and 72 princesses—84 mystical spouses to bear
his children to repopulate the earth.”80
1
The authors of a 2023 study that “aim[ed] to comprehend
the underlying dynamics influencing domestic violence
stated, “[R]eligion and spiritual beliefs have been
found to play a significant role in domestic violence
dynamics. Certain religious interpretations and
teachings can contribute to the acceptance of violence,
particularly against women, as a form of submission
or obedience.”81 This insight was certainly applicable
in the Children of God, whose founder manipulated
the “bride of Christ” imagery to justify extensive abuse
against women and children. Viewing religious trauma
from the perspective of domestic abuse provides an
understanding of the intimate, coercive aspects of
religious or spiritual abuse and why leaving abusive
religious groups can be as challenging as exiting an
abusive marriage or family. I conclude that recognizing
religious trauma related to Christian dogma as a
form of domestic abuse, regardless of denomination,
church, sect, or organization, is a helpful concept
for survivors recovering from such abuse, therapists
assisting them, and academics studying the subject.
Non-Christian religions likely also generate deviant
practices and perversions that harm their followers, as
occurred with members of the Children of God/The
Family. Although the scriptural foundations may differ,
the negative consequences are often very similar, if not
identical.
80 Tara Brown “What life was really like inside the doomsday cult
run by the paedophile known as ‘Little Pebble’”, 60 Minutes Australia. 2023,
https://9now.nine.com.au/60-minutes/what-life-was-really-like-inside-the-
doomsday-cult-run-by-the-paedophile-known-as-little-pebble/54ff2eee-
c0b3-4ca1-8c70-6fcc04ff0a2c
81 Cintya Lanchimba, Juan Pablo Díaz-Sanchez, and Franklin
Velasco, “Exploring factors influencing domestic violence: A comprehensive
study on intrafamily dynamics.” Frontiers In Psychiatry vol. 14, September
6, 2023, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychiatry/articles/10.3389/
fpsyt.2023.1243558/full.
Previous Page Next Page